Suggestions to improve the game!!!!

Printable View

August 17th, 2015
Const

Suggestions to improve the game!!!!

REQUEST TO FORUM ADMINS AND MODS: PLEASE DONT MOVE THIS TO IDEAS I ALREADY POSTED IT THERE I JUST WANT TO SEE OTHER PEOPLES CONTRIBUTION AS MOST FORUMERS BROWSE GENERAL EXCLUSIVELY!!
Hello fellow clashers. In this thread i am going to share fix for everything(obviously42). Ofc these are my ideas and not all of them are perfect so dont hesitate to contribute.

Keep Reading :P

Fixing Wars , End to .5 ths!
Offense should effect war weight. Both defense and offense counts towards
stars and victory why not make defence and offense weight balance 50/50

Fixing High Throphy Pushing!
Supercell actually got this half right by setting a limit to throphies at around 5000 throphies. But i think limit should be around 4200 throphies. IF we squeeze all those players in a tighter cup range we will have more people to attack.
Benefits:
+More chance to appear on leaderboards
+Less clouds ,more attacks!

Fixing Revenge System /Button !
Add a queue to revenge system. When a player requests to revenge another player server will add him to a queue. When other player logsoff server will ask if u want to attack before other player appears on multiplayer matchmaking.Queue will have a time out so you won't be queued for ever. Also revenge list length tweaks and maybe a range limiter above champs might be required

Making EQ SPELL worth upgrading!
Currently level 1 eq is as effective as maxxed out eq against any level wall(level 1to 11). Currently with an eq spell you can break through walls that are 5 tiles apart(4 tiles with jump spell). Eq spells radius should increase every level. 5 at max and 2.5 at first level maybe?

Moar Achievements !!
GoldGrab and ElixirEscapede : Steal 1 Billion Gold and elixier.
-We all know 100 million isnt prestidgeous anymore. I got that achievement
at like th7. Damn!
Reach Titans Leauge : 3000 gems
Reach Legends Leauge : 4000 gems

Dragon Hero!
A dragon hero! Unlocked at th10. Fits to th10 fiery theme.
I am not sure if we should have 40 levels to this but it should be as strong as a level 1 dragon at level 1 and as strong as a level 5 drag ar max level (perhaps level 40).

Also to balance we might have to choose between heroes and possibly between queen and dragon hero since they are both ranged.
For special ability i have 2 ideas:

Dive:
Dragon Hero will dive into a desired direction and deal damage to all of the buildings in its way. To balance this i have 2 ideas. It will either can be used when your dragon is low on health or when you use it your dragon will be finitto. It will be gone for the rest of the raid.

Shield:
It will create a short lasting shield that will protect nearby air units from ad bullets and (but nothing else,also maybe airbombs).

Single Player Maps:

I have couple of ideas for this. We can either have a reloading singleplayer map that you can replay after a certain amount of time(a month perhaps)!
Or we can have a competition where players try to create bases with a given amount of defences and buildings and get to vote bases after or maybe avarage stars taken can be used then we will have a monthly leaderboard/new singleplayer campaigns.

Waterfall!
Bring back the waterfall i am willing to sacrifice any amount of decorations to get the waterfall back :D

Supercell Support:
First respond sometimes take upto 3 weeks... I mean you guys can at least send a ticket back. Most of your replies are copy paste anyways :/

Dont hesitate to contribute <3 cheers
August 17th, 2015
Const

Reserved for future use!
August 17th, 2015
Calin2015

I agree with all but dragon hero. I wanted to post the offense mattering in war thing in IFR this days but too lazy.:thumbsup:
August 17th, 2015
targetweek

Offense is included in clan war weight...

However I agree that defense is weighed more heavily.
My reasons:

1. Defense requires no skill or interaction from the player to be effective.
2. Offense requires skill to be effective hence it's lower weight in war matchups. A player could have max troops but so what? They won't deploy snd attack the base for that player. The lower weight (I assume) is to tske this into account.
August 17th, 2015
hoopstime98

Offense does affect war weight, go check out the clan wars FAQ. It just doesn't affect your status on the defensive map (which is for the best, since when I'm attacking someone I don't care what their offense score is).

Some of the dragon hero stuff just makes an already OP air attack even more OP. Given that SC is trying to nerf air attacks with the sweeper, and the 2nd sweeper, this seems unlikely given that air attacks are still ridiculously easy to pull off (they did give Drag 5 to try to help even out 2nd air sweeper).
August 17th, 2015
Const

Quote:

Originally Posted by targetweek

Offense is included in clan war weight...

However I agree that defense is weighed more heavily.
My reasons:

1. Defense requires no skill or interaction from the player to be effective.
2. Offense requires skill to be effective hence it's lower weight in war matchups. A player could have max troops but so what? They won't deploy snd attack the base for that player. The lower weight (I assume) is to tske this into account.

Yea. That's what I tried to say :D
August 17th, 2015
Const

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopstime98

Offense does affect war weight, go check out the clan wars FAQ. It just doesn't affect your status on the defensive map (which is for the best, since when I'm attacking someone I don't care what their offense score is).

Some of the dragon hero stuff just makes an already OP air attack even more OP. Given that SC is trying to nerf air attacks with the sweeper, and the 2nd sweeper, this seems unlikely given that air attacks are still ridiculously easy to pull off (they did give Drag 5 to try to help even out 2nd air sweeper).

I didn't really talk about damage and protection details and be aware they are seperate abilities.It will either be shield or dive not together. If u have any other ability idea Pls share. I will do some number digging and try to come up with numbers. There are some other games that implement this kind of thing and it might not turn out op.
August 17th, 2015
targetweek

If u don't mind I'll reserve this so I can reply to each idea when I get time later.
August 17th, 2015
Cowbug

Quote:

Originally Posted by Const

REQUEST TO FORUM ADMINS AND MODS: PLEASE DONT MOVE THIS TO IDEAS I ALREADY POSTED IT THERE I JUST WANT TO SEE OTHER PEOPLES CONTRIBUTION AS MOST FORUMERS BROWSE GENERAL EXCLUSIVELY!![COLOR=#ff0000][I][B]

What makes you exempt from the forum rules? Ideas and suggestions is its own subforum for a reason. I dont believe you should get to post anything you want in general just because you want more views.
August 17th, 2015
targetweek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cowbug

What makes you exempt from the forum rules? Ideas and suggestions is its own subforum for a reason. I dont believe you should get to post anything you want in general just because you want more views.

I think if he rephrase it, he might be ok.

If his purpose is to "beta test" a new idea in general chat due to the much larger forum activity in general, then take the refined form after discussion and post the finalized idea in the ideas and suggestions area that would make sense to me.
August 17th, 2015
mido2malik

Quote:

Originally Posted by Const

My Favourite ones:

Fixing the War and ending the X.5 TH:
Offense should effect war weight. Both defense and offense counts towards
stars and victory why not make defence and offense weight balance 50/50

Fixing Revenge System /Button !
Add a queue to revenge system. When a player requests to revenge another player server will add him to a queue. When other player logsoff server will ask if u want to attack before other player appears on multiplayer matchmaking.

Making EQ SPELL worth upgrading!
Currently level 1 eq is as effective as maxxed out eq against any level wall(level 1to 11). Currently with an eq spell you can break through walls that are 5 tiles apart(4 tiles with jump spell). Eq spells radius should increase every level. 5 at max and 2.5 at first level maybe?

Moar Achievements !!
Gold Grab and Elixir Escapede : Steal 1 Billion Gold and elixier.
-We all know 100 million isnt prestidgeous anymore. I got that achievement
at like th7. Damn!
Reach Titans Leauge : 3000 gems
Reach Legends Leauge : 4000 gems

Single Player Maps:

I have couple of ideas for this. We can either have a reloading singleplayer map that you can replay after a certain amount of time(a month perhaps)!
Or we can have a competition where players try to create bases with a given amount of defences and buildings and get to vote bases after or maybe avarage stars taken can be used then we will have a monthly leaderboard/new singleplayer campaigns.

Waterfall!
Bring back the waterfall i am willing to sacrifice any amount of decorations to get the waterfall back :D

Supercell Support:
First respond sometimes take upto 3 weeks... I mean you guys can at least send a ticket back. Most of your replies are copy paste anyways :/

Dont hesitate to contribute <3 cheers

(IMO, the in game support is very helpful and they are pretty fast. They don't give you automated replies unless your issue is known. If you have a special issue, they look into it and write you the answer. One time, I had a strange video in which a golem exploded affecting the archer queen's very much but the archers near the queen were not affected. I sent the link to them and they watched the video and gave me the answer)
August 17th, 2015
Const

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cowbug

What makes you exempt from the forum rules? Ideas and suggestions is its own subforum for a reason. I dont believe you should get to post anything you want in general just because you want more views.

Well general is general. You can post anything but spam here :/
August 17th, 2015
Julezwatts

Quote:

Originally Posted by Const

Well general is general. You can post anything but spam here :/

Unless there's another subforum specifically for what you wanted to post. (e.g. you wouldn't post a 'I need a clan!' thread in General because there's another subforum specifically for that.) General is for threads or topics that don't fit in other subforums. Threads and topics in IFR do get seen, so next time please post appropriately to help make sure that things can stay organized.

I think that most of your ideas are good. More details for some parts would be beneficial to flushing out the topics, and I certainly don't think we need any more heroes at this point in the game.
August 17th, 2015
Const

Quote:

Originally Posted by Julezwatts

Unless there's another subforum specifically for what you wanted to post. (e.g. you wouldn't post a 'I need a clan!' thread in General because there's another subforum specifically for that.) General is for threads or topics that don't fit in other subforums. Threads and topics in IFR do get seen, so next time please post appropriately to help make sure that things can stay organized.

I think that most of your ideas are good. More details for some parts would be beneficial to flushing out the topics, and I certainly don't think we need any more heroes at this point in the game.

I already have a counterpart for this thread there. But very few actually look there. And I will improve this post as I have time and ideas. I might also add some numbers.
August 17th, 2015
AxionXD

Revenge is the only one, besides the obvious OP Dragon Hero, that I disagree with.

Not only would your idea bring back cheap shielding, it would make it infinitely easier, defeating the point of modifying revenges to prevent cheap shielding.

The easier you make revenges, the easier it will be to be revenged. Any decent farmer will have far more people on their attack log than their defense log where they took enough loot to make revenge a necessity. If you're looking for revenge to be an easy farming method, then you would have shot yourself in the foot as now people will also be able to revenge you easier as well.

The net gain would not be significant if there even is one, but the negative impact I believe would be devastating.
August 17th, 2015
Const

Quote:

Originally Posted by AxionXD

Revenge is the only one, besides the obvious OP Dragon Hero, that I disagree with.

Not only would your idea bring back cheap shielding, it would make it infinitely easier, defeating the point of modifying revenges to prevent cheap shielding.

The easier you make revenges, the easier it will be to be revenged. Any decent farmer will have far more people on their attack log than their defense log where they took enough loot to make revenge a necessity. If you're looking for revenge to be an easy farming method, then you would have shot yourself in the foot as now people will also be able to revenge you easier as well.

The net gain would not be significant if there even is one, but the negative impact I believe would be devastating.

I don't imagine it making it harder for farmers. I never had trouble revenging someone below masters. This was for throphy pushers. Maybe a range limiter for revenges above 3200??
August 17th, 2015
AxionXD

Quote:

Originally Posted by Const

I don't imagine it making it harder for farmers. I never had trouble revenging someone below masters. This was for throphy pushers. Maybe a range limiter for revenges above 3200??

This is how it'll be harder for farmers. How many people did you attack today? Or let's say Saturday since you probably had more time to raid then. 20? 30? 40 people?

You may have wrecked each of them for 300k of each, 2000+ of DE....

Now each of the 40 people will get into a queue.... to be notified the second you break shield and log off. This would literally break the game for anyone who doesn't spend 6 straight hours boost farming and spending it all before log off...

Now how long can this list of revengees get if you attack 40+ people a day?
August 17th, 2015
johnthepan

good stuff. The Dive thing should be the dragon heros special ability.
August 17th, 2015
Const

Quote:

Originally Posted by AxionXD

This is how it'll be harder for farmers. How many people did you attack today? Or let's say Saturday since you probably had more time to raid then. 20? 30? 40 people?

You may have wrecked each of them for 300k of each, 2000+ of DE....

Now each of the 40 people will get into a queue.... to be notified the second you break shield and log off. This would literally break the game for anyone who doesn't spend 6 straight hours boost farming and spending it all before log off...

Now how long can this list of revengees get if you attack 40+ people a day?

It doesn't queue you forever. Thanks for reminding me I will fix my post shortly. Ofc it has a timeout:)
August 17th, 2015
Laced13

Th9 level 4 pekka!!!!!!

I believe th9 needs a lvl4 pekka to be competitive !
August 17th, 2015
hoopstime98

Quote:

Originally Posted by Const

It doesn't queue you forever. Thanks for reminding me I will fix my post shortly. Ofc it has a timeout:)

It doesn't matter if it queues you forever, the fact that it queues you at all means you're going to get hit by a guy with a specific plan for your base rather than a passerby who stumbles upon you.

Would you rather get hit by a random who stumbles onto your base and snipes your TH? Or have 30 revengers run a train on your storages one after the other, all stopping before you get a shield?
August 17th, 2015
Const

Quote:

Originally Posted by hoopstime98

It doesn't matter if it queues you forever, the fact that it queues you at all means you're going to get hit by a guy with a specific plan for your base rather than a passerby who stumbles upon you.

Would you rather get hit by a random who stumbles onto your base and snipes your TH? Or have 30 revengers run a train on your storages one after the other, all stopping before you get a shield?

Nope. List also has a length. Like 5 players. Timeout will be 10 Mins. There will be a range limiter so you won't get revenged for soo many throphies above titan or maybe champs
August 17th, 2015
Const

Quote:

Originally Posted by Laced13

I believe th9 needs a lvl4 pekka to be competitive !

Nope. Th9 already gets so many lab upgrades. It gets more upgrades than anyother th so. No
August 17th, 2015
Cowbug

Quote:

Originally Posted by Laced13

I believe th9 needs a lvl4 pekka to be competitive !

10 agreements.
August 17th, 2015
Manyolo

Quote:

Originally Posted by Const

Nope. List also has a length. Like 5 players. Timeout will be 10 Mins. There will be a range limiter so you won't get revenged for soo many throphies above titan or maybe champs

So the player who is kicked after 6 hours of playing will be queued in the multiplayer list AND he will be able to be attacked from the first revenger in the list who has a 10 minutes timer? If the kicked player gets attacked before the revenger decides to attack him then people will cry again that revenge system is broken. Plus the second player in the revenge list will never have a chance to attack since the defender will be online again after 10 minutes. Improves nothings and complicates things even more. Just leave it like this.
August 17th, 2015
KiwiZeus

Really not sure why an active farmer in their right mind would want to make revenge easier. You get what, 2 defenses a day? How many attacks? 10? 20? If you are active you are going to be on WAY more revenge lists then people you have on yours. Just ignore revenge as a useless feature, making it better will shoot active farmers in the foot. Also upgrading 2 heroes is bad enough, no more please :p
August 17th, 2015
VanStorm

Clan War improvement: The "Opponents' View" Button

Hey folks i would like to make a suggestion how to improve building clan war bases a little bit.

I always find it interesting how my opponent sees my base, what would he think about my trap placings, how does the "naked base" look like. Of course one could just imagine erasing all the traps but would'nt it be convenient to implement a Button to hide your traps?

Please leave a comment in what you think about that idea!

greetings, Van Storm
August 17th, 2015
Jsinfoster

Idk

You got some good ideas man. But I will tell you as a guy who is over 4700 the revenge thing would be horrible for me. I am online over an hour and then I find like a champ 1. Someone who has like almost 900 trophies less than I do. I hit him for +1. I'm already taking a huge risk by attacking him cause if I lose its -39...... Could you imagine if he could just put his name on a list to get to revenge me? It make me cringe even thinking about it. Last night I got hit for a -19 1 star by a Titan 3.... Could you imagine how bad that would be if if a champ got to revenge?!
August 17th, 2015
Snarg

So, if we are not happy with the views we are getting, we can post whatever we want wherever we want, right?

Sweet! Reserve thext ten replies in this thread for me will ya? I'm going to go dig up some MasterOv YouTube videos!

Oh yeah! I'm going to find some really horrible clan recruitment threads as well. Aaaannnd, I'm going to invite the Black Magic Specialist Baba into this thread as well.

Man, this is going to be AWESOME!
August 17th, 2015
LegionOK

End sandboxing once and for all: each base is only attackable twice and each player can use two different war bases--different ones for each attack.
August 17th, 2015
meonhoc

Please don't make multiple threads to promote your idea. Stick to the on in iFR forum.

Thank you!