I think we should delete the ''recommend'target during war, as it makes no sence....
Printable View
I think we should delete the ''recommend'target during war, as it makes no sence....
I'd support this.
Yeap, delete it
Some clans use it.
especially beginners.
But, it's not accurate and sometimes you find your recommend target too strong for your army.
We spend so much time teaching new members of our clan to ignore that.
+1
Recommended target is about as useful as the search function on this forum.
I think it's quite hard for the game to tell you a good match, but as mentioned, some people might use that so I would leave this system in place for those people.. it's not like it does any harm to us :)
I would correct the above text and say "The recommended target is about as used as the search function on this forum", because the usefulness of the two cannot be compared :smirk:Quote:
Originally Posted by btcc1721
I don't even notice the recommended target anymore, it usually shows far too low for me to want to attack it.
I agree with this, our clan laughs at what our recomended is if we ever notice it...
Once it was at the end of the war; I was 20, my reccomended was 8...
After a year and a half CWs, you're telling me that people still use "hit within x of your reccomended"?
Id say just have it with the person closest to your base value. You're still going to have some overlap but not as severe.
It was good at first but just pisses me off now when it says me our #4 should attack their #6 /////I support this fully
Yep. Both are worse than useless. They don't work. The results are more likely to mislead than to help.Quote:
Originally Posted by btcc1721
I almost always hit my recommended target. It's usually #1 and #2. If I didn't, I think people in my clan would be mad at me.
This is something i support,
Yep. It's good for the top player, the bottom player, the last attack, and that's about it.Quote:
Originally Posted by herranton
I never attack my recommended target, but I always check what it is. It gives me a hint of how strong the game thinks my army is. Helps me keep my stuff balanced. If my recommended target is weaker than my base that means I have to work on my troops, if it is stronger means I have to work on my base. So, no.
Or asking Supercell technical questionsQuote:
Originally Posted by btcc1721
I would not miss it if it went away, when clan wars was introduced it was useful, but as the matchmaking has evolved it is no longer useful.
That being said I do find it interesting as others said on why it may recommend a target and why I may disagree...gives some insights into the warped matchmaking presently being employed.
So to summarize, pretty much everyone that said it doesn't do any harm also said they ignore it. Those in favor of leaving it said "maybe somebody uses it". Did I miss anything?
Seems a very good candidate to just go away.
Agreed. Some people actually follow these recommendations and hit bases that are out of their league.
I don't think many of us would regret it, if it were to be deleted.
Quote:
Originally Posted by devil9394
I think its really bad, it confuses new players... Cause It doesnt look at there army and at the target...
It just makes no sence!
Better remove it and new players will find themself what target suits them best
lolQuote:
Originally Posted by btcc1721
Invisible 10char
Quote:
Originally Posted by NF2335
:smirk::smirk::smirk::smirk::smirk::smirk:
People who say that "their recommended target it too hard for their army" need to get a better army. We had someone in the clan who said that, we taught him how to use mass dragons and he could consistently 2/3 star his recommended. It is a poor worker who blames his tools...
Get rid of it. Replace it with a new tab where the clan leaders can write stuff on war strategy.
I really don't care either way but since I never use it and 99% of the time it makes no sense I support this idea. In my opinion it's so bad that it either needs to be removed or overhauled. Once again, it dosen't bother me either way. It's not likes its in the way or has a negative effect.Quote:
Originally Posted by casper1988
I agree that thing is just annoying, at least give clan leaders the option to have it active or not.
agree it is very redundant, but I would love all leaders to be able to set the reccommeded target for our clan mates...
Yes it would be very nice option for clan leader and co leaders to add notes (mayby just 1 or 2 lines)Quote:
Originally Posted by daz258
To a target!!!!
Mayby something for coming update???
Quote:
Originally Posted by btcc1721
I just want to point out that I'm pretty sure this statement was originally made some months ago in response to me saying the recommended target needs to go, or at least be replaced by a recommended range.
I put it in this thread hereQuote:
Originally Posted by awesomness2016
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...75#post4367575 :smirk:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Liwa21
If they had a better army, their recommended target would likely be higher wouldn't it?
On the other end of the spectrum, I used to find I could 3 star bases half a dozen up from my recommended target, so that did a fat lot of good.