The War "Reserves"

Okay, while this idea will not benefit me that much, it will certainly benifet new clans and low level clans.

Idea:
So...you started a clan! you have 12 people in it so far and want to take your clan into its first war. But who should be in the war?? Who is trusted to stay?

Thats where the War Reserves come in! Basically, the leader or co leader selects the normal amount of people for war, in this case 10v10.

Then, he/she chooses another 2 people. These two will be reserves, and if anyone leaves, they take their position. Their base will be placed in its correct spot, so it wont be at the top if its bad. Also, the other team knows if a reserve is being placed on.

Now, you may think that clans can abuse this idea by pulling out 2 members before war starts. therefore, the teams can see each others reserve base.

How is it going to look?
Im not gonna provide a picture, but the list of players will be shown normally, but after the last player is shown, there will be a title called reserves and the reserves are shown (in order of priority, set by the co leader or leader).

What happens if a reserve leaves?
Too bad...if he gets placed on, the team has to suck it up.

What happens if a member leaves and joins back?
If he leaves and joins back, he wont be in the war! This is to prevent spying.

How many reserves are there?

10v10: 0 or 1
15v15: 2
20v20: 3
25v25: 4
30v30: 4
35v35: 5
40v40: 5
45v45: 5
50v50: 0...well, what do you expect?

^open for changing

Ok, so a player on team left. Our clanmates have chosen what number they want to attack and now its stuffed up...what do we do?

Lets have an example. In 30v30, number 5 leaves. the reserve comes on. His base is better than 26s but worse than 25s, according to clash of clans.
All numbers from 6-25 move up one, and that reserve takes the number of 25...
The other team will be notified (maybe when they click the war button, a pop up comes, saying that a reserve came on from the other team and all numbers from 6-25 move up one spot).
This pop up can be shown unlimited times to clanmates so they dont forget.

^this is the best solution i can think of, so if you guys have any better ideas for this, tell me.

Another example:
In a 20v20, number 20 leaves, and the first reserve comes on. His base is worse than 7 but better than 8. Since the player who left is WORSE than him, all the players from 8-19 move DOWN one spot. Then the reserve takes 8.
The other team will be notified of the spot change.

Ok, im sorry if i missed any major issues, so please reply and tell me what you think and ask questions :)

Wait dont post yet! I accidently clicked the submit button on my phone

*Slow Applause*

Good job. :facepalm:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LachlanS

*Slow Applause*

Good job. :facepalm:

---

Lol i fixed it!

Im thinking right now of HOW this can be abusable... :/

This is applicable to size 20 and above. But if 10v10 I'm afraid this reserve system will be abused. Question:

If I have a composition of:
-TH10 x3
-TH9 x2
-TH8 x2
-TH7 x1
-TH6 x1
-TH5 x1
With reserves of:
-TH10 x2

If my th6 leaves, what happens? Th10 takes the place?

And speaking of this topic, I don't think it's a solution to clan hopping. It's a nice feature to have, but not to solve the particular problem.

How about u just have one reserve for every five increments based on XP. Yes if will be abused a oil but the opposing team should take the "substitution" in consideration to be successful... like a football or basketball game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by terraflare

This is applicable to size 20 and above. But if 10v10 I'm afraid this reserve system will be abused. Question:

If I have a composition of:
-TH10 x3
-TH9 x2
-TH8 x2
-TH7 x1
-TH6 x1
-TH5 x1
With reserves of:
-TH10 x2

If my th6 leaves, what happens? Th10 takes the place?

And speaking of this topic, I don't think it's a solution to clan hopping. It's a nice feature to have, but not to solve the particular problem.

---

the enemy will be able to see the th10 bases -.- and what difference does it make from having the TH6 as a sub?

Okay...10v10s NO subs

Build a better clan. That's it. :-)

This is a terrible highly abusable idea that would wreck the war if you could do this. Let me explain. If you are a 50 person clan for example, and you are doing 45 v 45 war let's say, then you can have 5 subs correct? Make the subs say, max th10s? Then have your 5 dummy th2 accounts leave, replaced with 5 max players. But the matchmaking system matched them with the th2 level to th2 level, but now those th2s on the other team have to face maybe some th6s. And the th9 people who were at the top for the enemy clan has to face max th10s! This isnt good!