Suggestion Thread To End All

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Coomberlane

*sighs*
Why not just let people posts their new ideas and super cell decide? There is already a common ideas & ruled out ideas sticky, so let people read that rather than your shorter version?

---

Umm...I don't see what that has to do with my thread...these are just some suggestions I've mixed into one big thread.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

Not really... You need to be th 8 to get pekkas in the CC, and th 6s can already get maxed drags, they just need to be in a good clan. Just makes it easier to get troops.

---

I don't think you understand. Clan Bank let's you take troops and add into your ARMY, not CC. And while thanks for clarifying CC level, I still believe it should be ruled out. It makes it easier to get troops, but it would imbalance the game. You can have very good CC troops (Level 3 CC with a Max Drag or Wiz), and with the Clan Troop Bank, you can pull in troops to your ARMY CAMPS. So, like Spells, they'd be using troops they don't have yet. I mean, TH5s with Level 5 Dragon army?

(By the way, I'm glad we aren't people that cuss each other out in debates)

1. Healer Tower (RO): I've seen quite many of these towers, but as you can see, SC didn't rule out any tower or troop suggestions yet, meaning they want to give people the chance of suggesting anything and perhaps coming with interesting effects, stats, anything really..

2. Flying Witch (RO): If SC would start to rule out troop ideas, this could perhaps go there. I didn't see it suggested that often, maybe because I am not that active in the spells/troops suggestions sub-forum.

3. Collect All Resources (RO): Please Please Please.

4. Lower Wall Price (RO): Yes, totally agreed. Suggested a lot but with no chances in my opinion.

5. Clan Bank (RO): The topic made by Kowalski gives a really good version of this, I don't think it needs to be ruled out.

6. Target Spell (RO): Again, no spells were added at ruled out yet and I don't think SC intends to start doing so. As much as I disagree with this spell, who knows, maybe somebody will come with a good version of it.

7. Own Clan Castle (RO): I don't really understand this one, but if it suggests a secondary CC, then it has no chances of being added. Still, I didn't see this suggested in some time, if what I wrote here is the idea you are talking about.

8. Valkyrie Improvement (GS): The housing space is ok I think, the training time is also fine considering this troop's damage/hitpoints.

9. Sabotaging Troop (GS): Could be added, yes.

10. Hero Updates (GS): Yep, add all 3.

11. Global Chat Updates (GS):
a. I don't think this is either a problem, nor that suggested. Don't think it should be added.
b. It's pretty hard to have a proper censor list of words, but maybe they could take another look at it.
c. Don't think it's needed, might be private information belonging to the clan members only.

12. Private Chats (GS): Nah too complicated imo.

13. Reply Notification (FS): I know there is an option to subscribe to threads, but don't know sure how it works. Is it that what you want, if so, try the option as it already exists.

14. No FPS in Ideas and Feature Requests (FS):
a. Make it minimum.. 50 might be too much. I could go with like 20.
b. This would be too much work for the moderators. Also they just added the GS, doubt they would add another group of trusted members.

15. Group Update (FS): Might be too hard to add. The forums are limited to what content they can add on them.

16. Army Camps (GS): not really needed.

17. Invisibility Spell (RO): This is already added in the sticky topic but under "might come". It can stay there, it's not like adding it to the ruled out would make any difference.

18. Clan Updates (GS): requirements tab? Also, the war log is private information who should only be seen by the members of the clan, I wouldn't make this information public.

Huh this took a while.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Coomberlane

*sighs*
Why not just let people posts their new ideas and super cell decide? There is already a common ideas & ruled out ideas sticky, so let people read that rather than your shorter version?

---

Yes, but this explains why they are ruled out, and why the common ideas are not ruled out and explains them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheMightyCats

Yes, but this explains why they are ruled out, and why the common ideas are not ruled out and explains them.

---

Exactly. These are a few improvements and a few things that should should be ruled out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 789firespawn

I don't think you understand. Clan Bank let's you take troops and add into your ARMY, not CC. And while thanks for clarifying CC level, I still believe it should be ruled out. It makes it easier to get troops, but it would imbalance the game. You can have very good CC troops (Level 3 CC with a Max Drag or Wiz), and with the Clan Troop Bank, you can pull in troops to your ARMY CAMPS. So, like Spells, they'd be using troops they don't have yet. I mean, TH5s with Level 5 Dragon army?

(By the way, I'm glad we aren't people that cuss each other out in debates)

---

I am too. And it seems you have a severe case of "I misread the threaditis".
The donations go directly into the CC.
DEFINITELY time to make that as obvious as possible now...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 789firespawn

(WARNING: EXTREMELY LONG THREAD)
Key:
(RO) = Rule Out
(GS) = Game Suggestion
(FS) = Forum Suggestion

1. Healer Tower (RO)
This would make attacking so much harder. Keeping one in the core with some Inferno Tower's, ADs, and XBOWs would be way too OP and cause 3 stars to become nearly impossible.

Totally agree

2. Flying Witch (RO)
I mean, it seems pointless. Do we really need a flying Witch?

Witches are weak as it is. Do we REALLY want to have to deal with air defenses?

3. Collect All Resources (RO)
I don't know why people think tapping a screen 14 times is such a huge issue. I mean, traps are different because you need to rearm them, however, I believe that this feature is just for people too lazy to a few taps when they probably do over 14 in a raid.

No clue WHY this is needed. Just more server space.

4. Lower Wall Price (RO)
OK, I know, farming walls is hard. But if you lower the price, think of it this way. Millions upon millions play this, and think of all the TH8-10s that grinded walls. If this update came out, think of all the backlash that would happen since others dont have to pay as much and get walls done faster, while they had to do it there long hard way.

Walls are no problem. Farm, or gem the resourses.

5. Clan Bank (RO)
(Incoming criticism)
Alright, as much as I'd like this suggestion, numerous problems could happen. For example, this could be like donating resources, and a second account or more could just pile troops in for other account, or keep an ENTIRE army in their waiting while they BARCH/Snipe/etc.

Additionally, their could be trolls or members that hog troops to themselves, or set up very strict restrictions, such as only certain members can take from Clan Bank.

People don't understand the strain on the game if this was added. An entire new (And unnescecary) GUI would cause lag.

6. Target Spell (RO)
Probably ruled out already, but 12 Level 5 Dragons with 4 Freeze Spells, Target Spell, and a Rage Spell is not everyone's cup of tea.

...

7. Own Clan Castle (RO)
For those unaware, basically a building you put your own troops in to defend. It'd be unbalanced. Two Level 5 Dragons/Two Level 5 PEKKAs? No thanks.

Haven't heard this one before. Still bad.

8. Valkyrie Improvement (GS)
The most underrated troop, who while good, has so many flaws when it comes to preferences. First off, training time is obsurd. A 5 minute training time is much better than 8. Second, housing space down just by 1. Third, lower the expensive cost.

But icing on the cake, Level 5 for TH10 so it is usuable in higher league raids/higher base raids.

I've said that it should take redused damage when spinning. Kind of like it's hitting the projectiles.

9. Sabotaging Troop (GS)
What I see frequently requested is a troop that sabotages defenses. Decrease range, damage, fire rate, etc. For example, my Tree Ent idea (*cough* Check it out! *cough*) decreases damage/fire rate for a brief period of time. This could add a new level of strategy to the game.

I don't like these kind of troops. It would make raids to easy when I can make something like an inferno tower do half damage.

10. Hero Updates (GS)
Starting off fast, graphical updates. They only have 3 changes. Instead, why not give them different looks overtime. The King could go from how he looks to medieval style, with chain mail, logo (Clan logo?), and bigger, sharper sword, while the Queen could have a revolutionary looking XBOW, and different clothing overtime.

I would love to see this.

Second, give XP when upgrading. Like the Wall decrease price, this will affect players that grinded and gained no XP, so unless it's possible to give XP earned, this one stretches a bit.

Do other buildings give XP when upgrading? If so then yes. If not then no.

Third, use DE to heal. I saw this idea as really good. Not everyone has Gems (wasted mine on donating) so using DE would be great.
Healing is essentially a boost, and should be treated as one. Gems only.

11. Global Chat Updates (GS)
(a) Invite spamming. Have the ability to block invites from coming to you [either everyone or specific people].
(b) Fix censor machine. Haven't seen this pop up, but having "I need a good Clan", "Coke", "kill", "by the way" censored while (apologies) "d*mn" and "a*s" uncensored is pretty bizzare.
(c) When viewing Clan you can see if they are currently in War.

I agree with B and C. A I really don't find a problem, You keep sendin, I keep rejectin.

12. Private Chats (GS)
First off, NOT a Clan. This would be available for those to chat in privately. It would cost 1,000,000 gold/1,000,000 elixer/10,000 dark elixer EACH to make it. Leader (only one) can invite people only one time every 12 hours. He/she can kick, mute, or ban from chat. For privacy reasons, those already in a private chat cannot be invited, and you can toggle whether you want invites or not. This one I know not likely, but I thought it'd be good alternative to high levels unable to chat in global.

I would lower the price and make it so it doesn't have to start in a clan. 1 million is rediculous for those TH5 or 6 who want to talk.

13. Reply Notification (FS)
I hate having to search which thread I posted on if I have been replied to. Perhaps a reply notification so I know someone's responded to me.

Only in certain sections. This would be annoying in the game section, and find 30 responces to my game. Expecially one of those games which I start, but REALLY don't have to look over.

14. No FPS in Ideas and Feature Requests (FS)
Fresh Posting Spawns. I know, I'm like a debate person here (Trump I'm looking at you) but anyways, a few ways to solve this is that:

(a) Post limit in sub section
(b) If person has under 50 posts, thread must be approved by moderator/trusted person to see if it is a ruled out idea. I know, this would pain the Mods, so perhaps the "Welcome to forums, ruled out" people that post could do that job. So a new group to trusted members to delete threads that don't follow sticky rules.

I VOLUNTEER!!!!!!!!! PICK ME!!!!!!!!!!! MEMEMEMEMEMEMEMEMEMEMEMEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

15. Group Update (FS)
Have it almost like separate forum. Home page with editable message, tabs to view threads, members, chat, etc.

I don't get what you wan't here.

16. Army Camps (GS)
I understand people chill out there, but standing around running while something burns seems just odd. Maybe a minor change. Barbs could be sharpening swords, Balloons moving bombs, etc.
Would be interesting. Not immediately nescecary, but interesting.

17. Invisibility Spell (RO)
What makes troops invisible, Cannons can't fire on it, and is copied straight from Boom Beach?

See, if 14 was implemented, we would never see these.

18. Clan Updates (GS)
New Requirements tab, War Log available to people not in Clan.

I dont think we need more requirements. Would love to check war logs though.

Thanks for reading. If you wish to reply, just type number and your opinion. I'm sorry I'm unable to credit people who've suggested some of this stuff. Thank you and clash on!

---

Answers in bold. Also, for the forum updates, mods should be allowed to shut down petitions. I'm tired of people making them, getting unlimited bumps, when they could have done the SAME thing with a poll.

Add heroes usable during war to RO list.XD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

I am too. And it seems you have a severe case of "I misread the threaditis".
The donations go directly into the CC.
DEFINITELY time to make that as obvious as possible now...

---

Wait...so...that just means you can just take troops instead of requesting? What's the point?

The Healer tower is not ruled out!

i tower for every troop is.