Removing inferno anti heal

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

July 26th, 2015
steelseth

Quote:

Originally Posted by thebuch4

Read that every time I post and you respond, you harass me? Yeah, I've noticed that. Now, how many TH9s are three starring other maxed TH9s with giant healer?

And if this is the reason not to, wouldn't it be easier to nerf queen/healer range and bring balance to TH10 attacks? Or are you going to tell me that because I'm not a TH10, I can't state that TH10 offense/defense is not balanced even though everyone knows it?

FYI, I wasnt replying to you .... you are the one that took it upon youself to respond to me and tell me how wrong I was because apparently you know all things clash.

Whos harassing who here ?

It easy, you dont like my comments dont respond to me or maybe read them and learn something.
July 26th, 2015
samc233

The only really con about it is that it's very tough for th9's to counter multi infernos. Everything else is fine
July 26th, 2015
FisherPrice

Quote:

Originally Posted by Saleh47

I would say better add a lvl to freeze. Removing this ability means hogs/giants will dominate most attacks. I can see open bases 3 starred really easy. As much as I have used GoWiWi at th9 I can see 3 stars at th10 getting really easy especially against open bases or circular bases.

Just imagine 20 lvl7 giants with healers and healing, rage and jump behind them. What would stop that?

lvl6 giants at TH9 seem more powerful than lvl7 giants at TH10 (because of all the TH10 defenses additions and upgrades)...and TH9 already gets max rage, max heal, and max healer.

If it were so easy to just use mass giant/healer for success in war why aren't TH9's doing it? It would be more powerful for TH9 vs TH9 than TH10 vs TH10.
July 26th, 2015
thebuch4

Quote:

Originally Posted by steelseth

FYI, I wasnt replying to you .... you are the one that took it upon youself to respond to me and tell me how wrong I was because apparently you know all things clash.

Whos harassing who here ?

It easy, you dont like my comments dont respond to me or maybe read them and learn something.

Oh, I'm sorry that you posted something blatantly wrong and I pointed it out. Do I know all things clash? Of course not. But I do know that what you were saying is preposterous.
July 26th, 2015
thebuch4

Quote:

Originally Posted by samc233

The only really con about it is that it's very tough for th9's to counter multi infernos. Everything else is fine

And the fact that max TH10s are virtually impossible to three star, which is the serious problem with a three star system.

What is preferable? TH9s where a multitude of potential three star strategies exist, or TH10 where there are just a couple of two star strategies because of the OP inferno tower?
July 26th, 2015
SuperR0ck

Quote:

Originally Posted by arunt

Actually, think of how hard it will be for TH11 to raid TH10 bases for loot! If TH10 loot was pretty bad for quite some time, imagine what will be TH11 farming like :eek:

Yes and LOL!
I guess TH11 will have to rely on high league for win bonuses. 50% loot penalty will not worth to get loot from TH9.

Quote:

Originally Posted by arunt

But I digress. Honestly, I do not see any problem with healing being allowed when under inferno fire. Multi-infernos will still shred low hp troops when not under heal, and how many healing spells can you take when attacking a strong TH10 anyway? You already need those jumps and rages. Single target will still not care for heal.

I see it being truly effective for troops like giants, valkyries and hogs. Maybe Supercell could run simulations and see if this is balanced?

I can't answer that because there is no way to test it. Like you said, maybe SC did some simulations. Maybe hogs will be killed by multi-infernos even under healing ... Only SC knows.
Any way
July 26th, 2015
steelseth

Quote:

Originally Posted by thebuch4

Oh, I'm sorry that you posted something blatantly wrong and I pointed it out. Do I know all things clash? Of course not. But I do know that what you were saying is preposterous.

From your point of view it must seem wrong because you know .... there is no youtube video of it ... so it must not be possible.
July 26th, 2015
thebuch4

Quote:

Originally Posted by steelseth

From your point of view it must seem wrong because you know .... there is no youtube video of it ... so it must not be possible.

If it was happening, then TH9s would quickly find out about it, and every TH9 on TH9 war would be nothing but queen healer like TH7s is nothing but dragons vs dragons. but guess what. it isn't. Because you're wrong, and are resorting to the "you're not a TH9 or TH10 therefore you're not allowed to have an opinion" argument again.

So what does "my POV" have to do with anything?
July 26th, 2015
steelseth

Quote:

Originally Posted by thebuch4

If it was happening, then TH9s would quickly find out about it, and every TH9 on TH9 war would be nothing but queen healer like TH7s is nothing but dragons vs dragons. but guess what. it isn't. Because you're wrong, and are resorting to the "you're not a TH9 or TH10 therefore you're not allowed to have an opinion" argument again.

So what does "my POV" have to do with anything?

I imagine pentaloon would seem just as preposterous to you before youtubers made it popular. You must have thought ... those flying pigs only do 14 dps, they are useless ... I need more loons .... 16 loons are not enough.

It wouldnt be as popular as dragon attacks are at TH7 because not many TH9s have lvl30 heroes.

Well your point of view comes into play because of two things.

1. You are not willing to accept that someone else might know better than you.

2. You cant know until someone uploads it to youtube and you watch a video.

I was doing CB hog attacks, and Im sure others too, before any of the youtubers started showing them in their videos.

There are alot of war clans that dont like making their attack strategies public.
July 26th, 2015
thebuch4

Quote:

Originally Posted by steelseth

I imagine pentaloon would seem just as preposterous to you before youtubers made it popular. You must have thought ... those flying pigs only do 14 dps, they are useless ... I need more loons .... 16 loons are not enough.

It wouldnt be as popular as dragon attacks are at TH7 because not many TH9s have lvl30 heroes.

Well your point of view comes into play because of two things.

1. You are not willing to accept that someone else might know better than you.

2. You cant know until someone uploads it to youtube and you watch a video.

I was doing CB hog attacks, and Im sure others too, before any of the youtubers started showing them in their videos.

There are alot of war clans that dont like making their attack strategies public.

Okay, rather than argue this all randomly, please point to one instance of a max TH9 three starred by a 9 with nothing but a queen and healers. Just one example, on a base that actually has walls to slow her down, and I'll concede that you know more than me.

But instead, you're trying to make the argument that they can't nerf IT's like this because solo AQs would be able to three star TH10s.. And if that was true, then an IT on single would fry her anyway.

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page