TH9 War Base - which one is better?

Hi guys,

which one is better or mby harder to attack?

Let me know what you think :o

http://i.imgur.com/fSZ5AMT.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/amGcYb4.jpg

The second one looks a little stronger - it has a little more segmentation with smaller pockets.

Second is a common war base I always see that's easy to beat, first has no dgbs hog paradise...

I'd say the first and add DGBs at the top.

They both have potential, but need work. The top one doesn't have any proper double big bomb traps and in the second they aren't great. They both need to have the cc centralized better. One of my clan mates uses a variation of the second one and it has done quite well for him.