Idea for those who leave clan during war

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hamidal

for issue you mention you simply set your war status to off early during first war, then leader will not include you for next one, if he do then the blocking rule will not apply to you during next war, that's it

---

So the option of leaving would be connected to the color of your warstatus at the moment of looking for war?
That would be a solution to the problem, but will it be easy to implement somthing like that? The leaving button would only be available when meeting certain requirements. Don't get me wrong, i support this feature ;) just don't want players to be held hostage.

Any means of stopping someone from leaving the clan amounts to be held prisoner, and I am confident in saying that SC will never allow this to be implemented into game.

What do you hope to achieve to by locking someone in the clan, you still can't make them do their war attacks. Or if they can only leave after completing both their attacks then they just throw a few archers down and end battle; then exit the clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hamidal

Its hard issue to solve, by in game control the members can still find way to workaround, by hopes on management efficiency we know all thats not realistic for most of clan, except those old and very mature clans with.

but we still can do something to reduce the frenquency of the issue, i think just blocking player from leaving during war (if he opted in as some suggested) may reduce the the issue impact because most of those who leave dont do it to irritate you but only they are hoppers and keep looking for better clan so if they are forced to stay they may join and attack

---

It's actually not a hard issue to solve at all...you simply don't include new members in war until they've sat out at least one and/or you've chatted with them and are confident they will use their attacks and do their best. Do this, or join a clan that does this, and players not showing for/leaving in the middle of war without attacking will be a rare occurrence.

Also, players who leave in the middle are already punished...they can't war until your war is over, and they miss out on the chance for a big loot bonus.

A simple fix for this problem would be to have the new player stay in the clan for a week or so before putting him in war. Done, problem solved.

If I got locked into a clan by something (this or some other feature) I know exactly how I would get out.

I would be so offensive and disruptive that they would want me gone and I would get kicked.
Donating wallbreakers and goblins, spamming chat, deliberately failing war raids...

The goal for a clan should be that people want to be in it.
If it's so bad that people want to leave a war perhaps we need to look at that instead...

A problem such as this mostly results from the decisions of the leaders alone. Deciding to enlist new members of the Clan into war is the only problem. Get to know the people you recruit to the Clan first and learn if you can trust people before adding them in war, or you'll end up with a potential loss due to that new member's choice of departure.