Zero stars loss, 1 star draw, 2-3 stars win - my new idea

Very bad idea that would mess with everyone

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by watchamacolet

Did you know how Jorge Yao get trophies?
Because I think this makes the trophyhunting harder. But you have your proposal.
:)

---

No idea how he gets trophies. And yeah this makes trophy hunting slightly harder. But I think in a more reasonable strategic way. I don't expect everyone to agree with it. As you say just a proposal I put out there for people to think about.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by the8thark

No idea how he gets trophies. And yeah this makes trophy hunting slightly harder. But I think in a more reasonable strategic way. I don't expect everyone to agree with it. As you say just a proposal I put out there for people to think about.

---

He gets trophies by 50%. And 50% while TH9 is alot of buildings to break.

It's pretty much impossible to get to the TH on an 8+ base and still profit on elixir. This is a very bad idea. With well-defended bases, The TH is one of the last things you hit. This pretty much makes it impossible to win any trophies.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by watchamacolet

He gets trophies by 50%. And 50% while TH9 is alot of buildings to break.

---

AH this I did not know. Thanks. And I am noticing at the 1.2k trophy level more and more people are going for the 50% wins. I've even seen a few people get roughly 55% on my defence replays then retreat to conserve troops for future battles.

I suggested this based on my own (and others I know experiences). Nothing to do with the top players. But it'd make them have to earn their trophies too.

Someone actually liked my idea I proposed here in another topic and here is what he said about it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Purelink113

Yes, I agree with this, it would too easy to get more loot from the league bonus than the person you're raiding actually has. Also, that draw idea is excellent, I'm sick of people destroying non-military buildings just to get a 50% win.

---

I agree with what he said. I am sick of it too. People should have to earn their wins.

I don't agree with your idea that you will not keep the resources you've stolen if you do not got >51%? How about us farmers you farm abandoned mines and pumps? You will force us to 52% them?

Don't like it, sometimes you have to work you absolute ♥♥♥ off to get 50% against a properly defended base, for that to be counted as a draw with no trophy gain would be super lame.

If players don't like losing trophies to lots of outside buildings been destroyed - then protect some of them.

[/problem]

The only element to stars I like, which has molded on some other threads in for leagues.

1 star = existing league bonus
2 stars = 1.5x or 2x league bonus
3 stars = 2x or 4x league bonus

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Herp

I don't agree with your idea that you will not keep the resources you've stolen if you do not got >51%? How about us farmers you farm abandoned mines and pumps? You will force us to 52% them?

---

I didn't say that. You keep all the resources you farm no matter what your overall % is. My idea is purely about trophies. And how they are exchanged. A draw = zero trophies exchanged. But even in a draw or loss, you still get all the resources you farmed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by watchamacolet

He gets trophies by 50%. And 50% while TH9 is alot of buildings to break.

---

He actually got a three star on another top player. It was cool to watch.