Choose Which Clan to fight.

I want Supercell to bring new feature in which we can send a Challenge to other clan. Clan leader will get the challenge message and he will decide whether to accept or reject challenge. This feature will bring more fun as we can fight with our friends clan. And there should be a little break of 2 or 4 days so that we cannot keep fighting same clan again and again.
Believe me friends, its gonna be amazing.

And there should be another button named "Random Search" which is Normal one. So that we can fight our friends clan or random clan as we want. And one more thing, the challenger clan cannot send so many challenges to same clan for some time after they have Rejected 2 Challenges.

Some people will be thinking that if one clan have 50 members and other clan have 30 members so how can they fight. I have a solution for this!
When clan leader receive a challenge, the challenge should have a message saying that for Example, "Red Army Has Sent you Challenge for 20vs20 War. And they both can only choose 20 members for war. Isnt that good idea?

Would be exploited very easily, you could just attack a lv.1 clan while you are a lv.6 clan

And next we can get free gems by collecting our resources!!!! :rolleyes:

Honestly, I think that would take all the fun out of clan wars, and here's why.

Lets pretend I'm part of a clan family. Clan 1 challenges clan 2 to a 30v30 war.

Clan 1 proceeds to put their Town hall and all resource related buildings on one side of the map with no protection.
Clan 1 chooses not to attack. Clan 2 attacks and 2 stars all bases for a clan win (because they are easy to get through).

4 days later, rinse and repeat. 1 month later, Clan 2 has a full history of green in their war log (wins) that they won by manipulating said system. All members from clan 1 join clan 2 at whatever level perks they ended up on and Ditch the 1st clan.

The end.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by arose

Honestly, I think that would take all the fun out of clan wars, and here's why.

Lets pretend I'm part of a clan family. Clan 1 challenges clan 2 to a 30v30 war.

Clan 1 proceeds to put their Town hall and all resource related buildings on one side of the map with no protection.
Clan 1 chooses not to attack. Clan 2 attacks and 2 stars all bases for a clan win (because they are easy to get through).

4 days later, rinse and repeat. 1 month later, Clan 2 has a full history of green in their war log (wins) that they won by manipulating said system. All members from clan 1 join clan 2 at whatever level perks they ended up on and Ditch the 1st clan.

The end.

---

Hmm, Arose you are right. So isnt there any solution to this?

Solution: make it so no resources, achievements, or clan Xp can be obtained thru these wars.

Or if you tap the "Random Search" then there would be no penalty.
But if you tap the "Send Clan War Request" then there would be a penalty of deducting 50% of Clan XP and Clan War Bonuses.

What do you think?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KaiTheBeast0

Solution: make it so no resources, achievements, or clan Xp can be obtained thru these wars.

---

Would make it a complete waste of time and loot. You could not get any benefit from it because of the aforementioned reasons.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VJ9999

Or if you tap the "Random Search" then there would be no penalty.
But if you tap the "Send Clan War Request" then there would be a penalty of deducting 50% of Clan XP and Clan War Bonuses.

What do you think?

---

Same problem as before, clan one loses on purpose to clan 2. Just takes longer to stack benefits.

If if this was in place I would just make sure that both sides were able to get all the benefit by both sides taking th outside and only one clan takes a win both the other gets a smaller amount of loot at the end. VERY exploitable.

Way to think outside the box though, kudos to,the OP for that.

THERE COULD BE A PROBLEM
so how long do you have to wait to fight them, isnt it easy to be abused, it is like player search which is not allowed

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KaiTheBeast0

Solution: make it so no resources, achievements, or clan Xp can be obtained thru these wars.

---

I think you are right about clan xp and achievements but we should still get little resources so its not totally waste.