War Preperation Overhaul

You play the game too much.

Plain and simple. Just do literally anything else.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NFB

You play the game too much.

Plain and simple. Just do literally anything else.

---

Lol I feel like I should be flattered that you care about what I do with my time but sorry idgaf

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rashuns

Lol I feel like I should be flattered that you care about what I do with my time but sorry idgaf

---

You sound like my ♥♥♥♥ral son..... Dad! Ugh! Whatever!

Haha xD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by btcc1721

1. Dependent on war matchup in terms of time for preparation. The we're ready button would work if it was 24h + prep day time remaining. It would require a big change to the war system. It would also be immensely difficult to implement, without stopping wars being declared over 48h before the necessary maint break.

2. 320k is too low for a TH9, unless it is a very, very rushed base. I don't dip below 440k ever. Most wars, I get over 1 million in bonus. The fact is, my 2 alt accts. lived/live off wars. Imagine how much that could reduce gem sales.

The clan perks system was also integrated to work with 48h wars.

The long and short of it is, it's too hard to implement, and SC are unlikely to do so, as it will lose them money. Zapping lost them money, which is why they addressed it.

---

I don't buy the "immensely difficult" to implement argument at all. I've developed software and hardware for almost 20 years and do "immensely difficult" things all the time. Companies who don't do "immensely difficult" things fail and go out of business.

The perk system wouldn't really change any. So some clans will get perks faster. No biggy, it's still an even playing field for all. Already some clans war with 50 every two days and level up way faster. Other clans war with 10 once a week and will take far longer. This wouldn't change the picture drastically.

Already responded to the 320k number above. That argument is invalidated I believe.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dennisjm

2. I'm a TH9 and I get around 320k bonus gold/elixer for a war win. It takes 48 hours to do that with a war. I can do two or three attacks in a few hours and get more than the war bonus. It's more reliable too... we might not win the war but I can pretty reliably raise loot attacking. Further, to get the war win, I have to use more expensive troops. Likely if I decide to resort to barching, I can do just as well.. and then even faster.

If anything, warring faster is likely to make some players gem more.

---

I think you missed the point. You have to look at it from Supercell's perspective, not yours. The war bonuses are FREE LOOT GIVEN DIRECTLY TO YOU BY SUPERCELL. Why would they want to give out free war loot more often than every 48 hours? What's their motivation?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyPC

I think you missed the point. You have to look at it from Supercell's perspective, not yours. The war bonuses are FREE LOOT GIVEN DIRECTLY TO YOU BY SUPERCELL. Why would they want to give out free war loot more often than every 48 hours? What's their motivation?

---

Honestly I don't really think that the amount of loot is the issue, Supercell doesn't mind giving out loot/gems (boxes) if they think it will bring more players or cause people to spend more.

I think the biggest issue is introducing more conflict between clan members or between clans. If someone wants to change his base and didn't get the chance, or one clan is ready and the other isn't then one clan gets frustrated waiting for the other. Much more so then if they just have a set time to wait. Also as others mentioned what if one clan is ready but the other waits for a while before agreeing they are ready? The war could start at a bad time for you.

There are times where I might be away for 24/36h but I know that I will be back online in time to get my war attacks in. With variable start time you couldn't plan on this.

I agree the game needs to grow and Supercell seems to do a good job of that, I just don't see this being the way they advance in the future. I think something like clan war tournaments will be much more likely given the latest event in Finland.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PvtLeeOwned

So one team hits the ready button at 8pm and they are ready to roll. Then the other team based on the other side of the world hits the ready button at 4am relative to the first teams time zone. Who has the advantage now?

I very much do not want this idea to be implemented.

---

the idea here is to have that option, to help get in more wars. also if they hit the go button then i would assume their ready to go. rather its 4 am or 4 pm. also a way to implement this is if the clan is ready hits the go button they can make their attacks and move on. the attacks will not post tell a few hours after the other team has made theirs or hit the go button and made all their attacks, allowing you the option to make your attacks and get in another war. Enhancing the clash of clans war system. I know this may lead to more resource gain, so offset it a little to compensate for a reasonable gain. i know you can get millions Barching in 48 hrs. so an offset of say 50-100k with an increase war rate would be beneficial.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rashuns

I've been whinging about the length of clan war (to myself) for months now. It's too long a wait between wars. During Prep day most active clans fill war cc's in 12 hours or less, well we do anyway. Then we have another 24 hours to war. That is more than enough time to train troops and plan attacks. Once I've done both attacks I'm bored af. I also need to practice war strategies but the match ups in normal raids are not as competitive as war match ups so I don't even bother. I don't care about xp or loot as much. I'd love an option to start a new search for war at least 12 hours before the end of the current war. I know a lot of people and including myself are surprised to find how addictive this game is especially during clan wars, winning or losing. Please, please consider an option to start a new war search before the end of the current war.

---

I think the game is a great addictive addition to the line up of anyone's games on their ipads, tablets, phones etc. i would be happy to do more wars frequently it is just fun. Doing it more often would be even better.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PvtLeeOwned

So one team hits the ready button at 8pm and they are ready to roll. Then the other team based on the other side of the world hits the ready button at 4am relative to the first teams time zone. Who has the advantage now?

I very much do not want this idea to be implemented.

---

no one has an advantage they would be able to start the war when they hit the ready/go button and make their attacks. allowing them to do another start another war once finished. it would be a way for clans to war more often.