Clan Types

This would allow clans to follow a certain "type" or method in which to lead the clan. Each clan type would have distinct advantages over the others.


DEMOCRACY:
A weighted voting system in which members, elders, co leaders, and the leader can vote. A member vote would count as 1, elder vote is 2, co is 3, etc. This type would also allow the leader to be removed and an election to fill his place. It would also show in depths stats on each member and their activity level.


OLIGARCHY:
This type would allow multiple leaders (max of 4) that each hold equal powers. In this Clan Type the 3 most powerful members (deduced in a a similar way to Clan War rankings) hold a lot of power in the decision making process. This clan Type would appeal to many trophy pushing clans as motivation to push. This clan Type will also have power to vote. Members will not get a vote. Elders and Co Leaders count as 2 votes, Top 3 count as 3 votes, and Leader is 4.


Please note: The clan Leader retains leadership in all cases. If the leader is in the Top 3, it takes the next most powerful person.


COMMUNIST:
This Clan Type is favorable to Bounty Farmers. It will pool 5-10% of each member's available resources and hold it in a "clan bank". It will then be available for anyone in the clan to use (clan members will be able to withdraw up to 100,000 every 5 hours (tentative). Resources will not be pooled from anyone below Town Hall 5 and participation is voluntary (members can opt out of the pooling, but they will not be able to withdraw.) Alternatively, there could be a loan-return system.

Dictatorship:
This Clan Type is favorable to those clans which participate in wars. The leaders and co leaders of this clan can assign clan war attacks on a single person. For example, Leader Jane could assign Member Bob to attack Enemy Bill. (All names were purely made up. Any reference to any person or thing is purely coincidental). Each player could be assigned only one person. The second attack is up to them.


FINAL NOTE: Clan Types would be additional. Only 1 Clan Type can be chosen. To add a Clan Type an additional cost will be added (for example, a regular clan costs 40K. Each Type will have its own cost, so if Democracy is 30K then your Democratic Clan would be 70K Gold.)



Thank you for reading! Please reply with your ideas/comments along with additions.

I think I like it the way it is....besides, it's a bit complicated for some kids.....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Frosticewolf

I think I like it the way it is....besides, it's a bit complicated for some kids.....

---

Thanks for the reply! How would you simplify it? I thought making it optional would allow people to avoid it if they please.

DEMOCRACY: I will always disagree with having the ability to demote the clan leader. He is the one who built it and you cannot just take that away from him if you take a group of friends and populate his clan. These clans would be the target of large groups of players who are looking to populate a stronger clan, or one of a higher level. Disagreed.

OLIGARCHY: Too complicated. I like the current system where there is a single Leader, but multiple Co-Leaders. I don't see a point in having a clan with 3-4 Leaders as well as Co-Leaders. Also a voting system would be too much to include for taking any decision.

COMMUNIST: I like the idea of clans but I'd rather not have the other members use my loot for themselves. Also this would be a system of donating resources between members, which is ruled out. Players could create multiple accounts, form their own communist clans, and have the Leader keep on taking resources from this pool.

Dictatorship: Again, no. If the player wants to attack that base, he will attack it. You cannot force them into doing it.


As other notes, even if there is a rule for 13 y.o. or older to play this game, there are a lot of players under that age who access clash of clans. First, these kids don't know what all these mean, and even if you will add an explanation there, they still won't read it. Second, I'd rather not have kids talk about such dictatorship clans in the game because this will bring other painful subjects into discussion which are not meant to be discussed in a game with some kids. I will suggest keep the clans simple as they currently are.

Thank you for the perspective! I don't really know how to work with that though. you kind of tore apart the concept....

However, I will say that having multiple accounts is, I believe, against Supercell policy. Also, The loot sharing is similar to donations. I could have two accounts and donate between them.

Thanks though!