Clan perk 10 useless?

Ok, now maybe your thinking, what? No. But, yes, if you think about it, if your are th7 now and join an lvl 4-5 clan, by the time that clan reached perk 10, you will be at lest th8, maybe 9.

Also, with clan perk ten unlocked, getting players who already have high level donation troops shouldn't be an issue. People would flock to your clan.

With this in mind, at th9 perk 5 allows a th8 to donate most common max troops, and allow a th9 to donate nearly all max troops, besides pekka, which is an entirely different discussion, as lvl 4 pekkas are really needed on th9.

Yes I know that no one has even reached perk 10.

This post is to say, I believe perk 10 should be changed. What to?, I only have one idea, which is war losses give significantly more loot, but feel free to post your own ideas.

Clash on, guys

I agree, the level 10 clan perk isn't the best, but it always TH8s to donate maxed gibarch, near max golems, max pekka, max drags, ect.

But if you're a TH9-TH10 it's next to useless.

Well, it's useless to those who have 50 TH9+ players in their clan and don't have any real progress oppertunities on that subject. For clans in the middle-small range, this perk will give the possibility to open their doors to smaller players that will be able to contribute on hight troop level nevertheless.

But yes, if you have a solid pre-set 50 member clan, and walk this path to perk 10 with those people without opening your doors to smaller player you won't have any real benefit from that perk.

However, if your clan decides to open new branches or ''feeder clans'' ot would be a wise choise to place those new people in the perk 10 clan, and move your larger players to a new one. It will benefit the smaller players more after all, and could be a very valueble asset if they could start every CW with a +2 lvl bonus on all donations.

My clan for exaple variates between 20 and 30 members, and we do that on purpise as we have very strict donation requirements for all members. So smaller players almost have no real donation oppertunities as their troops are not strong enough and do not match the requested troop level. This perk on the other hand will give the smaller players the oppertunity to participate and perhaps donate more valueble troops than most top leveld players in the clan.

As for what i would like to see in the lvl 10 perk:
- Increased CW loot bonusses perhaps
- Another decreased CC request time
- Maybe more refund on donated troops
- Dunno, its hard to find ''fair'' perks besides the ones they've already got.