Printable View
Too many selfish members join and request reinforcements, but never give anything. Kick one out, two selfish join. So can request dimmed when give:request greater than 1:x and/or request - give greater than y? Possible?
or need gems to reactive their request?
Or put your clan on "Invite Only" and only accept those who want to stay in your clan. If one joins and asks for troops, kick him out.
+1 for above.
Why not just tell the clan during chat not to donate to immediate requesters ? Name and shame in-clan.
It lets everyone know how you feel and puts the newcomer on notice. I know some people donate instinctively but the whole clan needs to be on the same page.
A simple rule to implement is to have all newbies donate before they request, to prevent easy hopping.
Shame by username? Will they?
please help us to play nice and fair.
I told you, put the clan on Invite Only and that should do the job. It's nice and fair and keeps trolls out. Still, those trolls who get past this gate can be dealt with with a simple kick.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hkmins
If they genuinely want to stay in your clan, yes it will. If they are just hoppers, does it matter ?Quote:
Originally Posted by Hkmins
But, let’s look at it a different way. If you don’t tell people they should donate before they request, is it fair to just kick them (as you stated in your initial post) ?
If it’s a clan rule, it should be public knowledge in your clan and people should follow rules.
If it isn’t a clan rule then why do you want SC to create this system ?
One of the stats we always check before Accepting new members in Friends in Need. If its super low for their th level then its a quick Decline.
Don't give better than tier one to new people until they donate.
Do you really want people with LVL 2 archers donating? Unless there arent many people in your clan, I've always told newer members to ask away and dont feel like they need to donate until their troops are better. If you put pressure on them, they will feel like they must and donate junk. I personally dont mind junk for my loot runs as I generally barch and use CC for a final structure for a 50% one star, but some may not want lvl 3 loons when looting.
1. Any critical rules that are important to you should be in Clan Description. (i.e. New members must donate at least X troops before requesting for yourself.)
2. Not everyone sees chat. Send an email to your members so they know the rule. (i.e. Hey guys! When new players join our clan, tell them that they need to donate 50 troops before they request. Give one warning before kicking.)
3. This applies to any issues you have with new members. Make your rules clear, make sure your clan knows them, and enforce them with no exceptions.
Happy Clashing!
Who has to pay penalty for selfish? Clan leader, co-leader and elder!?
We need set invite only, check friend in need, accept invitation, interview, give them troops, send them clan mail warning, final kick them out.
then Repeat and repeat?
Selfish just kick join clan a, clan b, wait, say yes accept rules, ask, ask, ask, ask, ..., be kicked out.
Just kick them out of your clan
Lol?! If you think creating a clan is and should be easy, you're in for a nasty surprise. You gotta put in dedication if you create your own clan! That's the POINT! It takes work. That's why you have several trusty Co's to help you.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hkmins
If you don't have the management skills and don't wanna dedicate yourself to it, then just join an already strong clan.