Printable View
Hi, we just got into a clan war against a clan named Lio, and it is totally unbalanced. We're thinking about not participating in this one and not participating at all, it's ridiculous.
TH10 2 vs 6 (all of them with IT)
TH09 4 vs 2
TH08 1 vs 2
TH07 1 vs 0
TH06 2 vs 0
As you all see, totally unbalanced!! I've been in other clans, and 4 of them already quit it.
Get in line. I think the MM is fine but people keep complaining. You making a forum post in addition to the hundreds of other threads people made will not help.
It is getting really bad. I don't know if they did a stealth update? It was alright for a while, but our last 4 wars haven't even been close in matchup, we got the good end of it on one of those, though.
How could u say it's fine? How a TH6 would b able to beat a TH8? Or a TH8 beat a TH10 with IT? If u think it's fine, clearly u need to c a Dr.
I don't know we occasionally get some mismatched war - some in our favor - some against us. But most of the matches we have gotten recently have been fairly even. We usually have the edge 3 to 2 in TH 10s, but the other clan usually has 2 to 3 more TH9s than us.
Your matchup seems particularly unbalanced but dems the breaks. Use it to practice attacks on tougher bases and know you'll probably lose.
Last war we got matched with a max th10 but we had no th10.
Us vs them
th10 0 vs 2 (including one max and other max except walls and lvl35+ heroes)
Th9 21vs19
Th8 4v4
Those 2 th10 just swings the balance so massively in their favour.
So i feel your pain
However next war we got the bettet end of the draw where even our lowest th9 has better walls than theirtop th9.
Can't win every war and sometimes the matchmaking is just against you.
Seems to be better if we keep war search to under 15 minutes, then restart (the bad match we aearched for close to an hour)
Unless you can show us some pictures of the two teams bases and profiles, it's all hot air.
Post the clan tags so we can look at 'em.
10v10 are more susceptible for mismatches since they can easily be swung by 1 or 2 bases.
You have 12 th9/10 attacks to gain stars on their 8 th9/10 bases. Hopefully a couple of them are rushed in which case th9s should be able to 2 star them.
But sometimes mismatches just happen, we had one that was level on townhalls but the other team was way underpowered on troops/defenses/heroes and we rolled through them.
There are occasional mismatches that occur in a 1-5% chance :rolleyes:
But it's fine.
The only time you actually lose is by giving up right at the start and cursing SC.
Consider these mismatches as a "challenge" rather than an annoyance.
Oh! I haven't seen anyone posting about their overmatched opponent which occurs more frequently than the other way around.
We have had pretty close matchups, but have been a slight underdog for every single war. Last war they had 2 th10s, and 2 more th9s. We have only one th10(me) and their 1 was almost maxed with max troops, but only low 20 heroes. We ended up tying them. I got 3* star on their second th10 and he got 99% 2 star on one of our th9s lol.
I would love to have the advantage once lol. You can overcome a certain degree of disadvantage, but you will need to make your first attacks count,not much room for bad attacks.
[QUOTE=F34RTEHR34PER;5324559]Unless you can show us some pictures of the two teams bases and profiles, it's all hot air.
Post the clan tags so we can look at 'em.
#99UGQ9C9 DOMINICANS
#8C09GRRQ LIO
From my clan the Dominicans, only Redhulk and Ivan are participating.
[QUOTE=Redhulk;5324922]You have 22 members and they have 44, are we suppose to guess which 20 are in the war?Quote:
Originally Posted by F34RTEHR34PER
Overall, I would say it isn't a bad match.
I mean, one of the th10 bases isn't even maxed th7 yet. Spells are lvl 3 light, lvl 2 rage, rest are lvl 1. Doesn't even have freeze and only has poison.
Troop wise, that base has lvl 4 dragons, lvl3 pekka, lvl 5 wb, lvl 2 minion, rest of dark troops are lvl 1. Loons are lvl4 and heroes are bk7 and aq4.
I could go on about all the bases compared to your clans, but overall it isn't a bad match based on the numbers.
[QUOTE=steelseth;5324990]I went over their th10 bases...Quote:
Originally Posted by Redhulk
Not going to go through 44 members to guess which ones might be in the war but how do you know the weak ones are the ones in the war?Quote:
Originally Posted by steelseth
Lio has 39/40 heroes almost max TH10, Daniel 20/20 heroes decent TH10 .... why not these guys instead of the TH10 with pink walls and TH7 defences?
I looked at all their th10 bases. ;) If he could list the exact ones, I could look at it closer. I considered their top trophy bases that were th10, so the one you listed is considered.Quote:
Originally Posted by steelseth
i think you need to "c" a 1st grade teacherQuote:
Originally Posted by Redhulk
What would you like them to do to fix it?
There are only so many clans looking for a war at any given time. If there are no clans that's are a match for your clan what should they do? Should you just not get a war match up? Should they make you wait for a few days? A few weeks?
There's only so much they can do. If no one else close to your clan is looking for a war then it's literally out of their hands
if instead listing the th levels of the members you could list the actuall war weight of each member and then compair the 2 that be great....
Bingo! I read the complaint and thought the same exact thing. I am not saying you are a cry baby, because I have been in my fair share of lopsided match ups, but with weight it probably is relatively close. One of the downfalls of rushed town halls. I haven't even looked at your clan, nor will I...but I am just saying.Quote:
Originally Posted by Willivodka
I have been in a clan with lots of rushed bases, for quite a long time, and one with no rushed bases. I know it's only my experience but man, it is night at day. The clan with a lot of rushed bases got all kinds of crazy mismatches, usually against clans with rushed bases too, and it was all over the place. Clan with no rushed bases, the matchups are almost perfect(at least in comparison), usually identical numbers of each TH's and even similar defensive levels, and seems to match us with mostly not rushed bases as well.
Not saying accept rushers, or not, or to rush or not. I just have a feeling it is a lot easier for the system to get you a good match if there are no rushed bases in your war search.
Another thing though, is i also think you tend to get easier clans with rushed bases in your search. If i'm right and you tend to draw other rushed bases, they are typically less umm, good clans.
How can we "all see" that it is totally unbalanced?Quote:
Originally Posted by Redhulk
While it probably is, listing the comparative TH levels doesn't tell us nearly enough.
Give us the weights of all those bases, and we might have a bit better idea, although apparently even that doesn't take into account offensive capabilities.
My clan is usually up against tougher clans. Get better at attacks and learn to 3 star. We win more than we don't and facing stiff competition is more fun that than flattening a clan
So you lay down and act like cowards because you're afraid of a little competition?Quote:
Originally Posted by Redhulk
Disgusting mindset, how can you or you're clanmates look at yourself in the mirror as this behavior is a reflection of your real life. What else do you run away from when things don't go your way?
Anyways.
Only real reason for mismatches in war is due to rushing your base. When you have Th7 defenses/troops as a th10 building infernos will surely cause a bad mismatch.
Same with th9 and so on.
Blame yourself and your clans decisions on how they are progressing there base as to why you are getting mismatches.