Awesome idea (seriously)

I checked to see if this was one of the rejected ideas and its not there. this is happening to me right now, i changed my war base to a 2 star proof base! But my clan members are saying they can easily 3 star me. So i said, man i wish they would let CLAN MEMBERS try their attack on other clan members WAR BASES. This can only be done 1 time in the preparation day.

idea is awesome to me. if supercell would like to add on to it.. say if the clan member do indeed gets 3 stars on the other member, his resources does not change, but less than 100 percent, he lost his resources.

what do you guys think?????

You are right, it is not in the ruled out list, but I hope it will be soon, I messaged Daddy to add it..
It is too exploitable, people could set their bases to match one of their opponents from war and use that practice to try a 3 star attack on them, learn from the mistakes and don't repeat them in war. I'm afraid this is not going to happen. If you want to learn about your base faults, then look at the attacks of the opponents on the base and change it according to them.

spys frm the enemy cland wud use this

This would make sandboxing a lot easier, which kills the point of the game.

how about this idea then, after war is over, let the 2 clans communicate to each other. to tell each other good game or what ever. its too silent, sometimes the war can be real epic! can we at least talk to each other for a few minutes until we all go our seperate ways? at the results page let their be a box that says "conversation" between the 2 clans, what ever is posted their can be viewed by all clan members from both clans. then it expires after a few hours, or after any of the 2 clans start another war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoyoyusuf

how about this idea then, after war is over, let the 2 clans communicate to each other. to tell each other good game or what ever. its too silent, sometimes the war can be real epic! can we at least talk to each other for a few minutes until we all go our seperate ways? at the results page let their be a box that says "conversation" between the 2 clans, what ever is posted their can be viewed by all clan members from both clans. then it expires after a few hours, or after any of the 2 clans start another war.

---

This would make Global Chat look like Bible Study... Honestly, the verbal abuse would just be so enormous..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Callywally

This would make Global Chat look like Bible Study... Honestly, the verbal abuse would just be so enormous..

---

I like how everyone assumes the 2 clans would say "good job!" and "nice war!". 15 year olds would go rampant when they rage out from losing a war and unleash every expletive they know. That isn't even bringing into account the number of foreign clans everyone faces and the language barrier.

I should learn to avoid any threads starting with "great idea" or "awesome idea". I already know that the idea's inside are not anywhere near what the title suggests.

You should be able to find out how well your base handles within 24 hours of starting a war....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yanks8981

I should learn to avoid any threads starting with "great idea" or "awesome idea". I already know that the idea's inside are not anywhere near what the title suggests.

---

It's a pet peeve of mine when people make generic thread titles too...

The game is set up for us to learn through trial and error of real battles with real gains and losses, much like life, haha.

If you want to congratulate your opponent, have one of your members join right after the war with a personalized join request.

If they want to hear from your clan, they can let this person in (and kick them at the first sign of trouble).