if the trophies of A lost=the trophies of B win,where did the first trophy come from?

systeam? and how many trophies you gave us all at the early time?

Ewwww ewwww pick me pick me. Raises hand excitedly.

When you have less than 1000 trophies, you don't lose all of them in an attack. The closer you get to the 1000, the closer it gets to A=B.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rauta

When you have less than 1000 trophies, you don't lose all of them in an attack. The closer you get to the 1000, the closer it gets to A=B.

---

Well that brings up the question I believe he was trying to ask .... If you don't have 100% trophy transfer between winner and loser of an attack.what happens to the extra trophies? ... Isnt the extra trophies what causes the imbalance in matchups , in terms of more and more players complaining trophy offerings on offense and defense not making any sense?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HBCA25

Well that brings up the question I believe he was trying to ask .... If you don't have 100% trophy transfer between winner and loser of an attack.what happens to the extra trophies? ... Isnt the extra trophies what causes the imbalance in matchups , in terms of more and more players complaining trophy offerings on offense and defense not making any sense?

---

This doesn't affect the trophy offense and defense calculations. If you lose while under 1000 trophies, the full loss is not deducted from you but the winner gets the full trophies.

As for inflation of trophy points, this does work better than the normal ELO system, where each player starts with 1200 points. Inactive players do not add so many points to the system.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rauta

This doesn't affect the trophy offense and defense calculations. If you lose while under 1000 trophies, the full loss is not deducted from you but the winner gets the full trophies.

As for inflation of trophy points, this does work better than the normal ELO system, where each player starts with 1200 points. Inactive players do not add so many points to the system.

---

so who under 1000 produce new trophies，and when higher than 1000 A=B，is that right？

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lilith

so who under 1000 produce new trophies，and when higher than 1000 A=B，is that right？

---

Yep. The nearer you get to 1000 the closer A gets to B.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rauta

Yep. The nearer you get to 1000 the closer A gets to B.

---

thank you.but why you used word "nearly" all the time? when 2000 beat 2200 ,A !=B ???

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lilith

thank you.but why you used word "nearly" all the time? when 2000 beat 2200 ,A !=B ???

---

Nope, in such situation A is still B. Only affects trophies under 1000. What I mean is that at 990 trophies the A is almost the same B already.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rauta

Nope, in such situation A is still B. Only affects trophies under 1000. What I mean is that at 990 trophies the A is almost the same B already.

---

i see，thanks.

another question:

A=1000,B=2000, A beat B,3 stars, A=? B=?

A=1000,B=2000, B beat A,3 stars, A=? B=?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lilith

i see，thanks.

another question:

A=1000,B=2000, A beat B,3 stars, A=? B=?

A=1000,B=2000, B beat A,3 stars, A=? B=?

---

I think you might be looking at it wrong. You appear to be treating A as one player and B as another.

My understanding is that A is the number deducted from the loser, and B is the number added to the winner.

If the player being attacked is under 1000 trophies, then the winner might get 30 trophies, but he only loses 20.

If the player being attacked is over 1000 trophies, then the winner will get 30 trophies, and he will lose 30.

I hope that makes sense.

Cheers

Yowie

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lilith

i see，thanks.

another question:

A=1000,B=2000, A beat B,3 stars, A=? B=?

A=1000,B=2000, B beat A,3 stars, A=? B=?

---

I think it's a good question.

if player A has 1000 trophies and attacks player b who has 2000 trophies, how many trophies does he stand to win for 3 star victory, or lose for defeat.
similarly, how many trophies are on offer if b attacks a?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dpclash

I think it's a good question.

if player A has 1000 trophies and attacks player b who has 2000 trophies, how many trophies does he stand to win for 3 star victory, or lose for defeat.
similarly, how many trophies are on offer if b attacks a?

---

For 1000trophies vs 2000trophies, gain and loss of both players, regardless of who attacks, will be the same.

Basically only those who has less than 1000 trophies will get less trophies deducted.
so if you(with less than 1000 trophies) attack someone(regardless of how many trophies) and lose, he will gain more trophies than you lose. and if someone(regardless of how many trophies) attacks you(with less than 1000 trophies) and wins, you will lose less trophies than he gains.

Hope this helps.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hanjxx

For 1000trophies vs 2000trophies, gain and loss of both players, regardless of who attacks, will be the same.

Basically only those who has less than 1000 trophies will get less trophies deducted.
so if you(with less than 1000 trophies) attack someone(regardless of how many trophies) and loses, he will gain more trophies than you lose. and if someone(regardless of how many trophies) attacks you(with less than 1000 trophies) and wins, you will lose less trophies than he gains.

Hope this helps.

---

THIS IS THE ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION!

Very easy to understand. You should just close the post now. :P

I think there is more to this right now, in the sense that how is that 1000 trophy threshold determined? Is it that exactly at 1000 trophies A = B, or is it a gradual change?