Introducing Trading, what Clash of Clans really need!

Hello,

Today I'm introducing "trading" in CoC which is trading item for a item/ thing for a thing. The thing that could be traded are troops, elixir, gold and gems. So for example, I have 200 dark elixir I don't need - I trade it for 25,000 gold for example both the players create a deal. It also has disadvantages and advantages.

~Advantages
- Creates a real community
- Creates complex communications between people.
- People would be free minded because they know they will trade something they don't need.
-beneficial

~Disadvanges
-Creates scamming but it could be fixed by putting a system in which no body can give to somebody things without in return something.


This idea could be further developed by supercell.

-Mohd

there is trading in hay day

Ruled out. Read the sticky plz

I'm talkin about coc not hay day.

Why does no one read the sticky?!!!!! It's been ruled out ever since the forums got started!!!! READ THE STICKY SO PEOPLE DON'T HAVE TO SEE STUPID IDEAS BROUGHT BACK!

Stupid? Are you 9? This is clearly not stupid you dumb♥♥♥♥, it's very beneficial.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mohd17

Stupid? Are you 9? This is clearly not stupid you dumb♥♥♥♥, it's very beneficial.

---

It might be beneficial but it would create sooooooo many imbalances. There is a reason some things cost gold, some things cost eixir and some things cost dark elixir. Trading would just make the game imbalanced. And, yes, it was ruled out in the post that says "READ THIS POST FIRST" :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mohd17

Hello,

Today I'm introducing "trading" in CoC which is trading item for a item/ thing for a thing. The thing that could be traded are troops, elixir, gold and gems. So for example, I have 200 dark elixir I don't need - I trade it for 25,000 gold for example both the players create a deal. It also has disadvantages and advantages.

~Advantages
- Creates a real community
- Creates complex communications between people.
- People would be free minded because they know they will trade something they don't need.
-beneficial

~Disadvanges
-Creates scamming but it could be fixed by putting a system in which no body can give to somebody things without in return something.


This idea could be further developed by supercell.

-Mohd

---

Read the stickies. Good idea but someone will create 10 accounts and give all the resources to one super account. (Basically 10x income plus income already getting) Once they figure out how to recent that then they might... They might allow it.

Let's keep the aggressive tone down please on both sides or Daddy will have to get his ban hammer out.

Talking to people with respect breeds respect

Enabling the option in which you can't trade same ip's will not make people transfer resources to 1 super account.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mohd17

Hello,

Today I'm introducing "trading" in CoC which is trading item for a item/ thing for a thing. The thing that could be traded are troops, elixir, gold and gems. So for example, I have 200 dark elixir I don't need - I trade it for 25,000 gold for example both the players create a deal. It also has disadvantages and advantages.

~Advantages
- Creates a real community
- Creates complex communications between people.
- People would be free minded because they know they will trade something they don't need.
-beneficial

~Disadvanges
-Creates scamming but it could be fixed by putting a system in which no body can give to somebody things without in return something.


This idea could be further developed by supercell.

-Mohd

---

Even if you did put a system in it would have to have a ratio cuz otherwise it would make some clans OP very easily can be xploited too easlly

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mohd17

Enabling the option in which you can't trade same ip's will not make people transfer resources to 1 super account.

---

This would be trivial to get around too. For example I put my ipad on the wifi and my phone on 4G.

Basically a resource exchange system would greatly reduce available loot since people would simply exchange resources they didn't need for ones they did and spend them all.

A resource trading system would be even worse. It opens the door to a ton of possible exploits. Multiple farm accounts, resource hiding, etc...

Sorry folks, but in the sticky is:

Ruled Out:
Devs have related that these ideas are "Ruled Out", please do not start threads asking for them, they will just be locked.
* Donating (or trading) resources or gems to (with) other players

It is not something the developers with to pursue.