3 Star Clan War Loot Exploit Fix for Oct 2015

Hello clash team,

I have been a clasher and managed a clan for over a year now and here is a problem that's every clan's nightmare and spoils the war. Due to only needing to 1 star a war base to get max loot, players immediately attack the highest bases and no one wants to attack the lower bases. This greed for loot causes so many problems in clans and makes the team lose the war.

SOLUTION --> divide the war loot value for that defeated war base.

Example...

1 star = 33.3% of total war base loot value.
2 star = 66.6% of total war base loot value.
3 star = 100% of total war base loot value.

This would really change things around in clan wars and penalize players for exploiting the 1 star loot on war base so clan leaders, co leaders and elders dont have to kick players for not caring about their team and just looting instead of going for max stars. This will force players to attack responsibly bottom up instead of top down the war list.

Thank you so much for your time and hope someone listens and resolve this greed problem that we are facing in clans.

Players should earn their loot based on how many stars they get, not exploit 1 star to get all.

joeyz
computer scientist

No one ever attacks for loot in my clan. They would get kicked, no questions asked, no ... given. Start kicking people, right now, do not wait, do not pass go.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by herranton

No one ever attacks for loot in my clan. They would get kicked, no questions asked, no ... given. Start kicking people, right now, do not wait, do not pass go.

---

Ditto.Lol,you said everything I had to say.

Getting a star is technically winning. This can never happen...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Humdan

Getting a star is technically winning. This can never happen...it's like saying give 1/3 of the trophy offer for only getting 1 star on a base...

---

You know you do get only 1/3 of the trophy offer if you only one star

Must be a problem with your clan specifically and some others who aren't very war orientated if it's happening on such a mass level.

Im part of an 11-clan family and this issue does not exist in any of those clans, nor any clans I had been part of previously. There were clear rules in place, and a level of respect and team commitment from all onboard, we didn't need to speak to people about this issue cause it didn't really happen.

So the solution is not to amend the loot available for a star, because there is nothing wrong with the existing system, it's lack of discipline, and a lack of rules that causes this.

If the rules weren't followed in one of our clans a very very rare case then, warm them, opt them out or kick them if they just don't get it and become dead weight.

If it's happening on a mass scale in your clan or any other clan then it's simply one of three scenarios, either the clan is not very war focussed and are happy to war only for loot, I know some farming clans war only for this reason, or you are war orientated and there are no rules in place, or have rules in place and no one is bothering to follow them.

If you guys are genuinely committed to being the best you can be in war then I would suggest putting together something formal together with a list of rules, clan email or whatever and make sure people follow them. If they don't, then drop them as it will cost you wars.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ZachTyler

You know you do get only 1/3 of the trophy offer if you only one star

---

Wrote it without thinking... (facepalm) - was meant to write - "it's like saying if the town hall is sniped in multiplayer give 1/3 of the loot bonus"

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ZachTyler

You know you do get only 1/3 of the trophy offer if you only one star

---

:facepalm::facepalm:;)

Yeah exactly

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bench130

:facepalm::facepalm:;)

Yeah exactly

---

Wrote it without thinking... (facepalm) - was meant to write - "it's like saying if the town hall is sniped in multiplayer give 1/3 of the loot bonus"

(got to cover my tracks for being an idiot now haha!)

this is your issue . first of all why you will let newb clashers to go on war ? becuz people who are new play in clash just thinks loot is important not to win war. think youre self iknow you have a solution on youre own problem

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Humdan

Wrote it without thinking... (facepalm) - was meant to write - "it's like saying if the town hall is sniped in multiplayer give 1/3 of the loot bonus"

---

Not refering to muliplayer, just in clan wars. Clan wars is won by stars, not loot. Loot is awarded for the achievement and should measured by level of star achievement not the base (1 star win all loot).

The problem with this is, if nobody is 3 starring the other bases, you guys won't get the win, therefore you don't get the loot lol its common sense really: First attack, hit a base you can 3 star for sure. If everyone does that, guess what? You've already won! And those 2nd attacks can be used for loot/snipe. You dig?