bad trophy calculation after last update

dear supercell, i like rha someone explain me what are the new criteria for "cups" aftere the last upgrade.

i was a th8 level 91 until 15 August, and every attacch i received (also only 2% of town hall) i lose 10/12 cup. I belived that was because i was a th8 "maxxed" but i wonder when a th9, level 112 attack me with only queen, made 2 % and take the same 12 cup!!! so i controlle my cups and attaccker cup: they was in the same mu league or BIGGER.

I passed at th9, and i have no th9 defense levele, no th9 wall, always the same troups level and i attacck so much to reach cristal league, but i t was worst! levell 9 and level 10 town hal, with maxxed troup, with my same league of MORe, with also 50 level more than me (145 again 92) take me donw 8/14 cups for attack, and i against level 10 town hall, with more than 20 level in the same my league can gain form 9 to 20 cups for 100% victory again 29/33 if i lose.

with th9 it was again wost, with th8 it was 6 if i win, 30 if i lose (and i have again all troups at level of th8).



It seems that you don't want that a player gain cups also if play a lot and win a lot, and it is not titan league or champions leagues.

can you explain me, why all this unreal situations?

best regards
nagash! from Yun Hysse (level 95, th9)

I don't understand what's so hard to understand about elo/cup system. Cup offerings are a function of the difference between your cups and opponents cups. It has nothing to do with percentage or difference between th levels or your defences.
And when the raid is over total offer is divided by the amount of stars you got.

Here is how trophy offers are calculated

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...scovered%21%21

You are most likely to find people at your townhall level and the +-1 level

When you were max th8 you were likely to find th7-9 (and be found by the same people). Now that you are th9 you are more likely to find (th8-10).

So you will generally be finding higher townhall levels and cup offers should be similar to what they were before. Being a brand new th9 is a terrible time to be trying to climb trophies.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Const

I don't understand what's so hard to understand about elo/cup system. Cup offerings are a function of the difference between your cups and opponents cups. It has nothing to do with percentage or difference between th levels or your defences.
And when the raid is over total offer is divided by the amount of stars you got.

---

this mean that a maxxed th9 that is in silver III can give only 6 cups to a th6 if it made 100%?!?!? it's totally crazy, if so!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nexus6it

this mean that a maxxed th9 that is in silver III can give only 6 cups to a th6 if it made 100%?!?!? it's totally crazy, if so!

---

Yes it is just based on the trophy difference between the attacker and defender not at all to do with the attackers or defenders strength. But I agree if a TH6 100% a max TH9 they should get 1000 trophies :)

At the end of the day who cares? Cups are pretty much useless. They are easy to gain and even easier to lose.

If a th2 can get to Titan than its pretty obvious that cups don't mean much if anything