The surrender button in the clan war

Hi Supercell,I had one idea,in the clan war it might be one red button with written "Surrender".How many times has happened to know that the war is lost for lack attacks. With this idea would save time and then restart immediately a new war. Obviously only the leader can stop war and then to lost the war,The victorious clan can continue to attack for loot or to score more stars and it can stop the war when it want.there will be 'a limit of how many times one can surrender, This is a crude idea Need to work on...,
Sorry for any error but I am not english ;)

No offense but this should never happen. To many clans would cancel war before it ever started (if they where the underdogs) and it would be really annoying to cut it short. For ex my clan just war practices if we get crushed. And no one would try and make a comeback (no more awesome comebacks when ur getting crushed :(). It would be hard to control. Supercell will most likely not add it.

I kinda agree to this, but I'm pretty sure SC won't add it. It would just let some clans have too much clan XP due to attacking then immediately surrendering.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IcewolfBlizzard

I kinda agree to this, but I'm pretty sure SC won't add it. It would just let some clans have too much clan XP due to attacking then immediately surrendering.

---

Or cancel until easy war.

If the clan is losing in war and they don't want to lose, they can just surrender. People would use this to much and they would surrender until they found an easy match. Since most likely every clan would be doing thisit wouldn't be likely the war would last past preparation day.

This will cause too many conflicts.

"Why did we surrender???, I needed those extra stars for my achievements!!!,"
"My little brother borrowed my pad and accidentally clicked the surrender button!"
and so on.....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Awness

This will cause too many conflicts.

"Why did we surrender???, I needed those extra stars for my achievements!!!,"
"My little brother borrowed my pad and accidentally clicked the surrender button!"
and so on.....

---

This is a your problem

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IcewolfBlizzard

I kinda agree to this, but I'm pretty sure SC won't add it. It would just let some clans have too much clan XP due to attacking then immediately surrendering.

---

We should invent an idea for the players not to abuse ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Awness

This will cause too many conflicts.

"Why did we surrender???, I needed those extra stars for my achievements!!!,"
"My little brother borrowed my pad and accidentally clicked the surrender button!"
and so on.....

---

it will be a message whit written ''Write confirmation to confirm the surrender'' whit this confirm your little brother will not make your clan lose[/QUOTE]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Alessioquattro

it will be a message whit written ''Write confirmation to confirm the surrender'' whit this confirm your little brother will not make your clan lose

---

[/QUOTE]

Those were just a few problems I saw.

Another: With all the "mismatches" going on in wars, weak clans will most likely surrender immediately even without attacking, giving the opposing team an EASY victory and EASY loot. Now, imagine that happening 10, 20 times. They'll definitely max their base in no time at all and your clan will not progress as fast.

This has been suggested many times. As the OP seems to hint, the only way it really works is if both clans agree...meaning the war is not over until the clan being surrendered to ACCEPTS the surrender, so even if you want to surrender chances are a lot of the wars will still go the full length or close to it, because the clan that is winning is going to want to let its members continue to attack to maximize xp and loot bonuses.

I still doubt we'll see it, but another thing they could do is only make surrender available in the last 12 or 8 hours of battle day.

war should only be surrendered after the 12 hour mark, or after the other base has 75% of possible stars or something

and if surrendered , the loasing class should not get loot, and should have a 12 hour cool down

also, you can only surrender ever 3 wars (once a week for 24/7 war clan)

most likely it will get exploited with arranged wars to get xp fast

HOW!!!! you would have to be so lucky to know the opponent you are facing...

I agree with the above people who suggest that time should be scaled with TH level. 3:10 at TH8, 3:20 at TH 9 and 3:30 at TH 10.

Edit: Sorry, I posted on the wrong thread :facepalm: silly me.

I would be OK with a surrender option if there is a 48 hour cooldown for starting a new war for the initiating clan AND both clans had to agree. I would probably never agree to a surrender, if we get an easy war, we certainly don't mind crushing you. And hard wars are simply seen as a challenge. Do we lose hard wars? Sure, but I would rather go down fighting than give up like a whiney little girl.

Where is the competitive spirit in that?