[Improvement] - Clan War Selection

Printable View

September 6th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

2 Attachment(s)

[Improvement] - Clan War Selection
Description:
I think it would be more beneficial to show WAR related data about the player instead of showing leagues, level, etc. which doesn't really help. not that I'm against leagues being shown in clan war selection, but I think adding these will help you choose which member you would like to add much easier. So I came up with this GUI and I hope you guys like it.

Images:
http://forum.supercell.net/attachmen...d=138035&stc=1

Current Suggestions:
- Quote:
  
  Show the difference between the status of clan members would be helpful.
Quote:

OPTED IN and IN the war Green button/Green border
OPTED OUT and OUT of the war Red/Red
OPTED OUT and IN the war (as changed by leader) Green button / Red Border
OPTED IN and OUT of the war (as changed by leader) Red Button / Green Border
* I have opted people out, then realized I have done something wrong and need to go and restart the process

Give us a tap option with a pop up of player stats (mini profile)
Stars in last war (if known)
Total stars
Troop levels/Heroes
- A war loot : war stars ratio would be better
Current Features:
- Show Townhall instead of League
- Remembers your choices when you cancel war search. [Indicated by the Border]

Any suggestions would be appreciated on how to improve this. And I also don't think this would cause lag/huge data spaces since these data I'm asking for are already being retrieved and is nothing new to the database.
September 6th, 2015
Ahsuntry

Would definitely be useful as Leaders/Co Leaders will be able to select war participants based on their war skills more easily.
September 6th, 2015
TheGneissRock

A war loot : war stars ratio would be better
Since you can gain war stars by attacking 19&20 every war
September 6th, 2015
GameSketcher

Welk done!
I like your ideas and I think this should be implemented in the next update!

BTW welcome to Idea-Lab!
September 6th, 2015
oplemen

i think this is useless. stars mean nothing.
September 6th, 2015
Tisguyz

Quote:

Originally Posted by oplemen

i think this is useless. stars mean nothing.

They don't mean nothing. 1000 stars will get you so many gems man...
September 6th, 2015
Hamza1982

Geart idea

Quote:

Originally Posted by RepeaterCreeper

I think it would be more beneficial to show WAR related data about the player instead of showing leagues, level, etc. which doesn't really help. not that I'm against leagues being shown in clan war selection, but I think adding these will help you choose which member you would like to add much easier. So I came up with this GUI and I hope you guys like it.

http://i.imgur.com/gMbfCRH.png

Any suggestions would be appreciated on how to improve this. And I also don't think this would cause lag since these data I'm asking for are already being retrieved and is nothing new to the database.

that's great i like it
September 6th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Quote:

Originally Posted by kartikeya2010

A war loot : war stars ratio would be better
Since you can gain war stars by attacking 19&20 every war

I will sure keep that in mind. So basically like a war star ratio where you get the percentage of how much average stars they get per war?

Quote:

Originally Posted by GameSketcher

Welk done!
I like your ideas and I think this should be implemented in the next update!

BTW welcome to Idea-Lab!

Thanks for the invitation! Glad to be a part of a group.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ahsuntry

Would definitely be useful as Leaders/Co Leaders will be able to select war participants based on their war skills more easily.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hamza1982

that's great i like it

Thanks guys!
September 9th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Any Other Feedback?
Do you guys have any other feedback/suggestions to improve this suggestion? What we already have is:
- Do war star ratio instead of war stars.
September 9th, 2015
Mangekyou

War star ratio! Thumbs up

in fact, it will be nice to have it in our profile too.
September 9th, 2015
CuteBoboi

The TH image is useful. Sometimes we want to organise TH8 only, and it takes time for us to find one by one.

Probably showing last two war attacks/stars maybe more useful to show the player commitment or non-attack.
September 10th, 2015
George1971

Maybe.

But moreso i so I still want opt-in opt-out and un-opted.

when rounding out participants to the nearest five, the most important thing is player interest. Some opted-out have to be included, or some opted-in have to be left out. A few un-opted maybes would be nice.
September 11th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

New Feedback

Quote:

Originally Posted by CuteBoboi

The TH image is useful. Sometimes we want to organise TH8 only, and it takes time for us to find one by one.

Probably showing last two war attacks/stars maybe more useful to show the player commitment or non-attack.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mangekyou

War star ratio! Thumbs up

in fact, it will be nice to have it in our profile too.

Thanks guys! I appreciate the support.

Quote:

Originally Posted by George1971

Maybe.

But moreso i so I still want opt-in opt-out and un-opted.

when rounding out participants to the nearest five, the most important thing is player interest. Some opted-out have to be included, or some opted-in have to be left out. A few un-opted maybes would be nice.

That may be a nice feature. I'll think about it and maybe update this thread. ;)
September 28th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Improvement To Suggestion
Anyone else have new ideas on how to improve the suggestion I've posted? Would really love any type of feedback. We currently have:
- War Star Ratio instead of war stars. So basically average stars per war.
Any suggestions are great! Or just a nice message would be appreciated as well.
September 28th, 2015
PhilISuppose
Quote:
Originally Posted by RepeaterCreeper

Anyone else have new ideas on how to improve the suggestion I've posted? Would really love any type of feedback. We currently have:

War Star Ratio instead of war stars. So basically average stars per war.

Any suggestions are great! Or just a nice message would be appreciated as well.
Show the difference between the status of clan members would be helpful.
OPTED IN and IN the war Green button/Green border
OPTED OUT and OUT of the war Red/Red
OPTED OUT and IN the war (as changed by leader) Green button / Red Border
OPTED IN and OUT of the war (as changed by leader) Red Button / Green Border
* I have opted people out, then realized I have done something wrong and need to go and restart the process

Give us a tap option with a pop up of player stats (mini profile)
Stars in last war (if known)
Total stars
Troop levels/Heroes

(also I don't think you can find out War Star Ratio, as you don't know how many wars someone has been in...)
September 29th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Quote:

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

Show the difference between the status of clan members would be helpful.
OPTED IN and IN the war Green button/Green border
OPTED OUT and OUT of the war Red/Red
OPTED OUT and IN the war (as changed by leader) Green button / Red Border
OPTED IN and OUT of the war (as changed by leader) Red Button / Green Border
* I have opted people out, then realized I have done something wrong and need to go and restart the process

Give us a tap option with a pop up of player stats (mini profile)
Stars in last war (if known)
Total stars
Troop levels/Heroes

(also I don't think you can find out War Star Ratio, as you don't know how many wars someone has been in...)

Great Suggestion! I will definitely try and do a GUI art of that and update this thread. Should happen this weekend but no promises. Thanks for the feedback! :)

Also I do hate that as well. Like when I make a mistake on choosing a player to put in war I have to go all over again.
September 29th, 2015
Erebos29

Would definitely be useful, leagues don't do anything but add bonus, and there are lots of th7 trophy hunters at masters from my experience...
September 29th, 2015
Deadtoast15

Very nice idea! You have my support.
October 1st, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Quote:

Originally Posted by Erebos29

Would definitely be useful, leagues don't do anything but add bonus, and there are lots of th7 trophy hunters at masters from my experience...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Deadtoast15

Very nice idea! You have my support.

Thanks for all the feedback guys.
October 1st, 2015
herranton

I usually just add the lower levels to the roster. That way, if someone is opted out, and they don't attack, they haven't brought in a high weight opponent.
October 2nd, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Quote:

Originally Posted by herranton

I usually just add the lower levels to the roster. That way, if someone is opted out, and they don't attack, they haven't brought in a high weight opponent.

Thanks for your feedback. But the idea behind this is to help people to organize a clan of their liking. So basically if they want to assemble 2 TH9, 5 TH8, etc. They could do so easily.
October 2nd, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Updated [10/02/2015]

Quote:

Show the difference between the status of clan members would be helpful.
OPTED IN and IN the war Green button/Green border
OPTED OUT and OUT of the war Red/Red
OPTED OUT and IN the war (as changed by leader) Green button / Red Border
OPTED IN and OUT of the war (as changed by leader) Red Button / Green Border
* I have opted people out, then realized I have done something wrong and need to go and restart the process

Give us a tap option with a pop up of player stats (mini profile)
Stars in last war (if known)
Total stars
Troop levels/Heroes

I have completed the new and improved OPTED OUT/OPTED IN Feature suggested by PhillSuppose
October 10th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Updated [10/10/2015]

Made the thread a little more organized. As always please do let me know if you guys have any other ideas. :)
October 10th, 2015
LemoneyFresh937

Love it. Love it. Love it so much I wanna marry it and have 3 kids and live together for 6 years until my abusiveness and alcoholism drives it away and it divorces me and moves in with its parents and takes the kids with it.
October 10th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

Quote:

Originally Posted by LemoneyFresh937

Love it. Love it. Love it so much I wanna marry it and have 3 kids and live together for 6 years until my abusiveness and alcoholism drives it away and it divorces me and moves in with its parents and takes the kids with it.

Ummm okay. Thanks for the feedback I guess. hahaha
November 13th, 2015
RepeaterCreeper

More Suggestions

Looking for more suggestions on this. Also an improved image would be appreciated as you probably can see I'm not the best at creating GUI.
August 10th, 2017
RepeaterCreeper

If anyone is available to make a better image feel free to contact me. I'm still down for anyone that can give me ideas or an improved image.