[IDEA] Donate Spells [+PIC]

Welcome to this suggestion!

THIS IDEA WAS IMPLEMENTED IN THE GAME!

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...97722_orig.png

Spell donating unlocks when a clan reaches level 7!

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...10195_orig.png

There will come a button to requests "Donate", but for spell. As well, when attacking, you have one slot for clan castle troops and one for received spell.


Housing space for received spells is max. 1! So you can only receive a Dark spell. 2 or more will be too OP.

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...05290_orig.png

You can't recieve spells you can't make. For example, if your TH lvl doesn't allow you to build the dark spell factory, you can't receive any spells.
- simply: only dark spells the player can make show in the donation bubble (in the picture = player can make and so receive Poison spell and Earthquake spell)

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...74361_orig.gif


So guys what do you think? :smirk:

YouTube video: https://youtu.be/XhLFRvj8pyQ

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...35452_orig.png

PS: Don't forget to check out my newest spell idea: CLONE spell (link)

Hi there,GameSketcher. Unfortunately,I do not think this idea would be implemented into the game although I like it personally. I would not like to see a th5s using Haste Spells and boosting his troops (if the th5 successfully joined a clan with 300^ wars won) . This is actually unfair for other th5s. Firstly, a th5 with 2 loons in cc is already OP. Now,adding a maxed haste spell. The game might be unbalance then.

Well,good job on your pic tho.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrHuntSeanDown

Hi there,GameSketcher. Unfortunately,I do not think this idea would be implemented into the game although I like it personally. I would not like to see a th5s using Haste Spells and boosting his troops (if the th5 successfully joined a clan with 300^ wars won) . This is actually unfair for other th5s. Firstly, a th5 with 2 loons in cc is already OP. Now,adding a maxed haste spell. The game might be unbalance then.

Well,good job on your pic tho.

---

Thanks for your reply! I think that it's like when town hall 5 get valkyrie or another non-unlocked troop to clan castle. Only one not similar thing is that the TH5 can't get (for example) Haste spell if is not in clan with 300+ won wars. But I think it will add more interest and a new critic when choosing a clan. Just my opinion :)

I don't know if this will be a good thing.

Low TH's will take a poison with, saving the zap for buildings (making the attack easier)
Low TH's will take a haste with, making their CC loon attacks way too OP for 1 AD to handle.

Nice editing on the photo btw

I don't know about this. I think clan castle reinforcements are quite overpowered already, especially at lower town hall levels. Maybe this should only be unlocked at TH8 or TH9 as I think it could be abused easily.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by F34R991

I don't know if this will be a good thing.

Low TH's will take a poison with, saving the zap for buildings (making the attack easier)
Low TH's will take a haste with, making their CC loon attacks way too OP for 1 AD to handle.

Nice editing on the photo btw

---

Thanks

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Echo006

I don't know about this. I think clan castle reinforcements are quite overpowered already, especially at lower town hall levels. Maybe this should only be unlocked at TH8 or TH9 as I think it could be abused easily.

---

Or maybe not TH level but CC level. Maybe from level 4 CC. How about this?

Saw your edit. Thanks for it! Now it won't be too imbalance for low THs player. :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrHuntSeanDown

Saw your edit. Thanks for it! Now it won't be too imbalance for low THs player. :D

---

Do you have any ideas how to make it more balanced?

YouTube video: https://youtu.be/XhLFRvj8pyQ

I don't agree with your idea, but I do like the picture!

I don't think this will ever happen. If a TH 10 can donate a freeze spell to a TH5 that is WAY OP'D. Just think about how the balance of the low lvl game will go to $¥¡£. I don't think it would be fair that a TH5 could destroy a TH8 because the King is frozen. What about Dark spells can I donate 2 spells due to housing space. SORRY IT WON'T WORK OR FLY WITH THE LOW LVLS

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pympin

I don't think this will ever happen. If a TH 10 can donate a freeze spell to a TH5 that is WAY OP'D. Just think about how the balance of the low lvl game will go to $¥¡£. I don't think it would be fair that a TH5 could destroy a TH8 because the King is frozen. What about Dark spells can I donate 2 spells due to housing space. SORRY IT WON'T WORK OR FLY WITH THE LOW LVLS

---

You can only hold 1 Housing Space worth of Spells, so TH5s can't get Freeze Spells or anything.

But I do agree that it would be quite OP, because a TH4 could use a Haste Spell to boost Balloons over to an Air Defense.

If you will also add a Th requirement to this so the smaller TH levels won't have access to Poison or Haste Spell, then I could go with this idea. Also I don't believe the spell donation function should come based on war wins, maybe as a perk or as a simple new ability with requirements.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GameSketcher

When a clan reaches 300 won wars, it will unlock spell donating!

---

Also this ^^ makes this spell donations impossible to reach. I don't think any clan reached that number yet. I looked now at one of the old top clans, Team Y.O.L.O and it only has 242 war wins.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheScavenger350

You can only hold 1 Housing Space worth of Spells, so TH5s can't get Freeze Spells or anything.

But I do agree that it would be quite OP, because a TH4 could use a Haste Spell to boost Balloons over to an Air Defense.

---

First: I am pretty sure he is saying that you can donate ANY spell. Second: TH4 Can't have spells since the spell factory IS NOT available until TH5.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pympin

I don't think this will ever happen. If a TH 10 can donate a freeze spell to a TH5 that is WAY OP'D. Just think about how the balance of the low lvl game will go to $¥¡£. I don't think it would be fair that a TH5 could destroy a TH8 because the King is frozen. What about Dark spells can I donate 2 spells due to housing space. SORRY IT WON'T WORK OR FLY WITH THE LOW LVLS

---

You only read the title?? xD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheScavenger350

You can only hold 1 Housing Space worth of Spells, so TH5s can't get Freeze Spells or anything.

But I do agree that it would be quite OP, because a TH4 could use a Haste Spell to boost Balloons over to an Air Defense.

---

Thanks for telling him. ^^^
And also you missed a thing, "Only level 4 or higher Clan castle can stock a spell."

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by devil9394

If you will also add a Th requirement to this so the smaller TH levels won't have access to Poison or Haste Spell, then I could go with this idea. Also I don't believe the spell donation function should come based on war wins, maybe as a perk or as a simple new ability with requirements.

[/CENTER]
Also this ^^ makes this spell donations impossible to reach. I don't think any clan reached that number yet. I looked now at one of the old top clans, Team Y.O.L.O and it only has 242 war wins.

---

As I said you missed the CC level requirtment. And maybe it can be as a perk, but I think it will be better with war wins.♥

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pympin

First: I am pretty sure he is saying that you can donate ANY spell. Second: TH4 Can't have spells since the spell factory IS NOT available until TH5.

---

You are so....... :/

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by devil9394

Also this ^^ makes this spell donations impossible to reach. I don't think any clan reached that number yet. I looked now at one of the old top clans, Team Y.O.L.O and it only has 242 war wins.

---

Woof... I haven't checked it until now so... thanks for letting me know! - changed to 100
Or is 200 better?

Maybe if you could only donate spells that are already unlocked at the requester's TH level? I don't think it's a bad idea, but it doesn't seem very necessary, either. Good job on the image editing, though. :thumbsup:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GameSketcher

Woof... I haven't checked it until now so... thanks for letting me know! - changed to 100
Or is 200 better?

---

Maybe 50 or 75 would be good. 200 are again too many and only few clans reached it. Also, just picture that all those clan wins are x2 number of days, assuming the clan only won the wars.. so 200 war wins is at least 400 days of constantly warring which is an insane requirement to ask for. This ability is not that ground breaking that it needs such a number of clan wins.
A 50 war wins is at least a 100 days mission, + the times you wait a day to start the wars earlier + the war losses, number 50 seems the best option.
Anyway what I don't like at asking for war wins for this is that it would give an unfair advantage in wars to some clans against the new ones.. so I would maybe think of something different to ask for this spell donation perk.

"imbalance gaming"

Why not make it unlock as a perk for a level 10+? That's more easily accessible than 50-200 war wins...

For the record, level 4 CC means TH8+. Having access to a max poison spell? No big deal. Having access to a max EQ? Again, no big deal. Haste is debatable but I think it puts some use to having the feature. You have my support for this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aegonkai

Maybe if you could only donate spells that are already unlocked at the requester's TH level? I don't think it's a bad idea, but it doesn't seem very necessary, either. Good job on the image editing, though. :thumbsup:

---

This.........

I'm with you. I liked the idea. With this I could make GoWiPe much better putting 1 Rage spell, 1 Healing spell, 3 Quake spells and 1 CC Quake spell. This would make attacking much better!

You unlock this feature at CC Lvl 4. I like this idea but what what would the animation be? How would you put this down?

Thank you all for your opinions/additions/critics!

As I see many of you want to unlock spell donating by a perk.

So do you want it as a perk?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jackdopp

You unlock this feature at CC Lvl 4. I like this idea but what what would the animation be? How would you put this down?

---

Sorry, what? You mean how can player know that the clan unlocked donating spells?
It will just show in Army overview and CC info.

Cool Idea.
Keep this great work up.
.
I read some replies and I agree with them in:
1) It should be a perk your clan unlock when you reach a certain lvl.
2) You can't recieve spells you can't make. For example, if your TH lvl doesn't allow you to build the dark spell factory, you can't receive any spells.

I had to vote no. Just felt there were too many stipulations in order to implement the feature and keep the game balanced. Might as well just give people the ability to create and bring an extra spell into war which just seems too overpowered at this point unless you want to nerf spells.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mido2malik

Cool Idea.
Keep this great work up.
.
I read some replies and I agree with them in:
1) It should be a perk your clan unlock when you reach a certain lvl.
2) You can't recieve spells you can't make. For example, if your TH lvl doesn't allow you to build the dark spell factory, you can't receive any spells.

---

I also though of this, but you can receive troops which you can't train.

PS: I quoted this in the thread.

He also mentioned the fact that it would only be available at th8 because it would take level4 cc. And then 3 staring max th8s would become a bit easier, since a max th8 can't beat a max th8..................

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mahathir

He also mentioned the fact that it would only be available at th8 because it would take level4 cc. And then 3 staring max th8s would become a bit easier, since a max th8 can't beat a max th8..................

---

I think this will help the game. But it needs more support...

Change it so if you receive one it goes into yoir normal spells! Not an extra spell.

No! If it just gives you a spell space to your normal spell you have then max. 12 spaces, so you can make 6 elixir spells and that's OP. Btw how it will happen if you leave the clan then?? It will just disappear? Bad idea...

New super dooper PICS added! Check zhem ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GameSketcher

Welcome to this suggestion!

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...97722_orig.png

Spell donating unlocks when a clan reaches level 7!

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...10195_orig.png

There will come a button to requests "Donate", but for spell. As well, when attacking, you have one slot for clan castle troops and one for received spell.


Housing space for received spells is max. 1! So you can only receive a Dark spell. 2 or more will be too OP.

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...05290_orig.png

You can't recieve spells you can't make. For example, if your TH lvl doesn't allow you to build the dark spell factory, you can't receive any spells.
- simply: only dark spells the player can make show in the donation bubble (in the picture = player can make and so receive Poison spell and Earthquake spell)

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...74361_orig.gif


So guys what do you think? :smirk:

YouTube video: https://youtu.be/XhLFRvj8pyQ

http://gamesketcher.weebly.com/uploa...35452_orig.png

PS: Don't forget to check out my newest spell idea: CLONE spell (link)

---

I chosed 2) option. Because it's better, I think!

I don't agree with your idea.

Thank you all guys supporting this idea!

Supercell implemented it to the upcoming update! Yay! :o

http://i.imgur.com/fCpGEuz.png