PROFILE UPDATE: show how many stars a player LOST in war (all times). BEST WAR PLAYER

If you see how many stars are WON and how many stars are LOST by a player (all times), and then substract them, you see which player is most effective. This players you want to participate in your clan war (Only to show how many stars won doesn't say anything if you always give away 3 stars in defense)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Robituary

If you see how many stars are WON and how many stars are LOST by a player (all times), and then substract them, you see which player is most effective. This players you want to participate in your clan war (Only to show how many stars won doesn't say anything if you always give away 3 stars in defense)

---

Not true. If a player is not near the top of the clan, and if the opposition have any reasonable strategy, then that player should expect to be three starred every time by someone. For a good base that someone will be higher level than for a bad base.

A player who who always scores three stars probably is aiming too low, taking targets better attacked by lower players.

I am #11 in my clan. I attack the #1 and #2 targets of the enemy, and get 2 stars each time.

My wife is #10 in the clan. She attacks the #19 and #20 targets of the enemy, and gets 3 stars each time.

Who is the best war player?

(i.e. Statistics like this are meaningless.)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

Not true. If a player is not near the top of the clan, and if the opposition have any reasonable strategy, then that player should expect to be three starred every time by someone. For a good base that someone will be higher level than for a bad base.

A player who who always scores three stars probably is aiming too low, taking targets better attacked by lower players.

---

Good point! Maybe only add "stars lost" to the profile. Now it has only "stars won". Then you can do with the info what you like.

(i am a medium player (lvl 15 hero's) but spent a lot of time building my defense. I only got 1-starred in defense all the time, also by lvl 40 hero's. I got a best score of 98% smashed and only 1 star lost.). The number of stars people loose in war are not displayed... Only what you win. I think a good defense needs more respect :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Uthrac

I am #11 in my clan. I attack the #1 and #2 targets of the enemy, and get 2 stars each time.

My wife is #10 in the clan. She attacks the #19 and #20 targets of the enemy, and gets 3 stars each time.

Who is the best war player?

(i.e. Statistics like this are meaningless.)

---

Good point! Hard to say. (See my other comment)

That proves nothing.

Supercell has always been against negative statistics. Notice it doesn't keep track of how many loses you've had in a season? or total?

If they won't do it for your normal statistic, I highly doubt they'll do it for war statistics.

Personally, I don't mind having a loss tracker so we can see what our win:loss ratio is but it'll be very difficult to change Supercells mind when it comes to an underlining corporate philosophy of no negative statistics...