At TH7 you unlock DE, I think you should be able to store DE in your TH and it would help noob TH7's out. I'm a TH9 lvl 92. That would be nice.
YAY MY IDEA HAS BEEN ADDED! THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT!
Printable View
At TH7 you unlock DE, I think you should be able to store DE in your TH and it would help noob TH7's out. I'm a TH9 lvl 92. That would be nice.
YAY MY IDEA HAS BEEN ADDED! THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT!
I agree with having some DE stored in the TH, but in the same time I think it should hold little more of gold/elixir. If we would go with the current calculations, the TH would only store about 25 DE..
I think it should keep the 1000 DE, as it has 1000 elixir and gold. If it could only hold 25 DE, then what would be the point?Quote:
Originally Posted by devil9394
That's what I was thinkingQuote:
Originally Posted by Theking8133
Quote:
Originally Posted by Theking8133
The rationale behind the suggestion that it only holds 25DE is down to how quickly you can gain DE. As it stands you have 6 gold/elixir collectors each capable of making 3,500 of those resources every hour (at TH8, 3,000 for TH7). At TH7/8 you have one DE collector capable of making 45 DE per hour.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jackdopp
Now I ask you; would you want to be able to lose 1,000 DE from your TH if you can only recuperate 540 DE during the shield time that TH snipe gives you?
I'm going with 25Quote:
Originally Posted by ropepirate
That would be absurd. the TH holds 1000 elixir and gold out of a maximum of 8,000,000. This is .000125%. The DE maximum storage is 200,000. The equivalent amount is 25 DE and that would be the appropriate amount to store.Quote:
Originally Posted by Theking8133
However, I think it would be fair to up the amount of gold/elixir in the TH to 10,000, increasing it by 1000 for each TH lvl. Hence the amount of DE should increase from each TH level it can be stored by equal amounts. So 25 starting at TH7 up to 100 de in a TH10.
Those amount would make people stop and think but I think most would still choose to put their TH outside that do now. But maybe it would shut up the people who think leaving the TH out is some sort of crime against the game.
Why would you want to discourage farmers?! Farmers are part of the game, stop trying to force everybody to play YOUR style of the game, and let people be free to choose their own way of playing.
Part of what makes this game fun is it's so optional. You can push, you can farm, you can war, you can create your own clan, you can push for levels (req&leave), I could go on! People that try to take away strategies and gameplay really do ruin the game.
I don't think the TH was meant to become a storage at all. The only reason why the TH is able to store gold and elixir is because you don't have storages when you first start the game, hence, SC made it so the TH is able to temporarily do that purpose. So IMHO, I don't think putting DE in the TH is a good idea.
Yes I would be totally fine losing 1K DE. I don't farm, so I wouldn't be losing much, as I stay where I should be, so I rarely lose a defense.Quote:
Originally Posted by ropepirate
25 is nothing. I could make 5 minions at Lvl1 for that. If it's going to be an update, it needs to be worth it.Quote:
Originally Posted by gamul1
Yeah 25 DE doesn't do much. But it does make sense:)Quote:
Originally Posted by Theking8133
You might put up a DE drill and not storage. Then what?Quote:
Originally Posted by Kixeye
Check out my 1000 vs 25 thread to debate on 1000 or 25
Theres not much of a reason to create a seperate thread, we can discuss it hereQuote:
Originally Posted by Jackdopp
Oh yeah xP
How is this even a subject worth debating?! Why would you want to take away gameplay and strategy from the game?! It's not like there's anything OP about farming... It really bugs me when people try to force you over to their side of playing...
Agree.
and THs should generally hold a lot more resources, increasing with TH level.
Increased, but not increased so much to to really hurt farming.
Yes, I'd be fine with 25 max DE in the TH.Quote:
Originally Posted by George1971
You guys persuaded me to go 25. Even TH7s wouldn't care about losing 25 DE. And farmers can still be farmers.
We have voted for 25
What are you even talking about? Were debating about how much DE should go into the TH. Very little has to do with farming. May this discourage it slightly, yes, but not really.Quote:
Originally Posted by Callywally
He's apparently a farmer. He seems to want 25 DEQuote:
Originally Posted by Theking8133
Farmers read the last paragraphQuote:
Originally Posted by gamul1
I think it's a good idea this would also stop farmers from trying to protect their DE and people who keep farming would get a little disadvantage.
This won't really discourage farmer cause you can only store 25 DE.Quote:
Originally Posted by Shalok
Please Vote yes
Supercell what do you guys think?
why do we have resources in the town hall in the first place? btw your little argument is stupid 25 DARK ELIXER you guys just want an easy way to farm de its not gonna happen...
Who are you?Quote:
Originally Posted by IronSoldier73
This idea haven't been ruled out!
Please do not double post to BUMP your topic. If people will consider it a good idea, they will reply to support it or if they don't like it, they might say why, either way you should only reply to other people when they post.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jackdopp
Sorry, I wasn't trying to bump it.Quote:
Originally Posted by devil9394
There should be more than 25 DE in the TH. 25 DE is like ten minutes worth of collecting? 100 DE is more like it. Worth raiding, but barely.
No way, whoever suggested 1000 DE in the TH is insane. Wayyyy too much there. Couldnt ever farm DE properly if you have your TH outside and you lose 1000 a rip. Maybe 100 is a fairer number.
Seems good to me if the dark elixir amount is 10, 20, or 25. Would make farmers have a harder time, though......
We are thinking 25 because of current calculations. Not even TH7's would miss 25DE.
Has Supercell seen this yet?
1000 is way too much.
25 sounds good.
Thats what we're thinkingQuote:
Originally Posted by BluBest
Honestly never thought of that, but it does actually make sense to add that in at and after Th7. Would be a cool little edition to see in a future update.
And as everyone has said already, 25DE fits way better with calculations than a thousand.
Yeah, Say you build a DE drill and Dark Barracks, but no storage, this way you can still train up a few minions :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Avery99
1000 de for a townhall snipe? That would be outrageous. 25 would be too much even. Rewarding town hall sniping Is not at all a good idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by Theking8133
It only takes a handful if archers to snipe a townhall.
You could make thousands of extra DE in a couple hours.
That's a solid no from me and anyone who understands DE is supposed to be harder to get.
You haven't even done the calculations...Quote:
Originally Posted by Andremagus
A Th7 has 3,200 hitpoints.
Archer lvl 4 does 16 dps.
Multiply that by three 48 dps.
3200 divided by 48 dps is about a minute and 5-6 seconds.
Multiply that by say 4 hours of non-stop sniping, does not in include search time
60*4= 240/~1=240
240*25=6000 dark elixir
FarmingDE would suck if you lose 1000 every time. I'd quit if this update was implemented.
One word: Heroes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tisguyz
We're leaning toward 25 DEQuote:
Originally Posted by 789firespawn
The Town Hall only has DE to necessitate the introduction in the game.
And as some others have said, relatively speaking you are only looking at something like 10-20 DE in there.
As such I don't see it worth changing for something largely immaterial.
You actually start off with 1 gold storage and 1 gold mine if I'm not mistaken.
Like I've been saying, this wouldn't really effect the higher THs, this is more for the TH7 that just got there. You can build your drill and a dark Barracks, and you could still train up a few minions without the expensive DE storage!
I feel like we shouldn't encourage snipers anymore than we already have. Also, seems like such a small, insignificant change that would be split the community 50/50, that it really just isn't worth the coding.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jackdopp
Nope, you need to build them.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lavaclaw
This small article on Clash wiki about starting out, has a screenshot showing storage is capped at 1,000 [with some bad editing on gems lol]; which is all the hall can hold.
http://clashofclans.wikia.com/wiki/M...Clash_of_Clans
5 words: Who has that much time?Quote:
Originally Posted by Lavaclaw
25 DE can't make one Hog. So I see this as pointless. Huge sign of no from me
But it can make minions :DQuote:
Originally Posted by 789firespawn
If you put de in town hall that would stop some people from farming cuz they don't wanna lose de
Why you necro????????????????
I think 1000DE is too much but 25 too little id say 100
i agrre with putting in atleast 100 DE....Quote:
Originally Posted by devil9394
oh no, i lost 25/100 de but not the 20,000 i have in my de storage :eek:!! :facepalm:Quote:
Originally Posted by PhillyGator
LolololololQuote:
Originally Posted by KeenWarrior