Printable View
After a clan member attacks during a war, it is possible (but tedious) to watch war replays over and over to make note of where hidden teslas and traps are, plus what cc troops came out.
My suggestion is to put any discovered hidden teslas, traps, or cc troops on the scouting view for that base. This makes it less tedious to review already available information.
If this has already been suggested, I apologize.
Except when the update hits and you lose all your intel.. I agree with this idea 100%Quote:
Originally Posted by Jason5482
Agree 100%here. There's nothing worse than having no replays to watch bc of an update or maintenance break!
To my knowledge this idea has never been suggested and actually could be useful and handy! I see no real exploits (except it might cut down a little on strategy for second-time attackers) but I will wait to see what other people have to say before making my final judgement.
In the meantime, I think this is a very cool and useful idea!
Would like this very much
I dont think it should inplemented.
We have 24h to do 2 attacks, watching a replay takes 3 minutes or less.
About maintenance..... yes its annoying to lose replays during war that way but it also affect your opponents.
Maybe its an idea to save replays of clanwars in progress during maintenance.
But how many storage would SC need to save replays from clanwar in progress
huh i was coming here because i thought you were suggesting something else, but this isn't half bad, i can totally see this working.
prolly wont happen tho
You don't think it should be implemented because they can watch the replay? The OP already mentioned this, we are under no illusions, he or she just wants things to be a bit simpler, and your alternative is to suggest SC do something way more complicated, save the replay after updates?Quote:
Originally Posted by Bockerijder
I like it! It definitely would add some fluency to the game, not having to take notes on replays or whatever. Nice original idea. :D
Amazing Idea!
Would love to see something like this!
I'm about to suggest this too.
Well, after reading positive and negative comments on this (of course with reasons WHY), I'd give it a yes and a no.
Yes, because it may help us in telling the enemies' trap locations and Hidden Tesla spots especially when a maintenance break occurs and disables the ability to watch the replays.
No, because the enemy Clan would also be affected by this. They can see where your clanmates' trap locations, too. No, you can't say "...then this feature will only affect us." because EVERYONE is affected by a feature. Nobody isn't affected by the implemented feature (unless they don't update their game).
What's so bad if it affects everybody? That IS the point of the feature.Quote:
Originally Posted by DARWINIANS
To the OP, I'm starting to like this idea more and more :)
That's my opinion. Don't judge on it.Quote:
Originally Posted by AnthonyVince
(Hidden text below! Highlight to reveal...)
Fine, 75% Yes and 25% No. Happy?
Even if Supercell just reset all discovered items during maintenance, it would still be very convenient during most wars. Very rarely do war battle days fall on maintenance days compared to the entirety of all wars that happen.
I think there's really no downside to this. I didn't understand your point, @DARWINIANS. Enemy clan still can watch replays nowadays, it's just saving time for everyone.
The idea would save a lot of time, and the ones who really care about the replay could watch it too. But having to take annotations of traps and CC troops is just a waste of time.
I don't know if the programming behind this would be easy though, but it would be one of the small-but-great imporvement. Pretty optimal.
This needs to happenQuote:
Originally Posted by Jason5482