Add revenge against clan hoppers that leech troops

Straight forward stuff. Someone new enters clan they say "Hi! can i have troops!"
You do not want seem like your clan is cheap with donations so you give them
troops and they leave the clan. Grrrrrr.....

If they take troops then leave clan without donating at least the
space amount they got then the donators should be allowed to revenge them
to get their elixir back.

Yes only people you know let join but that is impossible. We bring players
in from global chat that seemed fine and they do this all the time

We just had a player and his brother INVITED and they came in we gave
them giants to make them happy then POOF both disappear. The person that
invited them was so mad and embarrassed even.

This would stop these clan hopping leeches pronto lol


Thoughts?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Groovy

Straight forward stuff. Someone new enters clan they say "Hi! can i have troops!"
You do not want seem like your clan is cheap with donations so you give them
troops and they leave the clan. Grrrrrr.....

If they take troops then leave clan without donating at least the
space amount they got then the donators should be allowed to revenge them
to get their elixir back.

Yes only people you know let join but that is impossible. We bring players
in from global chat that seemed fine and they do this all the time

We just had a player and his brother INVITED and they came in we gave
them giants to make them happy then POOF both disappear. The person that
invited them was so mad and embarrassed even.

This would stop these clan hopping leeches pronto lol


Thoughts?

---

No. There's already another post similar to this on the front page.

Your homework assignment is to consider how clan members could and would cooperate to abuse this feature.

Too exploitable.
I.E.- Bob has full storages but has to log off to do something silly like be social in real life. He texts his friends Joe, and says he'll join Joe's clan, request, then leave. Joe will then revenge him and destroy his TH/leave at 40%.
This will just add to the cheap shield problem at the top.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baconman

Too exploitable.
I.E.- Bob has full storages but has to log off to do something silly like be social in real life. He texts his friends Joe, and says he'll join Joe's clan, request, then leave. Joe will then revenge him and destroy his TH/leave at 40%.
This will just add to the cheap shield problem at the top.

---

Or, "Hey Joe you want some gold? I'll join, request, leave and move my storages outside."

or

"Hey Joe want some trophies?"

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Or, "Hey Joe you want some gold? I'll join, request, leave and move my storages outside."

or

"Hey Joe want some trophies?"

---

easy to solve. use a cool down


next!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baconman

Too exploitable.
I.E.- Bob has full storages but has to log off to do something silly like be social in real life. He texts his friends Joe, and says he'll join Joe's clan, request, then leave. Joe will then revenge him and destroy his TH/leave at 40%.
This will just add to the cheap shield problem at the top.

---

come on its so obvious how to tweak so that can't happen

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

No. There's already another post similar to this on the front page.

Your homework assignment is to consider how clan members could and would cooperate to abuse this feature.

---

so you never heard of a cool down before? do your homework and read up on it lol

oh and the same cool down would stop top players leaving and giving each other free shields as well from the same clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Groovy

so you never heard of a cool down before? do your homework and read up on it lol

---

A cool down to do what? Revenge them? Join the clan again? Join another clan?
Do your homework and explain it further than the phrase "cool down"

Is that small of an elixer loss that moor rant to you, really??

Why should you have the ability to revenge me if I feel that your clan isnt a good fit for me??

Cool down? For how long? If I want to visit 20 friends in 20 different clans today, why shouldn't I have the right to do that?

Better yet, rather that discussing this anymore, please read the stickies and do a forum search before you post your original idea.

Also, this thread may cover your idea: http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/59891-Clan-Hopper-Jumping-deterrent-SIMPLE-WAY-Player-History-button

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baconman

A cool down to do what? Revenge them? Join the clan again? Join another clan?
Do your homework and explain it further than the phrase "cool down"

---

there are a number of ways.

one example is if you did a 30 day cool down that a player must
be out of the clan and thus no longer considered a member before donators
can get a donator revenge against that player if that player tried this leech move.

same cool down type can be applied to top players leaving clan then doing a search
knowing that other clan members in top 100 players will show up and then attack them
to give free shield. if a cool down before you can attack former clan member
even just a few days, it would stop some that abuse.

However, cool down may not even be needed.

Simply make it so that the person can only be donator revenged
if that person prior to joining was never in the clan or any same
clan in the past as the donator.

then it will not matter if clan members leave and come back. You were
in the same clan be it your current clan or clans you both were in the past
and so you get no donator revenge.

Heck one of the features i wish we had was a history of all clans
a players was in. It would be nice to see if a player is joining
and leaving 50 clans a week. That would avoid the whole mess to
begin with, since that player would never have been allowed in
the clan in the first place.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Groovy

there are a number of ways.

one example is if you did a 30 day cool down that a player must
be out of the clan and thus no longer considered a member before donators
can get a donator revenge against that player if that player tried this leech move.

same cool down type can be applied to top players leaving clan then doing a search
knowing that other clan members in top 100 players will show up and then attack them
to give free shield. if a cool down before you can attack former clan member
even just a few days, it would stop some that abuse.

However, cool down may not even be needed.

Simply make it so that the person can only be donator revenged
if that person prior to joining was never in the clan or any same
clan in the past as the donator.

then it will not matter if clan members leave and come back. You were
in the same clan be it your current clan or clans you both were in the past
and so you get no donator revenge.

Heck one of the features i wish we had was a history of all clans
a players was in. It would be nice to see if a player is joining
and leaving 50 clans a week. That would avoid the whole mess to
begin with, since that player would never have been allowed in
the clan in the first place.

---

Simple. Supercell will simply purchase a ton more computing power so that they can run database crosschecks across every player's stored clan history every time people switch clans. :rolleyes: All to make it so you don't lose a tiny bit of elixir due to bad clan management.

Also, are you seriously suggesting a 30 day lead time before you can revenge a hopper?

Check out my idea for a clan history button- that solves the problem of clan hopping leachers...

Is it wrong that I clan hop to donate troops?

I don't want level 2/3 troops, but you can have my level 6 and I will take the XP.

Does that make me a bad player?

I did get 4,000 XP Monday from doing this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gulyas1

Is it wrong that I clan hop to donate troops?

I don't want level 2/3 troops, but you can have my level 6 and I will take the XP.

Does that make me a bad player?

I did get 4,000 XP Monday from doing this.

---

Abo♥♥♥♥ely not in my mind. We have had a couple players that did that with us. And i use to know someone in my first clan (been through a cant find a good clan phase after the second clans breakdown which was about 13 different clans didnt hop though ended up like what you did.) that did that.

No way this will EVER happen. Like others have said it is way too exploitable. They would be better off putting a "you must donate 20 troops before you can request troops" to combat clan hoppers.