Clan War, should i let them loot or not?

Hi guys. I have a clan that will turn level 4 later, we war always, and we have 20 wins, 1 loss, and 2 draws. I have members and ex-members that find our clan war rules too strict and against to it. This rule is no if the enemies' bases are already 100% destroyed, I allow them to loot but i don't let them go up, example, his number is 13, I don't let him loot above 12 because i find it unfair for those who go down just to 3star/clean the enemy's base and for our clan to win and theirselves(who are against my rule), want to go up because there is nothing left to attack and want to go up to loot. And I think they just wait for someone to clean teammate's mess, so they could loot. Some leave my clan because they are against my clan war rules, and I don't know if should let them loot or should I let them leave. My question is, is my rule too strict? And why?

I really really need help, any tip/help will be appreciated too. Thanks.

If you are a serious war clan you should not have loot attacks. If you have everything 3 starred then 2nd attacks should be a 3 star army against a challenging base for practice. No one is a perfect attacker and everyone needs to learn how to plan and execute attacks. When the war is already won There is no better time to try new things.

Your rules are fine. It's much better to win and maybe have a little less loot by securing a three star lower down than to have no loot because you lose the war by chancing a high level looting.

Stars before loot always!

Yes you may lose some ppl who just want it their own way but you will find new ones and you'll build up,a core of likeminded warriors and then it establishes as a culture. Stick to your guns and be patient, you'll succeed in the end and have a beautiful green war log :)

I do two levels of "loot". The first if a war is looking good and then I allow "flex" attacks. Those need to be war type attacks but I don't care what base you attack as long as it isn't 3 starred. So if a th7 wants to try their luck on a maxxed th9 go for it.

This let's people try new tactics, new armies and also let's the th7 peeps ( who honestly don't usually turn a profit in war) make some money. The other benefit is it forces people to try attacking stronger bases than they usually would. And that helps with tactics as they upgrade.

Then (rarely ) in the last hour we call pure loot. But we also have a rule that th7 players have to be done with attacks in first 12 hours so they can get shut out of those.

If clan wars already win 100% , i thinks its ok for looting ..
:o

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kelvinnj

If clan wars already win 100% , i thinks its ok for looting ..
:o

---

I think so too, but if you notice a player who always holds his second attck just for the opportunity to loot then you have an issue.

If all of the viable targets for a player are 3 starred then let them run a practice attack on an already 3 starred base. If yhat happens to be a few spots higher, that is ok, so long as they are going for the 3 star. No barch, Bag, bam allowed.

Look, if you are you serious war clan then folks should be concerned about stars not loot. Tell folks to raid for loot. War is for the challenge of hitting hard bases.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sutemi

If all of the viable targets for a player are 3 starred then let them run a practice attack on an already 3 starred base. If yhat happens to be a few spots higher, that is ok, so long as they are going for the 3 star. No barch, Bag, bam allowed.

Look, if you are you serious war clan then folks should be concerned about stars not loot. Tell folks to raid for loot. War is for the challenge of hitting hard bases.

---

Then the question the OP may need to answer is if he is happy with the size of his clan and the turn over rate. He may be a serious war clan with not so serious members.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jwp721

Then the question the OP may need to answer is if he is happy with the size of his clan and the turn over rate. He may be a serious war clan with not so serious members.

---

If the members are not serious about war then why even try to win? Just barch every base and get xp...

But that leads to a defeated attitude because no one likes losing, even intentionally. Winning is,a great morale booster. Kick the ones who only think about themselves rather that the clan, they are not good clanmates.


You will build a cadre of like minded folks who will do whatever it takes to win. You need stars on that silly th5 at the bottom? They will hit it. You need a scouting attack on a th10 to see what is in the cc? They will do it even though it means they get no stars.

Because what they want is for the clan to win. Obviously that is not every war, usually the best thing is to 3 star a similar level village. And they will, because they care enough to practice their attacks.

Trust me. Looting is a cancer, don't do it and purge those that do.

Ohh, so that's why. I thought there was something wrong with my rule.Thank you guys, I appreciated your answers very much.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sutemi

If all of the viable targets for a player are 3 starred then let them run a practice attack on an already 3 starred base. If yhat happens to be a few spots higher, that is ok, so long as they are going for the 3 star. No barch, Bag, bam allowed.

Look, if you are you serious war clan then folks should be concerned about stars not loot. Tell folks to raid for loot. War is for the challenge of hitting hard bases.

---

.....This!