Donations idea

Printable View

October 9th, 2015
AlexStyylin1

Donations idea

I know it's been a pretty big problem in my clan recently, and I'm sure it's not just mine. The problem has been people donating things like goblins when level 6 balloons are what was requested. This happened to me five times just today, and I haven't been able to see who has been doing it. Donations have always been something the clan requires members to keep at least half as high as their requested troops. I received 40 unwanted troops just today. When I finally got the troops I needed, my donations were way off.

I talked to my clan about our problem and we came up with a pretty solid fix. Our idea is to have a feature within the clan chat, like the changing clan settings feature, that would display a chat message when someone donates with what they donated and to whom. This would completely eliminate the problem. My clan would be able to see who was donating even when we weren't on to see it happen. We would then be able to kick the members that are donating unwanted troops.
October 10th, 2015
LemoneyFresh937

Imagine a big box of ruled out ideas. Now envision your idea inside of it. Congratulations! Your imagination has manifested itself into reality.
October 10th, 2015
andrewchang

It isn't actually ruled out, but I don't necessarily support it. Then again, they add the name in the donation text that pops up, so maybe. The only problem I see is how they would put the donation messages together. If it was by person, then there would be issues if several people donated at the same time, and there would be 20 messages. If the messages appeared only after the CC is full, they might not appear at all.
October 10th, 2015
AlexStyylin1

Quote:

Originally Posted by andrewchang

If it was by person, then there would be issues if several people donated at the same time, and there would be 20 messages.

You make a good point. I see how this would be a problem. If anyone has revision ideas that could help this work out, I would still like to see something similar. Like perhaps having the messages not in the chat but in the clan castle and listed under the troop inside would be a name. Or even the messages we already have would show up when we get back on rather than only showing up when we are on.
October 10th, 2015
AlexStyylin1

Quote:

Originally Posted by LemoneyFresh937

Imagine a big box of ruled out ideas. Now envision your idea inside of it. Congratulations! Your imagination has manifested itself into reality.

I found one guy who's been donating unwanted troops. ^
October 10th, 2015
andrewchang

Quote:

Originally Posted by AlexStyylin1

You make a good point. I see how this would be a problem. If anyone has revision ideas that could help this work out, I would still like to see something similar. Like perhaps having the messages not in the chat but in the clan castle and listed under the troop inside would be a name. Or even the messages we already have would show up when we get back on rather than only showing up when we are on.

Indeed, the bottom sounds like a reasonable fix, although a timer before the messages were displayed, like perhaps 10 seconds after it reaches each 10 troop mark, would help.