Printable View
For clans that like war, waiting 24 hours may be totally un-necessary. I propose adding a flag for each fighter in war (seen within the clan) that says 'I'm ready'... so that a leader can gauge who is ready for war. Then, based upon those, the leader / co-leader can set an official WE'RE READY flag for the team. If both team's raise the WE'RE READY flag, war starts immediately.
Clans could match one another and do one war per day - too exploitable.
Your reply makes no sense. I'm just suggesting an option where if both teams who have already been match raise a flag that says they are ready for war, the war would start immediately. Yes, it would be possible for almost a war per day... but if you want to populate with castle troops, etc... it will likely just lower some of the prep times to a few hours rather than 24 hours. As for 'clans could match one another'..... that doesn't make sense.
Friend A could make a clan with 10 members level 10. Friend B could do the same. They start search at the same time. They match each other.
Both immediately raise the We're Ready Flag and then Friend A used an attack and gets three stars. No attacks happen for the rest of the war.
Friend A's clan wins! Then they repeat and get 200 wins in 205 days.
There's no guarantee they would be an exact match unless their members stayed at the same level as they grew. The likelihood of that happening is very small. I mean, really, 20 members in two separate clans maintaining the same level as people come and go, go to school, go to work, get busy on other stuff -- not going to happen. Goodness... if that were the case, you could do almost the same thing now... just double the days. Besides, how many people in Friend B's clan would want to stick around for 200 losing battles.Quote:
Originally Posted by HoopsU
Your argument doesn't really work. Surely, as with many features, you could possibly exploit them a bit, but in this case, not very much. It wouldn't be any fun.
People do this - there are one-man clans that match themselves. And the peoe in Friend B's clan would be only Friend B's ten accounts. These people don't do it for fun, they do it for fame.
100 posts!
Ok. But that doesn't make it a less valuable idea for those who aren't wasting their time for such fleeting fame. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by HoopsU
It seems that you like to make several new threads, and when others comment on why these features wouldnt work, you get defensive and come up with all the reasons your clan thinks it would. The 24 hour prep time is good how it is.Quote:
Originally Posted by hayedidnm
Yanks.... it seems you like to be negative in every thread. I made a new thread for each idea. This facilitates comments better. If you don't like the idea fine. I do. I'll put in my two cents for my ideas and dispute arguments against it -- that is why they call this a forum. I'm not being defensive... I'm just defending my idea. If I didn't think my idea had merit to begin with, I would not have posted it.Quote:
Originally Posted by yanks8981
This thread as a case in point, HoopsU points out a possible exploit. I simply pointed out that if the same thing already happens, then it's not much of a new exploit... it just means that wars can happen more frequently. Yes, some may exploit the idea [in this case, an exploit really wouldn't cause damage], other will use the feature and benefit from it. For many clans, their bases are ready and they just want to do war. Forums are good for debating in growing an idea. In one of my ideas, a user posted an alternative suggestion and my response was that I though his suggestion was a good solution to the problem. Seems to me, that you are the one being negative.
While new ideas are appreciated, this has been suggested before and the threads should be searchable.Quote:
Originally Posted by hayedidnm
I would have to agree, only way that it may be useful is if the ban on continuing another war was in effect. Thus the clan was stuck being unable to start another war for the normal 48 hours regardless of when the actual attacking started. We already have level 6 clans. We would have multiple clans at level 10 within a month or two. Then the whining threads about fact that they are unable to get farther would start. Chaos would reign and the forum would be less fun then it is now. omg no. Either way the 48 hour war would have be followed, may as well keep way it is
Sorry... I didn't understand any of that or how it related to the proposed idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rahle
Thanks for the response. :thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by Rahle
Girls, girls, you're both pretty :smirk:
But seriously, guys, I think all of us know this update won't happen. Let's just agree to disagree and settle it nicely :)
Hey, you know there's a thing called a SEARCH tool. It's used to find a thread or make sure your idea is unique. This is about as unique as a zapping thread. But either way, it would have to be the whole clan, not just the leader making the choice, in which case this feature would never be used.
FYI if multiple people say its bad, GUESS WHAT, it's probably bad....
Whatever gator. A few peoples comments over a 2 hour period doesn't make an idea bad.Quote:
Originally Posted by Flgatorboy
Rahle, I didn't understand what you were trying to say. Can you please explain.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rahle
Quote:
Originally Posted by hayedidnm
Maybe it’s because most a sick and tired of repeated request for the same thing.
Do the search before you start threads. If you can’t understand posts, quite possibly you don’t understand the complex nature of the ways this game can be played.
In short. Bad idea..Often requested. Often discounted.
Don't let them stress you Hayedidnm. There's some really snotty people on here. I've thought of that before and heard many people express the same desire.
Nice to support a fellow forumite. Bravo.Quote:
Originally Posted by Conqueror777
Outside your circle of friends, your clan and global, .... have you read about this idea on the forum, the pros and cons and understood the reasons people think this is a bad idea ?
.
"Fresh Spawn" LOLQuote:
Originally Posted by Conqueror777
The prep day is good now and waiting 24 hours is the best way before starting the war so all members know when the war will start they will not wake up and see the battle day has begin after 2h of the prep (for big clans >35)
And man that things are useless u won't die if u wait 24h before u start the war in that time u can make tactics u can see if the opponent clan have made popular bases who are 3 stared on youtube u can use the whole 24h in doing things its too short its not 1week of waiting