Gain Clan XP in other ways

Printable View

October 13th, 2015
Hyper54

Gain Clan XP in other ways

The clan XP was a great idea and got lots of clans to take clan wars more seriously. However, I wish there were other ways to gain clan XP. For example maybe a certain amount of total donations every week cumulative for the whole clan, amount of town halls destroyed as a clan in a days/week/months time, dark elixir looted as a clan, etc.
October 13th, 2015
awesomness2016

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyper54

The clan XP was a great idea and got lots of clans to take clan wars more seriously. However, I wish there were other ways to gain clan XP. For example maybe a certain amount of total donations every week cumulative for the whole clan, amount of town halls destroyed as a clan in a days/week/months time, dark elixir looted as a clan, etc.

No, no, no and no....you already get benefits from those things, you don't need XP on top of it.

The only thing I think that should be added is XP for total # of trophies/points as a clan. Sort of like an achievement...200XP for breaking 20000, 500 XP for 25000, 1000XP for 30000, something like that.

This would encourage more than just the very top clans to do trophy pushes as a clan.
October 13th, 2015
Manyolo

Clan xp is acquired this way to make clan wars worth it. Clans were losing interest and when this came things totally changed. Take that away and clan wars will die.
October 13th, 2015
Radiating

The idea of clan XP is to promote clan wars. By implementing any other way, all value of CWs is lost.
October 13th, 2015
Hyper54

Just to be clear I mean in addition to the current XP received from wars, not instead of.
October 13th, 2015
Manyolo

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyper54

Just to be clear I mean in addition to the current XP received from wars, not instead of.

Farming is much easier, faster, cheaper than doing clan wars, not to mention that farming and donating is a daily routine. I believe that this will make lots of clans to quit clan wars.
October 13th, 2015
itmustbeaustin

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyper54

The clan XP was a great idea and got lots of clans to take clan wars more seriously. However, I wish there were other ways to gain clan XP. For example maybe a certain amount of total donations every week cumulative for the whole clan, amount of town halls destroyed as a clan in a days/week/months time, dark elixir looted as a clan, etc.

I think this would be a nice thing, but it would have to be limited, it seems to me you already think it should be limited by suggesting somewhere between weekly and monthly.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Manyolo

Farming is much easier, faster, cheaper than doing clan wars, not to mention that farming and donating is a daily routine. I believe that this will make lots of clans to quit clan wars.

You realize if you can get something like 50-150 clan xp weekly, it would make NO difference to clan who war for XP, you would still make mountains more XP for warring then for some small weekly XP gains, not a single war clan would stop warring because of something like that.
October 13th, 2015
Andymajor

Clan wars xp

The way it is set is the best. Clan xp is only gained trough wars and war alone as it was brought in to bring more players to war. It would b nice to c it but it would not benifit the game play. Sorry but my vote would b leave it the way it is.
October 13th, 2015
Manyolo

Quote:

Originally Posted by itmustbeaustin

I think this would be a nice thing, but it would have to be limited, it seems to me you already think it should be limited by suggesting somewhere between weekly and monthly.

You realize if you can get something like 50-150 clan xp weekly, it would make NO difference to clan who war for XP, you would still make mountains more XP for warring then for some small weekly XP gains, not a single war clan would stop warring because of something like that.

Ok, lets say you are right, how are they going to calculate the xp awarded per resource, donation and limit it to be weekly or even monthly?
October 14th, 2015
itmustbeaustin

Quote:

Originally Posted by Manyolo

Ok, lets say you are right, how are they going to calculate the xp awarded per resource, donation and limit it to be weekly or even monthly?

Exactly how trophy seasons work, let's say you can get a most of 200 clan xp every two weeks, you have four categories (something like total donations, total winning raids, total resources won in raids, and wars declared) You set it at three levels, the first gets you 15xp, the second gets you 30xp, the third gets you 50xp.

Example: If you declare 2 clan wars in the two week period you reach the first level for 15xp, 4 wars for the second level for 30xp, or 6 wars for level 3 and 50xp.

I wouldn't even begin to know what you would have to make the numbers to get level 1, 2, or 3 for other things such as donations made or attacks won...
October 14th, 2015
Pympin

Quote:

Originally Posted by itmustbeaustin

Exactly how trophy seasons work, let's say you can get a most of 200 clan xp every two weeks, you have four categories (something like total donations, total winning raids, total resources won in raids, and wars declared) You set it at three levels, the first gets you 15xp, the second gets you 30xp, the third gets you 50xp.

Example: If you declare 2 clan wars in the two week period you reach the first level for 15xp, 4 wars for the second level for 30xp, or 6 wars for level 3 and 50xp.

I wouldn't even begin to know what you would have to make the numbers to get level 1, 2, or 3 for other things such as donations made or attacks won...

I would have to agree with everyone else. Leave it alone. If this was implemented then SC would have to make the level break higher to balance it out or there would be 1000 lvl 10 clans in three months. I can already see you say add more levels. OK so let's play make believe and say they add ten more levels. 2 of these levels have add +X to level donation. Well how can you add X to a max troop when most of the clans that would be this level will have max troops. The plus two is already not going to help the first few clans that get to lvl 10. So again my vote is to leave it alone
October 14th, 2015
charizzle

I wouldn't mind seeing a way to earn a small amount of perk XP doing non war stuff. It makes it so people who don't like to war can enjoy the perks, or people who just suck don't have to be discouraged by going at a snail's pace. And those who are good anyway and already earn xp fast can earn it even faster if they take the time to do additional stuff.

It would have to be a small amount though. The main source of clan xp should obviously be wars. But there are a lot of perks that are attractive to non-war people too, and it isn't fair imo to force them into a playstyle in order to enjoy those perks.
October 14th, 2015
Manyolo

Quote:

Originally Posted by itmustbeaustin

Exactly how trophy seasons work, let's say you can get a most of 200 clan xp every two weeks, you have four categories (something like total donations, total winning raids, total resources won in raids, and wars declared) You set it at three levels, the first gets you 15xp, the second gets you 30xp, the third gets you 50xp.

Example: If you declare 2 clan wars in the two week period you reach the first level for 15xp, 4 wars for the second level for 30xp, or 6 wars for level 3 and 50xp.

I wouldn't even begin to know what you would have to make the numbers to get level 1, 2, or 3 for other things such as donations made or attacks won...

So what you want is something like resetable achievements every two weeks or so that reward you with clan xp? Well if thats the case this clan be added when and IF the daily/weekly/monthly quests will be implemented. I cant see this happening earlier.