I cant find where its broken?
Having played this game for over a year and I have 2 accounts farming league bonus in champs/masters I can tell you its not broken. People might want it changed and thats fine. I will adapt and overcome. What I see of the op is he attacks so infrequent because it takes time for a gowipe to be built. He gets attacked after each of his attacks.
Me? I barch and focus on 50% 1*. While my army is rebuilding I snipe and usually find at least 1 in the 20 min. 3 barch attacks takes 40 min plus a few snipes and im at a net positive for the attack against me. Cause im done for the day. Sometimes repeat again later.
I do keep my th outside so it often just a snipe.
Not every attack it for 1 trophy.
Again the system isnt broken or flawed you just want the rules changed.
Careful what you wish for. A change to make an advantage for you makes an advantage for everyone. Those that do the advantage more get more. Those that dont complain its unfair and want the rules changed again.
Good luck.