3 star to 5 star solution : TH sniping, Outside TH - Some loss to supercell.
I have read about many members saying that SC gives free shield for the base who keep TH outside (I keep my TH outside and get free shield saving from big attack and someone taking my resources). Also many player just take the outside TH and get the bonus loot (Of course bonus is higher on higher league) or push the trophy easily. If SC wants COC to be more fun and competitive and fair then just go through my proposed solution.
Note :- I don't know if this has been already proposed, if so than just ignore this.
Solution : Change 3 star for 100% attack winning to 5 star for 100% attack winning.
1)How it works : 1 star for 25% damage, 1 star for 50% damage, 1 star for 75% damage, 1 Star for 100% damage and 1 star for TH.
2)Attackers wins only if he gets 2 star out of 5 (If SC wants, they can make it 3 star to win but it will be hard then)
3)This will also work in clan wars and makes game more fun and competitive. specially for 5vs5 or 10vs10.
4)How this is going to help SC : getting outside TH is easy but it will be difficult to get 25% damage if defense is stronger than attackers troops. In this way attacker has to take more troops for additional 25% (1 star for TH and 1 star for 25%) this makes him to make more troops and use gems to boost barracks if he wants to quick trophy pushing.
5) As if only TH is damaged and 1 star out of 5 then defender will not get the shield. If someone really want the shield then only keeping TH outside will not guarantee it so he has to use gems to get shield.
This is just came in to my mind and thought it will be helpful, there may be some disadvantage which i do not see at this time, in fact there may be more advantage of this.
What you guys say...!
P.S. - Star in the WAR hero achievement might need some modification (Totally depends on SC).