Clan exp/Achievement for successful clan war defend

Printable View

July 9th, 2015
Kixeye

Clan exp/Achievement for successful clan war defend

Okay, so we just finished a clan war. Looking at the war stats, I saw that my base design actually defended against 5 attacks, which made me very proud of my war layout, at the same time sad, because successfully defending in clan war actually means nothing.

So here's what I thought: (I did a search and found nothing on this, if I missed something similar to this, disregard this thread and put it in the bin where it belongs :))

We know that leveling a clan can be tedious and we also know what gives out clan exp: successful attack, get [x] stars, win war. As making a base that can defend against attacks is crucial in clan wars, why not give clan exp for a successful defend as well? So as not to be abused by feeder clans by surrendering on purpose to make the main clan rack up the exp, make it like how we gain exp for a successful attack. This means your base can only get exp for one successful defend, 5 exp like successful attacks. All other defenses you make with your base will no longer give additional clan exp.

Also, it would be awesome if every successful clan war defend would be placed as an achievement. This way you can have bragging rights to your successful defends, and you will know that the person you chose to go to war has a good defend history.

This may also make people work harder to beef up defenses instead of going for THx.5 where they only upgrade their army to get an easier war match :smirk:
July 9th, 2015
Callywally

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kixeye

Okay, so we just finished a clan war. Looking at the war stats, I saw that my base design actually defended against 5 attacks, which made me very proud of my war layout, at the same time sad, because successfully defending in clan war actually means nothing.

So here's what I thought: (I did a search and found nothing on this, if I missed something similar to this, disregard this thread and put it in the bin where it belongs :))

We know that leveling a clan can be tedious and we also know what gives out clan exp: successful attack, get [x] stars, win war. As making a base that can defend against attacks is crucial in clan wars, why not give clan exp for a successful defend as well? So as not to be abused by feeder clans by surrendering on purpose to make the main clan rack up the exp, make it like how we gain exp for a successful attack. This means your base can only get exp for one successful defend, 5 exp like successful attacks. All other defenses you make with your base will no longer give additional clan exp.

Also, it would be awesome if every successful clan war defend would be placed as an achievement. This way you can have bragging rights to your successful defends, and you will know that the person you chose to go to war has a good defend history.

This may also make people work harder to beef up defenses instead of going for THx.5 where they only upgrade their army to get an easier war match :smirk:

No, SC gives out plenty of free gems as it is. Anymore and they'd lose business. Also, clan XP goes way too fast at the moment.

And also, defending successfully in war does mean something; it means it's a good base and you (possibly) won the war because of it.
July 9th, 2015
Kixeye

Quote:

Originally Posted by Callywally

No, SC gives out plenty of free gems as it is. Anymore and they'd lose business. Also, clan XP goes way too fast at the moment.

And also, defending successfully in war does mean something; it means it's a good base and you (possibly) won the war because of it.

Fair enough.

Still, it would be neat to see how many times you successfully defended against an attack in clan wars, like how you can see how many times you successfully defended against an attack outside clan wars, even if the achievement would give just 1 gem or nothing at all.

Thanks for the input though :)