No more donation by number but by elixer

I have a new idea that is not so important but it will be easier to judge how much a person donated. I think my title is wrong and is unclear so let me show what I mean.
Attachment 121922
So as you can see here, in the red circle, this guy's donation is lower than his request so the co leaders didn't want to promote him to co leader. But he donated a dragon!!! And all that he took from us was a healer!!!!! This way of measuring donation and request is unfair. So, rather then the housing space shown there should be the amount of elixer he used to donate, and the amount of elixer (troop) he took. But since there is also dark elixer, I say that the dark elixer would be like this
Troops donated: Troops received:
(elixer)+(dark elixer) (elixer)+(dark elixer)
This way of judging would be better. Plus, this would prevent any false troops count such as of a giant which is mostly donated to increase their donation ratio, but after this new update, they will not donate junks and would be willing to donate good things (even though wall breakers would increase their donation ratio with high elixer, not many people even wants to make wall breakers)
Since still people can donate wall breakers, I read someone's idea in this forum that their should be an icon, saying the information of the troop and who donated. So he can be kicked.

I just checked and it looks like you JUST took that picture. At this point in the season, I have about 1000 donations and that isn't even very high (for me, and in general). The clan in the picture simply doesn't donate that much. Don't get so hung up on who donated what to whom and your clan will become a much better place. Just donate what is requested when you see it come up. it isn't that hard. Sometimes I will end a season with 4k donations, sometimes 2k because some of the other members were beating me to it all season long. I am not bragging, just sayin that donations don't really matter as long as everyone is at least tryin to pull their weight.

Some people aren't on that much, and ONLY request for war attacks. By the end of the season, they will have like 400 troops given to them, but they have on;y donated 200. Would I rather have them NOT bring troops to war? HECK NO! I would be ♥♥♥♥♥♥ if someone didn't request before a war attack.

If your clan is getting all worked up over 20 troop spots, it might be time to find a new clan...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by herranton

I just checked and it looks like you JUST took that picture. At this point in the season, I have about 1000 donations and that isn't even very high (for me, and in general). The clan in the picture simply doesn't donate that much. Don't get so hung up on who donated what to whom and your clan will become a much better place. Just donate what is requested when you see it come up. it isn't that hard. Sometimes I will end a season with 4k donations, sometimes 2k because some of the other members were beating me to it all season long. I am not bragging, just sayin that donations don't really matter as long as everyone is at least tryin to pull their weight.

Some people aren't on that much, and ONLY request for war attacks. By the end of the season, they will have like 400 troops given to them, but they have on;y donated 200. Would I rather have them NOT bring troops to war? HECK NO! I would be ♥♥♥♥♥♥ if someone didn't request before a war attack.

If your clan is getting all worked up over 20 troop spots, it might be time to find a new clan...

---

I know, but... At that moment I only had 52 687 approx. elixer and I was the only guy at that time to donate dragons, everyone was demanding dragons and i became poor. My donation:request is 180:120 at the moment and someone in our clan known as "debottom" gave me giants and also others giants, even though we don't want it. So his donation:request became 167:49 so they were telling that he donates the most if judged by the request:donation, but not many of the clan members thought that I donated more. The only look at the housing space of the troop nothing else!!!! They are not thinking about the price of the troop!!! at first I had 1 200 000 elixer. 500 000 went to upgrading barbarians to level four, 250 000 on training dragons for war's first attack, more 250 000 for training for second attack and 367 000 elixer on donating. I got a little more elixer from the collectors, but if u don't know that if we donate in war, it is not counted in the "troops donated" so most people praise debottom!!!!!!!

My opinion is itll make the game gay. Its better with numbers and your clan is just real pricks mine dont do that

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Turibius

I know, but... At that moment I only had 52 687 approx. elixer and I was the only guy at that time to donate dragons, everyone was demanding dragons and i became poor. My donation:request is 180:120 at the moment and someone in our clan known as "debottom" gave me giants and also others giants, even though we don't want it. So his donation:request became 167:49 so they were telling that he donates the most if judged by the request:donation, but not many of the clan members thought that I donated more. The only look at the housing space of the troop nothing else!!!! They are not thinking about the price of the troop!!! at first I had 1 200 000 elixer. 500 000 went to upgrading barbarians to level four, 250 000 on training dragons for war's first attack, more 250 000 for training for second attack and 367 000 elixer on donating. I got a little more elixer from the collectors, but if u don't know that if we donate in war, it is not counted in the "troops donated" so most people praise debottom!!!!!!!

---

Well kick debottom out for donating unwanted troops. If your clan is only looking at the ratio you should really find a better clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ClashySquill

Well kick debottom out for donating unwanted troops. If your clan is only looking at the ratio you should really find a better clan.

---

yup, u heard me, he is a good player

Don't let em take advantage of you. tell people that you don't mind donating a bunch of dragons for war, but you cant keep up with giving everyone dragons for raiding. You always have the option of not filling requests too, if they get too greedy. Just do what you can.

I never feel bad about leaving a request empty (although I seem to have a psychological issue with needing to fill them). If someone request a dragon, and you are the only one with dragons, say "I'm sorry, I don't have the resources right now, can I make you some loons?"

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by herranton

Don't let em take advantage of you. tell people that you don't mind donating a bunch of dragons for war, but you cant keep up with giving everyone dragons for raiding. You always have the option of not filling requests too, if they get too greedy. Just do what you can.

I never feel bad about leaving a request empty (although I seem to have a psychological issue with needing to fill them). If someone request a dragon, and you are the only one with dragons, say "I'm sorry, I don't have the resources right now, can I make you some loons?"

---

I think I should've told u this before that, I am trying to make my clan win all the time, that is y i m forced to donate

Maybe an option to see how many of each troop that person has donated by clicking on it??

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CosmoLG

Maybe an option to see how many of each troop that person has donated by clicking on it??

---

I didn't think of an extra button, nice idea though, but, will there be enough space?