Printable View
I would suggest to Clash Of Clans Community that the game will be better if there is like spell donate when someone request troops from the clan castle. Then,we can share spells among of us. You can create in the clan castle like requesting spells.I hope you understand.
Thanks for your appreciation from coc player :JOSHUA KHALIB
The issue spell donations would raise is that low level players would get access to much developed spells, or to spells they didn't even unlock yet.
Imagine the drastic changes this would bring in the game.. th 5 or 6 with a Freeze Spell or with Rage Spells? There is a reason those TH levels don't have access to these spells and I believe it should stay the way it currently is; I'd rather not see TH5 players running around and freezing things in their way.
Even if you would make it so that they can only donate the spells they unlocked, there would still be the issue of donating a much higher spell level to a lower th player, which would again unbalance the game.
The best and most optimum solution is the current one and I wouldn't change it this much.
I think this idea was frequently requested and ruled out by SC,but lazy at doing those quotes :P .Anyway,if you are a th8 with a jump/freeze spell,won't you think it might be too OP?Normally in CW,th8 will fight against th8.If you actually brought a jump/freeze,it will be an insane GoWiPe(for th8).
If we can give a max hog or max balloon to level 3 th then we should be able to give them a higher rage or heal or freeze spell:)) just saying
If we can give a max hog or max balloon to level 3 th then we should be able to give them a higher rage or heal or freeze spell:)) just saying!
While that sounds fun, troop donations work because they work in both defense and offense meaning it balances(You can attack a th4 with max hogs but to counter that, that th4 could have max wizards to protect him).
The problem with spell donation is that they cant be "countered" by spells within the defenders CC thus throwing it off balance.
then what about the th6 gets a dragon when they request troops from clan castle??then how about a th5 gets a healer then it's freakin out when they attack somebody with th4 using giant and healer but th5/4..??? How about it devil9394
There's absolutely NOTHING wrong about TH3's receiving a level 3 Dragon. It just helps them win the battle more quickly. Well yeah, the same rules apply to lower level Town Halls having higher-ranking Spells, but it's way too OP to have even a TH4 to have Freeze Spells.Quote:
Originally Posted by Joshuakhalib
SC doesn't like having OP stuff, or anything that unbalances their games. I mean, Freeze Spells on a TH3?! Jump Spells on a TH4?! Rage Spells on a TH5?!?! Are you kidding me?
Also, I've just thought of this:
Higher-ranking Troops being donated to lower-leveled Town Halls? Look, it just teaches them how to use those troops properly as they have specific strengths and weaknesses. For Spells, well...there are no weaknesses when it comes to battling, as you can drop them anywhere, though some have specific requirements. It's just best to have Spells be unlocked for the required levels, rather than everyone of all TH levels having Spells.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ashleyc
Kindly please do not double post.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ashleyc
^This cool guy explains all.Quote:
Originally Posted by DARWINIANS
Quote:
Originally Posted by DARWINIANS
The CC space at TH3 is 10, dragons need 20 space. TH3-4 have no SF, and hence should not be made to receive spells anyways.
I think this idea is abit legit. Max loons and hogs are also a very extreme imbalance at lower level THs. Not everyone can have strong CC troops defending, and not everyone has even a clan. But thats what the game is, you become strong or get crushed.
Donating spells will teach new players about the spells they will one day use too. It can be just made as so that the spells you can receive is severely limited, lose a levels or two during donation, or has a longer cooldown period to request.
A TH8 GoWiPe with jump spell? Well is is fair when that TH8 has max pekka in his CC and then proceeds to destroy the base of the guy who only has wizards and archers in base CC?
Nothing is fair, thats the law of nature.
Trust me, two black balloons are MORE OP than frozen spell. I beg you haven't ever tried before. If you does not throw the frozen spell very well, you still will lose. However, wherever you tap only two black balloons to a lower TH, you can win anyway. Which one is more OP?Quote:
Originally Posted by DARWINIANS
Donating higher spell to lower TH also can teach them how to use those spells properly.
"there are no weaknesses when it comes to battling" It sounds like clan troops have weaknesses. Could you tell me what is the weakness of clan troop? These troops will attack your troop during battling, won't they?
That might be the law of nature, but "If you don't make this fair, I will file a lawsuit" is the law of humanity. I'm not saying somebody can sue supercell. I'm saying that it needs to be fair or people will cryQuote:
Originally Posted by Mbdking
Like already stated, higher troops for lower levels is fair because everyone has an equal chance at getting into a good clan with high level donators. It equals out, as everyone has a fair chance at it. However, with spells, there's no defending spells, so there's no canceling out.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mbdking
Troops in CC's adds more strategy because if used correctly, you can cancel both out, but to your advantage. There's no strategy in a TH4 having rage spell though.
Also, this isn't nature, this is CoC. (isn't that SC's job? To make CoC balanced and fair?)
If everyone has the same chance to get a frozen spell from higher TH, that's enough to say that this idea is fair.Quote:
Originally Posted by Callywally
The fair you mentioned above actually is not a fair thing, but a balance between offensive and defensive. And please keep in mind, there should be a little unbalance between attack and defence so that people can raid loot from others.