which of these th 10 bases would defend better

UPDATE: anyone know which top player base i should copt to defense against gowipes

They would both be about the same becuase they are both laid out wrongly. The defences should be round the outside of the middle ring to split the golems up from their support troops. These would both be an easy win because the base owners have missed the point of the designs and deviated from the original layouts.

First one. But they're both quite easy.
You would seriously defend better using a decoy base from one of the top players even.

On closer inspection the first looks likenyou took one of the top bases and then went and messed it up. You could just fix the ring by listening to the person above.