Take out an unneeded feature

When doing wars it is important that everyone is able to get their attacks in. Unfortunately disconnects happen and SuperCell, I am sorry to say, but you just made it severely difficult for large-scale wars to get all of their attacks in. The dreaded "Client out of sync" disconnect or a blunt connection issue when attacking is one of the worst things for any war-fighter to experience and with the new update people with bad connections are being permanently punished simply for having slow connection speed during war time. My suggestion? Keep the army composition screen and take out the penalty if a person attacks but drops absolutely zero troops. Too many people are missing attacks due to disconnects before they can even drop one troop, whoever thought this was a good idea needs to be questioned HIGHLY.:thumbsdown:

SC can't fix a bad connection. Nor can any other gaming company. You or your clanmates need to get a better router or connection in general

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

SC can't fix a bad connection. Nor can any other gaming company. You or your clanmates need to get a better router or connection in general

---

It is still unfair that if you do not get to drop one troop you lose an attack in the war.. Even people with excellent connections have this problem at times. On top of this many people are not used to it in general, some attack by mistake and back out only to find out they missed an attack even when they did absolutely nothing. It is an unfair feature entirely and does not exist in the campaign or normal attacks, so why does it have to exist in wars where teamwork is 100% needed and every attack is important?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by slyram

When doing wars it is important that everyone is able to get their attacks in. Unfortunately disconnects happen and SuperCell, I am sorry to say, but you just made it severely difficult for large-scale wars to get all of their attacks in. The dreaded "Client out of sync" disconnect or a blunt connection issue when attacking is one of the worst things for any war-fighter to experience and with the new update people with bad connections are being permanently punished simply for having slow connection speed during war time. My suggestion? Keep the army composition screen and take out the penalty if a person attacks but drops absolutely zero troops. Too many people are missing attacks due to disconnects before they can even drop one troop, whoever thought this was a good idea needs to be questioned HIGHLY.:thumbsdown:

---

1 word: che@ters. They ruined this for people with legitimate disconnects unfortunately.

I won't go into detail, but allowing people with disconnects to redo attacks allowed people to exploit that to their advantage to see traps, teslas, and do even worse things. SC eventually changed it due to how bad it was getting.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by zachUVA

1 word: che@ters. They ruined this for people with legitimate disconnects unfortunately.

I won't go into detail, but allowing people with disconnects to redo attacks allowed people to exploit that to their advantage to see traps, teslas, and do even worse things. SC eventually changed it due to how bad it was getting.

---

If you are talking about the notorious sandbox mode than that happens simply from viewing a base (through scouting) not actually pressing attack =\ It is absolutely fine in my opinion if someone disconnects after dropping at least one troop and it counts, but not being able to drop any troops before disconnecting and having it count is meaningless..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by slyram

If you are talking about the notorious sandbox mode than that happens simply from viewing a base (through scouting) not actually pressing attack =\ It is absolutely fine in my opinion if someone disconnects after dropping at least one troop, but not being able to drop any troops before disconnecting and having it count is meaningless..

---

Nope, there were exploits that relied on disconnects.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by slyram

If you are talking about the notorious sandbox mode than that happens simply from viewing a base (through scouting) not actually pressing attack =\ It is absolutely fine in my opinion if someone disconnects after dropping at least one troop and it counts, but not being able to drop any troops before disconnecting and having it count is meaningless..

---

No, actually people would attack using airplane mode, and since they did not count it as an attack, they could proceed with the ideal attack, then lose connection and find that their attack didn't count. They could then repeat the process so their attack on that base was perfect. This was called ghosting, and with the current feature added it's fixed.