Disable people spying on enemy bases during wars

Nothing irks me more on this game than being in a war and a member from the other clan joins your clan to see what troops are stocked in your clan castle and where all of your traps are set up. Sure, change your clan settings to "invite only" but then that bottlenecks the flow of new members joining your clan as by the time you accept it, they've moved on to another clan.
I feel like this problem creates an unfair disadvantage for the people who play this game the RIGHT way.
My suggestion would be: if clan A and clan B are in a war, a member from clan A can leave an join any other clan EXCEPT clan B until that war is over.

That would be an easy fix

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kippy909

Nothing irks me more on this game than being in a war and a member from the other clan joins your clan to see what troops are stocked in your clan castle and where all of your traps are set up. Sure, change your clan settings to "invite only" but then that bottlenecks the flow of new members joining your clan as by the time you accept it, they've moved on to another clan.
I feel like this problem creates an unfair disadvantage for the people who play this game the RIGHT way.
My suggestion would be: if clan A and clan B are in a war, a member from clan A can leave an join any other clan EXCEPT clan B until that war is over.

---

All's fair in love in war. Of all things, I hate when people think there's a "right" way to play. You can spy, can't you?! Spying is a strategy, however "cowardly" or "cheap". Up your clan security or don't do wars until you have more than enough new members. Also, your solution wouldn't even work as someone with an alt that's outside the clan or in a feeder could still join and spy.

DEAL WITH IT.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Callywally

All's fair in love in war. Of all things, I hate when people think there's a "right" way to play. You can spy, can't you?! Spying is a strategy, however "cowardly" or "cheap". Up your clan security or don't do wars until you have more than enough new members. Also, your solution wouldn't even work as someone with an alt that's outside the clan or in a feeder could still join and spy.

DEAL WITH IT.

---

Up clan security? This a phone app. If my clan and i are getting ready for a war we should not be bothered with the rival clans members. Yes, you are correct with that last sentence. But alts are weak and clans would be less likely to add them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BluBest

Up clan security? This a phone app. If my clan and i are getting ready for a war we should not be bothered with the rival clans members. Yes, you are correct with that last sentence. But alts are weak and clans would be less likely to add them.

---

But my point remains; spying is currently part of war.

Until SC does somthing about it just leave your clan closed during war.

How about not allowing new members to be war spectators. That would seem to me to be the best solution to the spying issue

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sporkein

How about not allowing new members to be war spectators. That would seem to me to be the best solution to the spying issue

---

I like the thinking of this idea, as it would fix both the problem currently pointed out and the work around that CallyWally pointed.

However, I'm with CallyWally about leaving this strategy in the game. I doubt there has been a war in the history of mankind that didn't involve spying. Personally, I think this is a positive aspect of the game and don't really see it as a problem. There are ways already to defend against it, if your clan is careful and honestly you should have the option to be careful or not. Spying should remain as is.

i actually i was thinking there should be more espionage options in coc. clan war is what this game is all about for a lot of people including myself. and espionage is part of any good strategic battle.

Um, what? Close your clan or put it on invite only. It's not that hard.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kippy909

Nothing irks me more on this game than being in a war and a member from the other clan joins your clan to see what troops are stocked in your clan castle and where all of your traps are set up. Sure, change your clan settings to "invite only" but then that bottlenecks the flow of new members joining your clan as by the time you accept it, they've moved on to another clan.
I feel like this problem creates an unfair disadvantage for the people who play this game the RIGHT way.
My suggestion would be: if clan A and clan B are in a war, a member from clan A can leave an join any other clan EXCEPT clan B until that war is over.

---

Spies irk me too.

Not accepting new people during war is irksome when we would like to accept new players.

Excluding members from the other clan is no solution, spies may not have been in that clan. People can have multiple accounts!

Better, just don't let new players see traps, HT or CC troops on the war map.

Set to invite only.

Problem simply solved!