Rushed Town Halls and War Matches

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LordKerensky

Are you illiterate or just an idiot?

He's talking about his clan vs another clan. In his clan everyone has "average" bases. On the other team, their bottom player who is matched against a TH8, is a TH10 with really low defenses, to include not even building some of them, and MAX TROOPS.

At TH10 with 240 troops plus 35CC and Max Troops, and he is matched against TH8s, he's going to absolutely crush them. Thats what he's talking about.

I do not allow rushed bases in my clan, we have over 100 wins as a clan. However, we have seen it plenty of times that a rushed base, typically TH10s, tip the balance of war significantly. I loved playing as TH9 but had to upgrade to 10 just to have freeze spells because really ♥♥♥♥ty rushed players at TH10 were getting matched against me in war and we had no TH10 to fight them effectively.

Rushed bases are the problem regardless of how much you "like" their loot. Try reading the post before giving some garbage reply because you're an idiot.

---

No need to be condescending, but I agree with the majority of your post. Especially the end part. That's part of the reason why Supercell will have mad people on their hands. Too many people game the system for loot and various other reasons. This ruins it for the legit players.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by devil9394

My personal opinion about this subject is that every player gets to choose how he/she plays the game. If they want to rush their TH, then it is their own choice whether to do it or not, and SuperCell shouldn't intervene in this. I will be honest now, I rushed my th from TH8 to TH9, since I wanted the Queen. I must say I totally dominated at the beginning since I maxed my troops, so I can now say I would do it again every time if I'd have choice.
This being said, I am against this idea and I feel like players should be able to choose how they play at their free will.

---

You upgraded just for a queen? I think that's dumb. Not only did you get a loot penalty during individual raids, but your base probably performed poorly in wars. Why bother being part of a clan when it seems like you'd rather just play as an individual?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Honda323

You upgraded just for a queen? I think that's dumb. Not only did you get a loot penalty during individual raids, but your base probably performed poorly in wars. Why bother being part of a clan when it seems like you'd rather just play as an individual?

---

Rushed bases typically are a team of one...they are hoppers more often than not...that's why most clans don't want them.

I love fighting rushed bases. As a maxed th8 its very easy to topple any of them and get solid loot bonuses. One of the reasons my clan seldom loses is because we don't take rushed bases to war

The solution is easy... instead of just enforcing a prerequisite, also have an XP/level requirement. So, if you're rushing to TH10 but you're only lvl 15 with so much XP, you should have to wait until you reach the appropriate level.

This isn't just to regulate rushing, but also makes sense. Apply it to a real-world scenario... say your "chief" is a young guy, he wouldn't have the knowledge and experience to know how to run a TH10 until he gets older and wiser.

Still no point for SUPERCELL to include a level requirement. Why are you folks tryin to implement something that aint needed.

I made a thread earlier about how levels mean absolutely NOTHING in this game. Whether you gem or get it legit, you still level up regardless. You shouldnt have to be a certain level to have certain things. If you want that then go to Boom Beach

I got the money and I want TH10, I can get it and I should be able to.

Thing about it is, how folks talk about the penalty for loot and such. Whats loot to a gemmer anyway? And SUPERCELL knows that rushers are there biggest money bringers.

the problem I see alot is that people ignore there collectors and upgrade ther th casuing us to find low loot in there bases when they go dead my opionion would be a minumum requirement of having max collectors so when they abadon they can give the max loot to the economy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aluxtu

I love fighting rushed bases. As a maxed th8 its very easy to topple any of them and get solid loot bonuses. One of the reasons my clan seldom loses is because we don't take rushed bases to war

---

I love playing single player matches against rushed TH's too...definitely good loot. However, that doesn't change the fact that they are bad for war match ups.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Turr

The solution is easy... instead of just enforcing a prerequisite, also have an XP/level requirement. So, if you're rushing to TH10 but you're only lvl 15 with so much XP, you should have to wait until you reach the appropriate level.

This isn't just to regulate rushing, but also makes sense. Apply it to a real-world scenario... say your "chief" is a young guy, he wouldn't have the knowledge and experience to know how to run a TH10 until he gets older and wiser.

---

Agreed...regulating is definitely a necessity. You should be a certian level before you're able to upgrade TH.

No regulations are needed. The game itself tries to be balanced and players will always try to gain advantage the best they can. Why not force people to build x-bows the moment they hit TH9 so they can't employ the TH8.5 strategy? A rushed TH10 gains an attack advantage, but gives up all three stars to someone on the other team. Quite frankly it's very rare that someone is a rushed TH10 who doesn't have inferno towers which would make it extremely unlikely that they match to a TH8 due to the weighting of defensive scores.

Clans should have an attack strategy that allows for dealing with impossible match-ups. It's far more common to see an impossible matchup when the breakpoint from TH8 to TH7 is different between the warring clans.

By by far the biggest problems are caused by the players your own team selects to participate in war. Someone with strong TH10 defenses and only TH8 equivilent attack ability messes things up for everyone, not just themselves.