New Troop: Wralter

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

August 21st, 2015
WhatwouldJesusdo

Quote:

Originally Posted by sujalthelost

I am sorry but I can't understand which stat should be 60 or less.

60% on dmg tken. Or 50%
August 21st, 2015
789firespawn

This just seems like the Dark Troop version of the Haste Spell. Haste Spell has a 48 speed boost, your has a 50%, and while I can't convert numbers, I'd like to say that I'm sure Haste Spell is more balanced. So signed no since your troop is just a Spell converted to a Troop.
August 21st, 2015
LigiMeon7

Quote:

Originally Posted by 789firespawn

This just seems like the Dark Troop version of the Haste Spell. Haste Spell has a 48 speed boost, your has a 50%, and while I can't convert numbers, I'd like to say that I'm sure Haste Spell is more balanced. So signed no since your troop is just a Spell converted to a Troop.

I protects troop and increases speed. Though it is like haste spell but healer is too like heal spell, please give it try!

And also updated the table
August 21st, 2015
AnthonyVince

While I really like the detail you have put into this (thanks for taking it from the Volcano Mage) I have two concerns.

The first is minor. In trivia, it says the damage boost stacks. I think you forgot to change that when you copied it (unless you changed it already) and I'm not sure what you meant.

And I'm just going to say two abilities that are totally different are not going to work with this troop. Why? If he's increasing the speed of units, they are going to run out of his "aura" which protects them, making the unit pointless. I like the troop as it is without the speed increase ability, but if you want two abilities make it similar enough to the damage decrease feature so it won't wreck everything. :)

P.S. Change the stats, the traps on the outside of the base strategy, and the artwork. Those are all from my thread and I don't really like people taking credit for my ideas. :unsure:
August 21st, 2015
LigiMeon7

Quote:

Originally Posted by AnthonyVince

While I really like the detail you have put into this (thanks for taking it from the Volcano Mage) I have two concerns.

The first is minor. In trivia, it says the damage boost stacks. I think you forgot to change that when you copied it (unless you changed it already) and I'm not sure what you meant.

And I'm just going to say two abilities that are totally different are not going to work with this troop. Why? If he's increasing the speed of units, they are going to run out of his "aura" which protects them, making the unit pointless. I like the troop as it is without the speed increase ability, but if you want two abilities make it similar enough to the damage decrease feature so it won't wreck everything. :)

Thanks for your suggestions Anthony. If I remove the speed ability, then it would just be just like healer. A healer which heals air troops too, nothing else
August 21st, 2015
AnthonyVince

Quote:

Originally Posted by sujalthelost

Thanks for your suggestions Anthony. If I remove the speed ability, then it would just be just like healer. A healer which heals air troops too, nothing else

Well, I'm not really sure. Just be creative. Also, you can tell you copied a bunch of stats and information from my thread, which I'd like you to change. Not just because it's downright copyright, because the stats and information don't match the troop. For example, the DPS, DPA, and attack speed do not match, and you can tell you copied them from the Volcano Mage.
August 21st, 2015
LigiMeon7

Quote:

Originally Posted by AnthonyVince

Well, I'm not really sure. Just be creative. Also, you can tell you copied a bunch of stats and information from my thread, which I'd like you to change. Not just because it's downright copyright, because the stats and information don't match the troop. For example, the DPS, DPA, and attack speed do not match, and you can tell you copied them from the Volcano Mage.

How does it looks now
August 21st, 2015
789firespawn

Quote:

Originally Posted by sujalthelost

I protects troop and increases speed. Though it is like haste spell but healer is too like heal spell, please give it try!

And also updated the table

Heal Spells don't get targeted by defenses, and heal everyone in the radius. This idea is the Haste Spell PLUS protection, so no vote for me.
August 26th, 2015
Livvyboss

As Anthony said, the troop will just run out of the range really quickly with a speed boost. So how about this:

While in the aurora they have quite a bit of protection (the same already stated in the thread)

Once outside the aurora they are given a permanent percentage of protection that lasts the whole battle. This could be as little as 5%. This is not too OP given if it was attacked by a lvl 13 cannon with 98 damage, it would still lose about 93 hp.

I would also decrease the tile radius to 3 seeming as a diameter of 8 is pretty big.

Other than that, nice troop, nice thread, nice concept :thumbsup:
August 26th, 2015
LigiMeon7

Quote:

Originally Posted by Livvyboss

As Anthony said, the troop will just run out of the range really quickly with a speed boost. So how about this:

While in the aurora they have quite a bit of protection (the same already stated in the thread)

Once outside the aurora they are given a permanent percentage of protection that lasts the whole battle. This could be as little as 5%. This is not too OP given if it was attacked by a lvl 13 cannon with 98 damage, it would still lose about 93 hp.

I would also decrease the tile radius to 3 seeming as a diameter of 8 is pretty big.

Other than that, nice troop, nice thread, nice concept :thumbsup:

thanks, I will update that .
And do you mean to remove the speed boost ?

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page