[One and Only] War Related Stuff Thread

***Just a side note, the poll is public so I will see if you link to the thread or not!!!

It's me again, making another idea thread.

Ok, lately I've been seeing the typical "Less prep day! More battle day!" and the "Let leaders deleted war troops cause they're awesome!" :smirk: Threads. Now as many of you know I personally can't stand it when IFR is clogged with the same idea fifty bajillion times. So the purpose of the thread is to bring together all the major war ideas into one, clean, flame free thread. Ok so let's begin.

**PM or VM me your suggestions (links are fine) I'd like this thread to stay generally clean, as multiple ideas on this thread will make it look sloppy. If you don't like the idea, don't argue about it, just simply make a cons chart to add onto the ideas already existing Pros and Cons one. It will help keep this thread flame free. Please and thanks. Ok, so now we can really begin.

Ive already covered the troop filter and donation storage area, so I'll put a link at the bottom.

First and foremost,
Opt OUT should be the default.

Pros

Why? Many times you have a guy who is inactive but pops online every once in a while to collect look, make some upgrades, and log off - not chat. So they never opt out of wars, I've lead 3 clans. 2 of which were during Clan Wars. What destroyed the first one was that. 5 or 7 guys not chatting but you knew were active, not opting out of war. To add onto that, it's a very tedious process having to opt everyone out of war each time. It's quite frankly a hassle.

Cons

I can't think of any..... It's a Monday, not to mention a Monday morning...

Secondly
Upgrading Heros during war

Pros

We've ALL had that moment when your at a tight war, 2 stars behind, and you have the final attack.
-Dramatic curtain opens-
And so you hit attack! You deploy your troops, destroy that base, but wait - there's a builders hut in the corner and an AT shooting at your final few troops. You click to deploy you hero - but alas, they are upgrading. You troops destroy the AT, but don't have enough time to destroy that builders hut, making the war tied.
-Close Curtain-

Cons

Loss of revenue for SC

Third,
When all attacks used, end war.

Pros

This idea is rather simplistic, whenever your in a war and all your clans attacks are used, and all your enemies attacks are used, the clan war should end rather then wasting 6 more hours of your time

Cons

This would create a slight unbalance in clan XP, as you could war more frequently.

Reserved for future use. You may now post!

I like the thread, but I don't think putting the information from other popular topics into one is the best idea. For example, I think for the Heroes usable during war, that petition is very important and the amount of replies it achieved is up to the sky. You can also message me to put a certain topic in the Index of Common Ideas & Requests, because it was read already by lots of people and also people starting to reply in those threads linked there.
Anyway, to get back to the topic:
Opt OUT should be the default: So after every war you opt out? If that's the case then I am against it, simply because sometimes I cannot be online to put myself back IN when the war ended. I think this will cause much more stress for the Co-Leaders since they wouldn't know who actually wants to be out and who was just changed by the server automatically. Force that guy to opt out if he is inactive or kick.
Upgrading Heros during war: Again, the petition works amazing.
When all attacks used, end war: This might cause stress "the other clan keeps one attack so we cannot finish!", "make it so the system knows when the opponents cannot win anymore". Sure, I'd love to end a war faster if all members acted great, but this will mostly benefit those clans with low players who are likely to use all their attacks. People would move to 10x10 clan wars and war every.. 5h? Who knows.

If they're not even paying attention to the sticky threads, then why would they bother watching your thread wich is't even sticky?...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by devil9394

I like the thread, but I don't think putting the information from other popular topics into one is the best idea. For example, I think for the Heroes usable during war, that petition is very important and the amount of replies it achieved is up to the sky. You can also message me to put a certain topic in the Index of Common Ideas & Requests, because it was read already by lots of people and also people starting to reply in those threads linked there.
Anyway, to get back to the topic:
Opt OUT should be the default: So after every war you opt out? If that's the case then I am against it, simply because sometimes I cannot be online to put myself back IN when the war ended. I think this will cause much more stress for the Co-Leaders since they wouldn't know who actually wants to be out and who was just changed by the server automatically. Force that guy to opt out if he is inactive or kick.
Upgrading Heros during war: Again, the petition works amazing.
When all attacks used, end war: This might cause stress "the other clan keeps one attack so we cannot finish!", "make it so the system knows when the opponents cannot win anymore". Sure, I'd love to end a war faster if all members acted great, but this will mostly benefit those clans with low players who are likely to use all their attacks. People would move to 10x10 clan wars and war every.. 5h? Who knows.

---

Yes the petition does work well hence forth I included it. As for opt out, it's a one time deal.