Loose loot if u don't do more than a certain % demadge.Read

I have think a lot about this idea and have discussed with a lot of my clash friends now i want to share it here.
If u attack someone u have to do at least 30% of total demadge in order to not loose u own resources,even if u get ea one star by a th snipe.u lost loot don't go to the defender player.the lost loot should change depending from the th level
my idea for the lost loot from th7 to th10 because i haven't thought from th6 and down but we can discuss it here
A missed 30% demadge loot loos by th difference
th7 loose 60 k gold 60 k elix 50 dark elix
th8 loose 80k gold 80 k elix 65 dark elix
th9 loose 100k gold 100 k elix 80 dark elix
th10 loose 120 k gold 120 k elix 100 dark elix

Now what advantage could bring this change for the decent and hardcore farmers?
1.drastically drop of th sniping or let's say a guaranted on slowing it down because if u are a full barch th9 sniper to get that 30 % u are obligated to use at least 120 troops which means more time on training troops for the next snipe so it brings more occasions for storage and collector farmers to find more bases for their sessions.
2.eliminates a lot of useless th snipes of th8 sniping a th10 or th9.
3.snipers should think more than twice before hitting an exposed th.

What advantage for supercell?
1.a lot of collector farmers might be forced to buy daily or weekly shields so more profit for supercell here.
2.the loot system might become more fluid

What disadvantage for trophy pushers?
1.of course more time to climb up if it relies only in the attacks but the nightmare lasts only from crystal to master 3 because from my personal experience even now to find a th outside u get it one from 100 of nexting once u get im master 3 and above so not so much difference once i reach masters.

Let's discuss it guys.Just for some info if someone might think that i opened this thread because it might be hard for me finding loot i inform u that i did 250 legos in 25 days.What made me come with this idea?My selfbase with 7.5 m gold and 7.2 m elix everytime i'm without shield i get sniped 9 times from 10.

I don't understand you at all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Victor1234567890

I don't understand you at all.

---

My english is not perfect but the concept is simple.if you don't do at least 30% of demadge when u attack a base u loose resources even if u get 1 star from attacking a th placed outside in the corner.u loose the resources but they don't go to the defender player.This will discourage the players to hit the exposed townhalls and giving shield at players which have their storages full.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Erl86

Let's discuss it guys.Just for some info if someone might think that i opened this thread because it might be hard for me finding loot i inform u that i did 250 legos in 25 days.What made me come with this idea?My selfbase with 7.5 m gold and 7.2 m elix everytime i'm without shield i get sniped 9 times from 10.

---

Let me get this straight....You keep your th out so you can you sniped to get an easy shield, yet you are complaining that they don't raid you for your resources?

Imagine im th7. I have got 20k gold 10k elixir and 10 dark elixir.. What if i didnt get a 30%? My storages will be having negative values??

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xav1

Let me get this straight....You keep your th out so you can you sniped to get an easy shield, yet you are complaining that they don't raid you for your resources?

---

sometimes i keep it out sometimes in i don't bother about it even if i get destroyed by a th10 i will get those resources back in no time from other raids.even when i let it out it passes hours without someone attacking me maybe because i sit on gold2-gold1 but if i move on crystal or even master a lot of players will decide to snipe me th instead of attacking my full sotrages.i'm pretty sure that hardcore farmers would like this idea and the collector farmers would hate it but it depends from supercell for which category cares more.

What if someone loses connection in the middle if the attack? They probably already used most their troops and will probably lose cause they didn't place them all. So they already lost all that elixer used on troops, why add anything else to losing an attack. If someone places their townhall so it can be snipes that's on you. If your townhall is in the middle of your base you aren't getting sniped anymore, unless you rushed but that's also your problem. Seriously I've never heard anyone complain about being sniped and not losing loot. Dude that's a good thing. If you place your th outside your walls and expect nothing to happen then you're foolish, plain and simple.

Putting this in the worst ideas ever section.
Say hello to topics like "Donate to Yourself" and "Remove Bad Leaders" while your there.
Worst:
*Donate to Yourself
*Remove Bad Leaders
*Copy Bases Instantly
**Losing Loot For Failed Attacks(New Addition!)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Erl86

sometimes i keep it out sometimes in i don't bother about it even if i get destroyed by a th10 i will get those resources back in no time from other raids.even when i let it out it passes hours without someone attacking me maybe because i sit on gold2-gold1 but if i move on crystal or even master a lot of players will decide to snipe me th instead of attacking my full sotrages.i'm pretty sure that hardcore farmers would like this idea and the collector farmers would hate it but it depends from supercell for which category cares more.

---

I have to say this is the first time I have ever seen someone complain that their resources aren't getting stolen.

If you want your "full storages" raided then put your th back inside your base....problem solved.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BluBest

Putting this in the worst ideas ever section.
Say hello to topics like "Donate to Yourself" and "Remove Bad Leaders" while your there.
Worst:
*Donate to Yourself
*Remove Bad Leaders
*Copy Bases Instantly
**Losing Loot For Failed Attacks(New Addition!)

---

Now I'm angry because I hate agreeing with you.