Printable View
Just now I clicked on every single revenge button in my war log, every one of them said : 'Can't attack, village owner is online/Village has active shield blah blah blah...), very frustrating to spend so much time for nothing, they should grey out the revenge button if owner has shield/online. What do you guys think??
Wait, how long did it take you to click allmof those buttons? Two and a half seconds? I think the revenge feature is kinda messed up, but would not use that a a reason...
I agree. They should make a grey or red revenge button
I feel more inclined to suggest removing revenge from the game. Can't say it's ever been a meaningful aspect for me.
I agree that the revenge should improve, and I like this idea.
However it is unfortunately ruled out.
Graphical Interface Related:
*Separate tab in chat for troop requests
*Revenge list indicate online/shielded or currently attackable without having to click each person’s button
*Ability to hide certain attacks in battle logs
*Show loot/trophies which were available on battle logs in addition to what was earned
*When revenge used – defense log includes original attack results (resources/trophies/%/stars)
*Modify Att/Def Won stat to include losses as well, example: Attacks: 38/12 Defenses: 3/12
*Add comma or space at thousands space in ALL places: Upgrade buttons, spell/troop buttons, shop, etc.
*Add a counter when all builders are busy to indicate when first one will be free
*Allow iOS Device battery indicator icon to be displayed while in-game
*Upgrade menu listing all things upgradable
*Ability to turn on white buffer lines without moving building/decoration
*Add a League Chat area
*Ability to hide traps/bombs (perhaps Tesla) in edit mode to give an "attacker's view"
Read the sticky:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines
I have also been frustrated with no opportunity to revenge. I love the idea of revenge, but this is what happens. A person attacks my base (Currently at 3856 cups) and typically wins with 1 or 2 stars. When I scout their base, they nearly always have their Town Hall's outside waiting for a higher level player to hit them for a cheap snipe. I know this happens because that's what I do when I push for cups.
What would be a better, more competitive option, is to actually allow for a revenge. Here is my idea:
From the Defense log, a player is allowed a Special Revenge option on any (one) person from the log. When that person logs off to defend, a push notification will go out to the player claiming a "special revenge" giving them up to 5 minutes to perform an attack before that base is released to the masses. Since it is "Special" you can only perform one of these revenges per day. (If Supercell wants to allow more, maybe they could assign a gem value to purchase that option?) I think it would be a big hit in the highest league levels.
This will allow more true competition within the multiplayer game. I see fewer people placing their Town Halls outside their base to be sniped. Lower level players that have no business being in the highest level of competition due to sniping exposed town halls and attacking for measly one stars will be exposed. Fewer Town Halls will be left out, because who would want to give a free victory to someone that actually has the opportunity to revenge them?
Does anyone else have any thoughts to add to this proposed feature?
Btw what's the point of having 2 yes buttons in poll
Revenging while online or shielded is a terrible idea.
There's a buffer preventing revenues until 7 minutes of being available to regular matchmaking. This was to combat cheap shielding. They certainly won't fix revenge by not only reverting to the old sytem, but making that old system easier.
Theres a solution out there that may work, but no one has come up with it yet...
In the meantime, remember that the system protects you as much as it protects them.
Who is proposing revenging while online or shielded? I must have missed that thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by AxionXD
Quote:
Originally Posted by AxionXD
If this is true- the 7 minute buffer should only apply to Champs and above. What are the odds of finding someone you know in masters or lower?
The threads start to blur together after responding to my 1000th change revenge thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by ITB
My apologies but until there is a good idea on how to revise Revenges without bring cheap shielding back, what good is the indicator if they're still never available? The buffer, at high leagues, insures that any base is attacked well within the 7 minute buffer.
One suggestion that is promising is to reduce the buffer time as you go down leagues. By Gold, perhaps there is no need for this buffer but may be needed again once you cross lower towards sub200 (where the pool of players is low similar to higher leagues)
I have yet to see "proof" of the 7 minute buffer. I have been waiting 6 days to revenge someone on my list. They are online alot. 4 days ago I had 3 minutes left on my troops he was online. I waited the three minutes then, I tried to attack him, he had a shield. I understand I am not the only one who wants Revenge but the is something fishy there. Just my experience. There is something to the special revenge option that was mentioned earlier hereQuote:
Originally Posted by AxionXD
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pympin
What exactly do you find fishy? You are put into regular matchmaking for 7 minutes before any revenge attacks can be done; usually you are attacked within those 7 minutes of being in regular matchmaking (especially if you put your th out for a free shield) and therefore trying to do a revenge attack becomes almost impossible. Nothing "fishy" about it.
Either implement a virtual revenge, or get rid of it as a feature that doesn't work.
It is only tempting at low levels anyway, as there is no win bonus for a revenge attack.
Will virtual revenge (you revenge a copy of the base that attacked you, but the attack doesn't lose anything) upset game resource economics? No more, probably a lot less than, the current emergent gameplay of mid level players (crystal-masters +) cheaply sniping each other for the full loot bonus each time.
Oh the way I read it was the other way. Which I personally think is how it should be. 7 minutes available to revengersQuote:
Originally Posted by Xav1
So there haven't been many people commenting on the Special revenge idea I mentioned earlier. This has nothing to do with 7 minute buffers, or being able to revenge someone that is online or shielded. Basically its a messaging system that is allowed on a limited basis (less limited if a person possibly uses gems) that allows a player to revenge someone when they sign off before the base is put out to the masses in multiplayer. Any thoughts on this specifically? I know I've been hit by players and want to express my displeasure on their bases as well...How many others are in this same boat?
When I really want to do something is when I'm in the Titan league with giant bombs outside my base and individually placed barbarians trigger each one before the attack even begins....It angers me enough to contemplate quitting the game altogether, not that anyone would care...
I think a lot of thing are messed up and revenge is one of them. I spent 30 minutes last night trying to revenge someone right after they attacked me and it was for nothing as in between hitting the button and waiting a few moments he got offline and was attacked. I would love to be able to buy a notification telling me when a village has no shield so I could revenge them.