Balancing clan wars

I think when searching for enemy clan the search should be based off of clan trophies, level, but also clan total stars. The clan total stars I think would be a great balance.

Problems i can see:
If one team has very few stars but a lot of wins it will be matched up against some one with very few wins and little stars. [fixed] in this case balance it with wins as well. (don't match up with wins all the time though because wins and stars are 2 very different things.)

Some people are opted out so would they count?[fixed] only people opted in or the people in the war at that time would be averaged.


Any other problems you see please post.

No not on clan stars, So if a BIG Cup clan suddenly decides to war for first time they get matched with noobs :)

No

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by casper1988

No not on clan stars, So if a BIG Cup clan suddenly decides to war for first time they get matched with noobs :)

No

---

No I'm not saying match with just stars I'm saying include stars to the match making, so that would involve: stars, trophies, wins, levels, and what ever they use to match up. I'm just saying include stars.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Reelzerz

I think when searching for enemy clan the search should be based off of clan trophies, level, but also clan total stars. The clan total stars I think would be a great balance.

Problems i can see:
If one team has very few stars but a lot of wins it will be matched up against some one with very few wins and little stars. [fixed] in this case balance it with wins as well. (don't match up with wins all the time though because wins and stars are 2 very different things.)

Some people are opted out so would they count?[fixed] only people opted in or the people in the war at that time would be averaged.


Any other problems you see please post.

---

trophies - drop to 200, start war, easy match
level - dont donate ever, easy match
total stars - unfair, people can just practice by pushing

with this dumb idea you would see town hall 7 clans against town hall 10s

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ayuntamiento

trophies - drop to 200, start war, easy match
level - dont donate ever, easy match
total stars - unfair, people can just practice by pushing

with this dumb idea you would see town hall 7 clans against town hall 10s

---

All You ever do is write hate replies so how about you explain without a hate reply and I might listen. Oh yea and also if your going to do a hate reply make sure you use better arguments then trying to hate like an autistic 8 year old.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Reelzerz

All You ever do is write hate replies so how about you explain without a hate reply and I might listen. Oh yea and also if your going to do a hate reply make sure you use better arguments then trying to hate like an autistic 8 year old.

---

Except he's right...it would be too easy to manipulate your matchups if level or trophies were included...not to mention that some clans have a hard enough time already finding an opponent, and the game doesn't and shouldn't take your skill level into account.

current system is fine for me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by awesomness2016

Except he's right...it would be too easy to manipulate your matchups if level or trophies were included...not to mention that some clans have a hard enough time already finding an opponent, and the game doesn't and shouldn't take your skill level into account.

---

Oh ok, well thank you for replying maturely and respectfully.