More Ranks/Titles in clan with perks and privileges

I believe we need more title/rank options for promotions in clan. Elder and Co leader is not enough, and they do not have enough options to help them serve the clan. I also believe with each title a certain benefit should be applied rather its an increase in clan resources or xp gain etc. Give us a system that will help us better rule ourselves and help reward our members that our loyal. Also some examples of names with their job description for the new rank structure.

• Peasant - The first title given and the lowest rank. with no kick privileges and the lowest clan perk. also a penalty if you leave your clan unjustly of 50,000 of each resource and a attack penalty cool down of 36 hours, a join clan cool down of 24hrs if grace was permitted upon your leave no penalty incurred. a Desertion during clan wars penalty based on Town hall level deducted from your resources and given to the clan as a war loot bonus ex. th7 say they get 250k of each resource on a win then the penalty is 500k. For not making their attacks in a clan war and the end result is a loss a penalty based on their Town hall level of just 1 x so say a town hall 7 gets 250k of each resource on a win then the penalty is 250k.
• Footman - The second rank given. no kick privileges. higher clan perks than peasant. kick penalty of 100,000 ea. cool down for joining another clan or attacking is the same. and if grace is permitted no penalty. same penalties as above for peasant for desertion and not making clan war attacks
• Soldier - The third rank given, kick and promote privileges of the peasant rank only, higher clan perks than footman no penalty for leaving clan. same desertion penalties apply as above but no penalty for clan wars attacks
• Captain - The fourth rank given, kick privileges and promote abilities up to captain, higher clan perks than soldier. no penalty for leaving,desertion or clan war attack penalties. can permit grace to leaving members below footman rank.
• Elder - The fifth rank given, Kick privileges and promote abilities up to captain. higher clan perks than captain, can change war base during war prep time up to elder rank, clan message cool down time 6 hours. no penalty for leaving, desertion, or clan war attacks. can permit grace to leaving members, And can accept members into the clan.
• Co Leader - The Sixth rank given, can accept new members, kick and promotion abilities up to co leader, can make changes to members clan war bases during war prep time up to co leader rank, can start wars, Can penalize players for not making attacks in clan wars and distribute said resources among clan, higher clan perks than elder, clan message cool down time of 1 hour. no penalty for leaving, desertion, or clan attacks, also has the ability to permit grace to leaving members.
• Leader - The seventh rank, Kick and promotion abilities up to leader (yes you can have more than 1 leader) highest clan perks, sets internal clan rewards for its members, may penalize all members in war for not making attacks as well as out of war for losing to many trophies for the clan during a clan trophy push. no cool down time on clan wide messages. no penalties of any kind. and may permit grace.

Last but not least to help with checks and balances i recommend a Leader kick and promote option to clan members if their leader is deemed unworthy a vote must be taken and passed by 80 percent of its members and the leader can be expelled and replaced. The option of having a dead clan and leaving when at the rank of Peasant, footman or soldier would be also overturned by an option of clan disembark vote.

This of course is just an example and a recommendation to Supercell for a new rank structure with perks to go along with each. Please leave a comment below showing support or a variation of what is listed to help out. thank you all for your time and Clash On!

I like the time spent on it but really, the penalty thing isn't really that good of an Idea. It ruins Req and ♥♥♥♥ clans. Plus who cares about clan hoppers. Just don't donate to them once they join or don;t give them co lead. Seriously we don't need penalties.

[QUOTE=CarlTheGreat;5330909]I believe we need more title/rank options for promotions in clan. Elder and Co leader is not enough, and they do not have enough options to help them serve the clan. I also believe with each title a certain benefit should be applied rather its an increase in clan resources or xp gain etc. Give us a system that will help us better rule ourselves and help reward our members that our loyal. Also some examples of names with their job description for the new rank structure.

• Peasant - The first title given and the lowest rank. with no kick privileges and the lowest clan perk. also a penalty if you leave your clan unjustly of 50,000 of each resource and a attack penalty cool down of 36 hours, a join clan cool down of 24hrs if grace was permitted upon your leave no penalty incurred. a Desertion during clan wars penalty based on Town hall level deducted from your resources and given to the clan as a war loot bonus ex. th7 say they get 250k of each resource on a win then the penalty is 500k. For not making their attacks in a clan war and the end result is a loss a penalty based on their Town hall level of just 1 x so say a town hall 7 gets 250k of each resource on a win then the penalty is 250k.
• Footman - The second rank given. no kick privileges. higher clan perks than peasant. kick penalty of 100,000 ea. cool down for joining another clan or attacking is the same. and if grace is permitted no penalty. same penalties as above for peasant for desertion and not making clan war attacks
• Soldier - The third rank given, kick and promote privileges of the peasant rank only, higher clan perks than footman no penalty for leaving clan. same desertion penalties apply as above but no penalty for clan wars attacks
• Captain - The fourth rank given, kick privileges and promote abilities up to captain, higher clan perks than soldier. no penalty for leaving,desertion or clan war attack penalties. can permit grace to leaving members below footman rank.
• Elder - The fifth rank given, Kick privileges and promote abilities up to captain. higher clan perks than captain, can change war base during war prep time up to elder rank, clan message cool down time 6 hours. no penalty for leaving, desertion, or clan war attacks. can permit grace to leaving members, And can accept members into the clan.
• Co Leader - The Sixth rank given, can accept new members, kick and promotion abilities up to co leader, can make changes to members clan war bases during war prep time up to co leader rank, can start wars, Can penalize players for not making attacks in clan wars and distribute said resources among clan, higher clan perks than elder, clan message cool down time of 1 hour. no penalty for leaving, desertion, or clan attacks, also has the ability to permit grace to leaving members.
• Leader - The seventh rank, Kick and promotion abilities up to leader (yes you can have more than 1 leader) highest clan perks, sets internal clan rewards for its members, may penalize all members in war for not making attacks as well as out of war for losing to many trophies for the clan during a clan trophy push. no cool down time on clan wide messages. no penalties of any kind. and may permit grace.

Last but not least to help with checks and balances i recommend a Leader kick and promote option to clan members if their leader is deemed unworthy a vote must be taken and passed by 80 percent of its members and the leader can be expelled and replaced. The option of having a dead clan and leaving when at the rank of Peasant, footman or soldier would be also overturned by an option of clan disembark vote.

This of course is just an example and a recommendation to Supercell for a new rank structure with perks to go along with each. Please leave a comment below showing support or a variation of what is listed to help out. thank you all for your time and Clash On![/
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Not even sure where to begin, but I'll address the two areas I bolded.

First, there is no way Supercell will ever penalize people from leaving a clan, the idea is ridiculous; everyone has the right to leave a clan if they want to. You say leaving a clan "unjustly" ....who is to decide what is unjust or not, you basically want to hold people prisoners in your clan with the fear of losing resources or my favorite "an attack penalty cooldown of 36 hours." I'm sorry, but this one of the craziest ideas I have heard in a long time.

Second, your expell the leader idea; if you deem your leader "unworthy" then press that magic button called leave clan, because no one has the right to take ownership of a clan that does not belong to them.

More ranks, cool. More privleges, cool.

Penalties for leaving? 100% idiotic. What if I genuinely dont like a clan? take 100k of my resources? PLUS I cant attack or join my old clan back for 36 and 24 hours respectively? Very bad idea.

I don't agree with editing someone's war base. That's a terrible idea, what's the point of them playing clash of your playing it for them.

great keep the comments and ideas coming, i through in the penalities, cooldowns, and or leadership replacement based on other forum posts that have issues with clan hoppers, dead leaders, etc. but the ranks and titles is the initial aim of this thread. they do not have enough of them in clan.

Sounds overly complicated to me. Do we really need all these ranks? You don't actually explain why leader, co-leader, and elder are not enough ranks. You simply state that you don't think they're enough and so therefore more should be created. Proper use of the roles of leader, co-leader and elder can effectively run a clan. The leader sets the rules and picks his co-leader(s) to help create those rules and advise on clan matters. Elders help enforce the rules of the clan when the leader and co-leader aren't around. Regular members are encouraged to speak their minds on clan matters, and their ideas are taken seriously.

The problem is many clans giveaway "elder" and "co-leader" so they can get people to join or reward people with elder for silly reasons like reaching 100 troop donations. If you use the current hierarchy system properly and give titles and responsibilities based upon necessity and not frivolity there is no need for more ranks.

If supercell was implement anymore ranks, personally I wouldn't be quick to start handing them out in my clan and maybe not even use them at all.

I think your idea is creative and appreciate that you put a lot of thought into it with the names and abilities the different ranks would have. I'm sure there will be others who will support your idea and want more ranks as well. I'm just not one of those people.

People... Please let this thread die...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by smolson

Sounds overly complicated to me. Do we really need all these ranks? You don't actually explain why leader, co-leader, and elder are not enough ranks. You simply state that you don't think they're enough and so therefore more should be created. Proper use of the roles of leader, co-leader and elder can effectively run a clan. The leader sets the rules and picks his co-leader(s) to help create those rules and advise on clan matters. Elders help enforce the rules of the clan when the leader and co-leader aren't around. Regular members are encouraged to speak their minds on clan matters, and their ideas are taken seriously.

The problem is many clans giveaway "elder" and "co-leader" so they can get people to join or reward people with elder for silly reasons like reaching 100 troop donations. If you use the current hierarchy system properly and give titles and responsibilities based upon necessity and not frivolity there is no need for more ranks.

If supercell was implement anymore ranks, personally I wouldn't be quick to start handing them out in my clan and maybe not even use them at all.

I think your idea is creative and appreciate that you put a lot of thought into it with the names and abilities the different ranks would have. I'm sure there will be others who will support your idea and want more ranks as well. I'm just not one of those people.

---

the reason you need more ranks is because their is only 3 and not even close to enough structure. And we do not reward for silly reasons, in my clan they are earned. And in my clan i am a co-leader with the current system their really is not much room for growth, their should be more options to have the ability to handout to your members especially if you have more than one clan. Furthermore what do you do with a loyal clan with only 2 options to give them. Do you end up with a clan full of elders and co leaders? what do you reward them with after years of loyalty and activeness? Eventually in the current system their is no room to go anywhere. The end result is a stale mate.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tisguyz

People... Please let this thread die...

---

Why even post dumb replies? we do need more ranks in clans especially those with more than one clan to manage.