2 stars= town hall plus 75%

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

July 1st, 2015
Callywally

Quote:

Originally Posted by daddylindo

@sungirl, His troops are maxed and he's looted 1 billion coins n elixer thru farming. And he did bring the collector in. Whatever, im not gonna harp on that. You folks like the same ole monotony that's fine, it doesnt surprise me. But for wars, stars should be earned more than 50%, then you get clans thinking about whether or not to spend more attacks trying to get the extra star. Not getting 2 stars for an unworthy 50% and then making the decision easy to "leave him alone" after that cuz 3 stars is out of the equation. If you people cant understand that competetive aspect of clan warring, then you're exactly who I think you are

I'm a competitive war participant and I disagree.

You'll learn that at TH10, it's very difficult to get that 50%. In fact, I get 30/40% by the time the town hall's fallen. You can't just think about your own TH level, you gotta consider others.

And if you can't stop 2 stars 50% of the time at TH9, then your base obviously isn't good enough.
July 1st, 2015
sungirl

Quote:

Originally Posted by daddylindo

@sungirl, His troops are maxed and he's looted 1 billion coins n elixer thru farming. And he did bring the collector in. Whatever, im not gonna harp on that. You folks like the same ole monotony that's fine, it doesnt surprise me. But for wars, stars should be earned more than 50%, then you get clans thinking about whether or not to spend more attacks trying to get the extra star. Not getting 2 stars for an unworthy 50% and then making the decision easy to "leave him alone" after that cuz 3 stars is out of the equation. If you people cant understand that competetive aspect of clan warring, then you're exactly who I think you are

Um, what? I do understand the competitive aspect of clan warring. I am in a war clan. MoManiacs - Level 6. Tag and recruitment thread in my signature.

1 stars do not win wars.
2 stars do not win wars.

You need three stars to win wars, and gowipe isn't that effective at getting three stars. It's a two-star strategy. I don't quite understand what you are complaining about because gowipe has ALWAYS been a two-star strategy at TH9 and at TH10, it's even harder to get two stars with gowipe.
July 1st, 2015
daddylindo

Quote:

Originally Posted by Callywally

I'm a competitive war participant and I disagree.

You'll learn that at TH10, it's very difficult to get that 50%. In fact, I get 30/40% by the time the town hall's fallen. You can't just think about your own TH level, you gotta consider others.

And if you can't stop 2 stars 50% of the time at TH9, then your base obviously isn't good enough.

Well callywally, when theres a will theres a way. They can nerf defenses a touch and make troops a touch stronger. Im thinking of the gaming experience as a whole. I want clan leaders thinking. Im not a noob so stop talking to me as such just because youre a th10 and im a th9. I know good gameplay when I see it, and I know when it's lacking. I love the game and they're doing a great job. Wars come down to stars. They don't add up percentage and award a winner. Maybe th10 doesnt need an extra XBow or the infernos being immune to heal spells. I know the freeze spell but still, Max balloons struggle against th9's, how the hell they supposed to excel against th10? I mean, 3 starring any base should be a part of the equation, why does it have to be impossible?? Come on now. I may not have best answer right now but the developers should be able to put their heads together to find the perfect medium. 2 stars shouldn't be the ultimate victory, especially 50% which only cleans half the map.
July 1st, 2015
daddylindo

Quote:

Originally Posted by sungirl

Um, what? I do understand the competitive aspect of clan warring. I am in a war clan. MoManiacs - Level 6. Tag and recruitment thread in my signature.

1 stars do not win wars.
2 stars do not win wars.

You need three stars to win wars, and gowipe isn't that effective at getting three stars. It's a two-star strategy. I don't quite understand what you are complaining about because gowipe has ALWAYS been a two-star strategy at TH9 and at TH10, it's even harder to get two stars with gowipe.

Yeah 3 starring the med-weaker th9's wins wars. 2 starring the tough ones only keeps pace. And im saying its not difficult WHATSOEVER to 2 star a max th9 and even a medium th10 with a gowipe. Ive done it 100 times already
July 1st, 2015
daddylindo

Quote:

Originally Posted by Callywally

I'm a competitive war participant and I disagree.

You'll learn that at TH10, it's very difficult to get that 50%. In fact, I get 30/40% by the time the town hall's fallen. You can't just think about your own TH level, you gotta consider others.

And if you can't stop 2 stars 50% of the time at TH9, then your base obviously isn't good enough.

Hey callywally, i was just thinking about something you said right here. Since I should think about the welfare of other town halls as you put it, how come supercell made it UNFAIR to town hall 7's that they cannot defend against dragon attacks? You should at least be able to defend against your own town hall. The sweeper proved to be a waste of time to them. How come youre not worried about the poor th7's that don't wanna put $$$ into the game like us? Let's hear it since youre such a man of equality.
July 1st, 2015
Wrxeter

There is already a thread a few hundred posts deep on this... basically, there should be 4 stars, keeping the same star award as it is currently, but adding a fourth star at 75%.

Personally I think there should also be a 5th star at 90% as well... when a 99% 2 star = a 50% 2 star... that is just stupid.
July 1st, 2015
sungirl

Quote:

Originally Posted by daddylindo

Hey callywally, i was just thinking about something you said right here. Since I should think about the welfare of other town halls as you put it, how come supercell made it UNFAIR to town hall 7's that they cannot defend against dragon attacks? You should at least be able to defend against your own town hall. The sweeper proved to be a waste of time to them. How come youre not worried about the poor th7's that don't wanna put $$$ into the game like us? Let's hear it since youre such a man of equality.

You might want to talk to your TH7s about where they should place their air sweeper because I had a TH7 in my clan who put the air sweeper in the right spot and stopped dragon attacks. I mean they would get one or two stars, but not three. :confused:
July 1st, 2015
daddylindo

Quote:

Originally Posted by sungirl

You might want to talk to your TH7s about where they should place their air sweeper because I had a TH7 in my clan who put the air sweeper in the right spot and stopped dragon attacks. I mean they would get one or two stars, but not three. :confused:

LOL.. SUNGIRL... youre so full of it. After lightning 1 air defense, that lone air defense is NOT stopping 11 dragons coming from behind the sweeper. You must think im an idiot. Im done with this convo.
July 1st, 2015
Callywally

Quote:

Originally Posted by daddylindo

Well callywally, when theres a will theres a way. They can nerf defenses a touch and make troops a touch stronger. Im thinking of the gaming experience as a whole. I want clan leaders thinking. Im not a noob so stop talking to me as such just because youre a th10 and im a th9. I know good gameplay when I see it, and I know when it's lacking. I love the game and they're doing a great job. Wars come down to stars. They don't add up percentage and award a winner. Maybe th10 doesnt need an extra XBow or the infernos being immune to heal spells. I know the freeze spell but still, Max balloons struggle against th9's, how the hell they supposed to excel against th10? I mean, 3 starring any base should be a part of the equation, why does it have to be impossible?? Come on now. I may not have best answer right now but the developers should be able to put their heads together to find the perfect medium. 2 stars shouldn't be the ultimate victory, especially 50% which only cleans half the map.

Did I ever say you were a noob? No, but as a TH10, I obviously have more experience in these matters than you.

Also, 3 starring is still extremely possible even at endgame TH10. Yes, it's rare and most go for the 2 star instead, but you act like 3 starring is quite literally impossible, which is very far from the truth.
July 1st, 2015
Callywally

Quote:

Originally Posted by daddylindo

Hey callywally, i was just thinking about something you said right here. Since I should think about the welfare of other town halls as you put it, how come supercell made it UNFAIR to town hall 7's that they cannot defend against dragon attacks? You should at least be able to defend against your own town hall. The sweeper proved to be a waste of time to them. How come youre not worried about the poor th7's that don't wanna put $$$ into the game like us? Let's hear it since youre such a man of equality.

How is it unfair?! A TH7 can easily defend against another TH7's mass drag attack with the right base design. Yes, obviously a TH7 won't have much chance vs a TH8 using mass drag, but what's different?! It's the same with all levels.

Anyways, as a TH7, it's not like you can't use the mass drag strategy yourself as well...:facepalm:

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page