A greater punishment

I thought of this as im a clan leader and after reading a few threads in this forums.

How about a greater punishment for players who leaves clan during a war or hopping between clans asking for troops and causing inappropriate trouble?

Instead of holding them captives like what some clashers has suggested in previous threads,supercell could implement this features.

Examples:

[For clan hoppers]
*Suspended from joining another clan for 12hrs

[For War Quitters]
* Suspended from joining another clan for 24hrs or more depending how many times he has done it.

I hope this feature could be implemented so that the amount of clan hoppers in Clash Of Clans will reduced.

If anyone has any opinions and contructive criticism,please share !

Greatly appreciated

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DiabloPhoenix

I thought of this as im a clan leader and after reading a few threads in this forums.

How about a greater punishment for players who leaves clan during a war or hopping between clans asking for troops and causing inappropriate trouble?

Instead of holding them captives like what some clashers has suggested in previous threads,supercell could implement this features.

Examples:

[For clan hoppers]
*Suspended from joining another clan for 12hrs

[For War Quitters]
* Suspended from joining another clan for 24hrs or more depending how many times he has done it.

I hope this feature could be implemented so that the amount of clan hoppers in Clash Of Clans will reduced.

If anyone has any opinions and contructive criticism,please share !

Greatly appreciated

---

I don't agree with having punishments for clan hoppers or war quitters.

If you don't want clan hoppers, close your clan or make it invite only.
Clan hopping punishment would kill the Request & leave clans.

As for war quitter, don't let new comers war with you.
You have to wait and test the new member.

It's really about clan management.
If you manage your clan better, you will suffer less from hoppers and quitter.

not only for the above reasons but you will also kill off request and Go Clans.

Or remember the first time you tried to find a good clan that was right for you... how many attempts / hops did that take...

In the game you have bad clans as well as bad players.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mido2malik

I don't agree with having punishments for clan hoppers or war quitters.

If you don't want clan hoppers, close your clan or make it invite only.
Clan hopping punishment would kill the Request & leave clans.

As for war quitter, don't let new comers war with you.
You have to wait and test the new member.

It's really about clan management.
If you manage your clan better, you will suffer less from hoppers and quitter.

---

Alright thanks for reminding me about those request and go clan tho...Cant disagree with you..Thanks for your opinion👍 Clash On!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ironagedave

not only for the above reasons but you will also kill off request and Go Clans.

Or remember the first time you tried to find a good clan that was right for you... how many attempts / hops did that take...

In the game you have bad clans as well as bad players.

---

Cant disagree with you tho..Thanks for your reply :) But maybe when an update for request and leave clan is released...this idea might work ^^

:thumbsdown:
I think we don't need punishment!

Ask your friends to join in your clan;)

There are hoppers that want to get rid of troops or simp,y dont have a main clan. There is nothing wrong with that. Clan hopping is only a problem of new clans with low members coming for troops and leaving.

In my clan the biggest danger of new players is that they suck at war and I dont know how to make a rule to prevent that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DiabloPhoenix

I thought of this as im a clan leader and after reading a few threads in this forums.

How about a greater punishment for players who leaves clan during a war or hopping between clans asking for troops and causing inappropriate trouble?

Instead of holding them captives like what some clashers has suggested in previous threads,supercell could implement this features.

Examples:

[For clan hoppers]
*Suspended from joining another clan for 12hrs

[For War Quitters]
* Suspended from joining another clan for 24hrs or more depending how many times he has done it.

I hope this feature could be implemented so that the amount of clan hoppers in Clash Of Clans will reduced.

If anyone has any opinions and contructive criticism,please share !

Greatly appreciated

---

I am getting really tired of people posting this stupid thing, WE already went over this a billion times, stop asking for punishment!!!

Clan hoppers just play the game differently than you do. Whats wrong with that? Don't put them in war and they will leave. Then don't let them back in. See? Easy.

Glad we got this thread settled. Moving on....

Been discussed, not needed, get better clan-mates and move on..

Ehhhh, I don't really like the idea. It seems unneeded. Just close your clan in the time your at war.

Stricter rules about who participates in our wars has resulted in no one leaving during war in our clan.