Bringing 2 star attacks back to wars!

Heya!

So, I had the privilege to be at the Nordic Clash Tourney last Sunday. And I was absolutely astounded by the system they had put in place to run the wars. One feature in particular really stood out to me, and that was the no "tie" system.

This is how it works:

So we have two clans.
Invictus Kings VS Lunar Rising.
Both clans have two starred all enemy bases. And there are no attacks left on either side. Normally the end of the war would come and the result would be a tie. Well how the Nordic Clash worked, was it would then go to a second party to determine the winner. Total clan destruction %.

http://i.imgur.com/4FWlJX6.png?1

And whoever has the best % would then win the war.
Now personally, I would love to see this added to the game, because it would give purpose to two star attacks. Looking at my war log is depressing to see the amount of ties. This wont affect lower level gameplay much, but for the clans where everyone is maxed, and most wars result in a tie, this could bring that spark back to wars.

I made this thread to gauge the community, and see what you guys think. So... Is it just me? Or is this something you guys would want added to the game?

I have to agree. I LOVE the idea of this. I was actually having a conversation about this exact topic the other day. Would love for it to come down to a percentage rather than it ending in a tie, it would bring a whole new side to clan wars in a positive way (can be a negative thing to some people/clans though). I vote yes, this should definitely be a thing. Great thread, I am looking forward to viewing other people's opinions also.

It's a logical idea and easily within SC's power to add in.

I'd like to see this in game soon.

Lach, this is great and you sir should have talked to supercell about that.

This is needed for sure & as you said especially when wars are between 2 maxed out clans. This will encourage attackers to try and get best % out of each base.

Interesting idea indeed, I liked how the clans performed in the clan tournaments few days ago.

I have to ask this.. what would happen in the very rare occasion when even the Total Clan Destruction would be equal as well? Would it then go to the Total Best Attack Duration? What if that one would be equal too? Would it then be a tie?

I know these would be really really rare occasions for this to occur, but they can happen and I feel we should clarify them too if we are to talk about changing the tie system.

And no one has mentioned number of attacks won/lost? Wouldn't that be the easiest, unless that was the same, too, then go to %? Just a thought. I'm not in the higher levels of gameplay, so just throwing it out there.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MommySnooks

And no one has mentioned number of attacks won/lost? Wouldn't that be the easiest, unless that was the same, too, then go to %? Just a thought. I'm not in the higher levels of gameplay, so just throwing it out there.

---

If this was the case, players couldn't go for loot raids if they know it's not possible to get any extra stars etc without possibly sacrificing the war. That being said, the same goes for the percentage. There would have to be some way around this. Possibly only counting the % of the winning attacks on each base could do the job.

Thanks for the positive feedback guys :)
The better the feedback, the easier it is to present it to SuperCell.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by devil9394

I have to ask this.. what would happen in the very rare occasion when even the Total Clan Destruction would be equal as well? Would it then go to the Total Best Attack Duration? What if that one would be equal too? Would it then be a tie?

I know these would be really really rare occasions for this to occur, but they can happen and I feel we should clarify them too if we are to talk about changing the tie system.

---

So incredibly rare, like the odds are 1 in millions. But lets say this happens, after going through both tiebreaker options, it would be safe to say its a tie. :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MommySnooks

And no one has mentioned number of attacks won/lost? Wouldn't that be the easiest, unless that was the same, too, then go to %? Just a thought. I'm not in the higher levels of gameplay, so just throwing it out there.

---

The issue with that, is anyone can 1 star a base using just barch. The number of wins would skyrocket and it wouldn't be a true test of skill.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheGreatLach

Thanks for the positive feedback guys :)
The better the feedback, the easier it is to present it to SuperCell.


So incredibly rare, like the odds are 1 in millions. But lets say this happens, after going through both tiebreaker options, it would be safe to say its a tie. :p

The issue with that, is anyone can 1 star a base using just barch. The number of wins would skyrocket and it wouldn't be a true test of skill.

---

So smart. Such wow. Many :thumbsup: