Defence bonus, surviving troop cost refund, resource exchange centre in new update

Printable View

August 21st, 2015
Toni88

Defence bonus, surviving troop cost refund, resource exchange centre in new update

Well, this is not normal fanboy post cringing for new troops and spell. I want some serious changes in new update. Kindly take time to go through it and support it if you like the idea.

I would love to have some new feature in new coc with possible justification:
1) defence bonus for base who defended attack both in war and multiplayer: the war win bonus alone is not good enough when compared to troops cost deployed to get 3 stars
2) surviving troop cost refund after attack: as heavy troops are used for attack, the troops which are alive after attack should be refunded back
3) increase attack win bonus: seriously guys the win bonus is too low compared to troop cost used when u get to th8 n higher level. Even the loot available decreases significantly.
4) exchange centre building: many a times we have excess of one resource while the other resource is required. An exchange centre to convert one type of reource to other would be awesome. Justification: elixir is used to train troops. So it drains faster compared to gold or dark elixir.

Hope these requests make sense.
August 21st, 2015
hashtagbene

You should post this in the Idea & Requests forum!

Also number 1, 2 and 4 are already ruled out by Supercell!
August 21st, 2015
FisherPrice

1. Don't war if you are worried about war. War isn't about loot and isn't for loot. It's war. That said it would be nice if you could at least cover the costs of your army. I lose DE on every single war. I suggest higher loot bonus BUT prorate it based on the number of stars you get. Something like 1* is 50% of the loot bonus, 2* is 75% of the the loot bonus and of course 3* you get 100%. I don't know. Something so there's more loot but without overly encouraging "looting" in war (hitting really high for barely 1* just to get the loot)

2. No, balance issues. Don't want people training massively overpowered armies for everything and going all out because they get refunds for doing so. If you want to go all out, pay for it.

3. What is this "attack win bonus" you are referring to?? You want higher league bonuses again?

4. No. Everybody who pays attentions knows how bad elixir for walls under level 9 was, this would be even worse.
August 21st, 2015
fieldofdreams

Defense bonus would be nice - in multi it would disincentivize puting the th outside which could have a variety of consequences both positive and negative.

surviving troop refund I am pretty sure has already been ruled out. This is not a new idea.

I find attack win bonuses are great once you reach master. This sounds like a loot complaint for lower lv ths and has almost no chance of being implemented in any material way.

Exchanging center buildings can be done with the existing base layout options.

I believe there is a thread for update requests too so put this there.
August 21st, 2015
fieldofdreams

Miss read #4. No way that is happening. See the first responder.
August 21st, 2015
tellingthetruth

There's already a defensive bonus, it's called trophies.

I know, it's silly, but what are you going to do...
August 21st, 2015
BlindHaze

Number 4. So in effect you just want to scrap either gold or elixir and just have one resource?
August 21st, 2015
Eddiesalita

Number 4 is ridiculous. Utterly.
August 21st, 2015
bbdoc

Quote:

Originally Posted by hashtagbene

Also number 1, 2 and 4 are already ruled out by Supercell!

Just like lots of other stuff that have been implemented now after being ruled out...
August 21st, 2015
hashtagbene

Quote:

Originally Posted by bbdoc

Just like lots of other stuff that have been implemented now after being ruled out...

There's still no point in requesting stuff that is already ruled out
(because SC already knows about it)
August 21st, 2015
SuperR0ck

1) defence bonus for base who defended attack both in war and multiplayer: the war win bonus alone is not good enough when compared to troops cost deployed to get 3 stars

A: Agree 10000% for multiplayer. Right now my TH is outside for easy shield. There are NO justification to protect your TH unless you are in push mode.
Regarding war I don't believe a defense bonus is required, but the winning reward must be severely adjusted. If you consider the amount of time, effort and resources put in war you will see that isn't worth participate in wars. I'm out wars for about 1 month so I can upgrade my heroes and wars.

2) surviving troop cost refund after attack: as heavy troops are used for attack, the troops which are alive after attack should be refunded back

A: Agreed. Everyone use barch because they are fast and cheap. If my surviving troops return, I will consider in use heavy troops. Right now, why should I spend 300K in a army if the resources used don't return.

3) increase attack win bonus: seriously guys the win bonus is too low compared to troop cost used when u get to th8 n higher level. Even the loot available decreases significantly.

A: Agreed. Right now this game sounds like a slot machine where you will depend of luck. Yes luck. Luck of finding a good raid village. You can spend 100 searchs without nothing that worth to be attacked. increase the bonus will make people attack more, bases in the bonus return instead for endless searching..

4) exchange centre building: many a times we have excess of one resource while the other resource is required. An exchange centre to convert one type of reource to other would be awesome. Justification: elixir is used to train troops. So it drains faster compared to gold or dark elixir.

A: It happens basically in TH8, which is the most stupid TH level in this game. It demands 2x more gold then elixir. I suggest everyone to skip this level right after SF, CC, Lab (farm troops only) upgrade. Do some defenses while upgrading to farm troops but move to TH9 asap.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toni88

Well, this is not normal fanboy post cringing for new troops and spell. I want some serious changes in new update. Kindly take time to go through it and support it if you like the idea.

I would love to have some new feature in new coc with possible justification:
1) defence bonus for base who defended attack both in war and multiplayer: the war win bonus alone is not good enough when compared to troops cost deployed to get 3 stars
2) surviving troop cost refund after attack: as heavy troops are used for attack, the troops which are alive after attack should be refunded back
3) increase attack win bonus: seriously guys the win bonus is too low compared to troop cost used when u get to th8 n higher level. Even the loot available decreases significantly.
4) exchange centre building: many a times we have excess of one resource while the other resource is required. An exchange centre to convert one type of reource to other would be awesome. Justification: elixir is used to train troops. So it drains faster compared to gold or dark elixir.

Hope these requests make sense.