Zero stars loss, 1 star draw, 2-3 stars win - my new idea

I have been playing and to me the whole idea of the game is to defeat the town hall and score the win. But many people are getting one star wins for 50% without even getting close to the TH. Hence I'd like to propose the following for battles.

Zero stars = Loss for the attacker. Pretty simple this.

One Star = A draw. Meaning you can't just kill the TH for an easy win. Mostly relates to farmers with non defended TH's to lose trophies. It also means you can't defend your TH and storages a lot but lose cause the enemy picks off 51% of your buildings. And in a draw, no one would win or lose any trophies.

Two or Three stars = A win for the attacker. So to win you have to get 50% + destroy the TH or destroy the lot.

This would help the issue of high level players saying it's too hard to defend against high level attacks, cause with my suggestion you can't just pick off 51% or do a TH rush to win. You have to have that 2nd star for the win.

What does everyone think about this?

[edit] For clarification. With a draw or a loss, you still keep every resource you have farmed. My idea is only about how trophies are exchanged. A draw is zero trophies exchanged, but you keep all the resource you farmed. What I said with a draw above is simply that with my proposed idea tactics would change as you could no longer cheese 50% for trophies. The attacker would have to earn their trophies with 2* or 3* it also gives leeway if you get 1* you lose nothing.

I think it's a bad idea, but that's just me

I think it's a bad idea , if 1 star will draw , then what u have to do is put ur xbows + teslas + inferno + mortar/wiz tower inside the walls n cover with more walls n just left other buildings outside , this will almost never lose ... The attacker won't win if they can't touch TH.

Indeed it is a bad idea! 1 star for draw? LOL!

So everyone wants their easy wins without working for them?
Or is there another reason for this? I don't get it. With a draw, no one loses. And you get to keep any resources you've stolen too. This just makes the game balance a little more in favour of the defender. Cause as it stands now, if you protect your TH too much, your other buildings are not well protected and you lose at 50%-60%. I just don't see the point of making the TH so special when players can simply avoid it and still win. And yes a lot of players do avoid it for the win. I know in my defence replays a few attackers do exactly this, and get their 55% for the win.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SuperJia

I think it's a bad idea , if 1 star will draw , then what u have to do is put ur xbows + teslas + inferno + mortar/wiz tower inside the walls n cover with more walls n just left other buildings outside , this will almost never lose ... The attacker won't win if they can't touch TH.

---

And that's the idea. Do that and you're ripe for the picking to be farmed for resources. Cause none of your generators or storages are not protected. So you have to make the choice.

The whole idea is that u have and proper strategy and manage to get 3 stars what happen if u make it a draw then does the attacker and defender both loose not trophies.
its a huge loss for the attacker that way.
the current gameplay fits the game properly

If this happens then it will be impossible to win as you can just place all defenses by th

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icemann

The whole idea is that u have and proper strategy and manage to get 3 stars what happen if u make it a draw then does the attacker and defender both loose not trophies.
its a huge loss for the attacker that way.
the current gameplay fits the game properly

---

Of cause it won't come cause people want their easy one star wins. And as you said yourself "The whole idea is that u have and proper strategy and manage to get 3 stars". And that does not change with my proposal. You can still farm as much resource as you always have. The only losers here are trophy farmers who farm 55% wins. They will have to work a little harder for their trophies. Oh no? Having to actually work for your trophies? It would make trophies a touch harder to get. But also make trophies more valuable. And you'd get much more satisfaction in your current league rank, knowing you really earnt your place there.

This would make it too hard to win an attack and too easy to win on defense

Did you know how Jorge Yao get trophies?
Because I think this makes the trophyhunting harder. But you have your proposal.
:)